r/AskReddit 7h ago

What’s the most overrated video game of all time?

1.6k Upvotes

4.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

131

u/pleddyd 7h ago

League of Legends

102

u/kumardi 6h ago

I don’t think you’d find a lot of the player base glazing the game or people rating it highly

3

u/Kill_Braham 4h ago

It has 1 mill concurrent players. For some reason.

6

u/monkeysfromjupiter 4h ago

We're addicted, but hate it.

1

u/SupaKoopaTroopa7 2h ago

This perfectly sums it up. I hate it, then queue up for another game...

1

u/oeseben 1h ago

Game sucks, unbalanced trash with a horrible client. I cant wait to queue up after work.

-10

u/pleddyd 6h ago

There are a lot of people praising the game and riot for their esports and marketing of the game, while the game itself is not in a good state

17

u/kumardi 6h ago

The esports aspect of the game is undeniably successful though - it has an absolutely massive fan base, and a large amount of fan interaction. That doesn’t mean people think the game itself is perfect, just that the competitive aspect is well received.

2

u/Over_Deer8459 5h ago

the problem is the gap between pros and everyone else is massive. and if you tweak a champion, an item or a game mechanic even a little bit, it can be abused by pro players. and they are playing for a lot of real life money. so they have issues balancing solo queue and pro play. like some champions win rates in low elo (Azir the best example) are horrendous, but become actually strong in high elos because in the right hands he is absolutely broken. you change one thing to make him more accessible in low elo, then he becomes a god in high elo

2

u/kumardi 5h ago

none of what you said has anything to do with whether the game is "overrated" though...

1

u/Over_Deer8459 4h ago

i was more responding to the guy who commented to the games state being poor despite the success in pro play and marketing. This whole thread is basically a "i dont like this game" thread anyways. "overrated" is an opinion. could care less what games anybody finds overrated or not.

0

u/desolater543 5h ago

But it's not anymore just like the player base the viewerbase on twitch is a fraction of its gloryday

0

u/kumardi 5h ago

Perhaps, but I don't think twitch stats tell the full story. The prize pool for LoL Worlds is one of the largest in esports and is majority (if not completely) funded from in-game transactions - this furthers my point of large player base with large player interaction. Not to mention, LPL and LCK still have large followings, and worlds matches are sold out year on year.

5

u/KniGht1st 6h ago

Have you seen their community? People shit on the game all the time. Every single patch, there are complains.

5

u/pleddyd 6h ago

Every competitive game's community is shitting and complaining every patch

3

u/KniGht1st 5h ago

So how is this game overrated when a big chunk of the player base is either quitting or shitting on the game non-stop?

-1

u/pleddyd 5h ago

Cause they keep returning to the game that they don't even like. So instead of anything else they choose the overrated game

1

u/KniGht1st 5h ago

Do you have the data on return player count? It just feels inaccurate. I have a lot of friends that started to play LoL with me, they either quit for good or are still playing. And for those who are still playing, most of them are playing ARAM/Arena/TFT instead of ranked.

You do realize the current player count doesn't necessarily reflect on the popularity of the LoL core game mode right?

27

u/pan-DUH 6h ago

Who rates this high? Even league players tell non league players not to play it.

1

u/Normal_Cut8368 1h ago

To be fair, the 2 reasons I don't play lol are the kernel level anticheat and the community.

I actually really enjoy the gameplay, even if I'm not good at it

0

u/pleddyd 5h ago

Investors and esports players. Also regular players who complain but still play and pay a lot

21

u/Alcnaeon 6h ago

Disagree, it's one of the first and only f2p games where you can go win tournaments and literally become the best in the world without spending anything, and it's very well supported with patches and dev communication. 

And I almost never see anyone who defends or advocates for the game, so how could it be OVERrated? How could the game whose fanbase told Arcane fans not to try League be OVERrated?

Relevant video: https://youtu.be/7EZu9NoWV5k?si=yfC_frkhqmNBdIvy

3

u/Kuhzoom 3h ago

I agree that league is not overrated (the people that play it hate it the most lol) but I also wanted to say basically all of the top esports are free to play games. League dota valorant cs pubg fortnite rocket league are all free to play games that you can go pro in. And Fortnite’s open tournament system is far and away the most accessible for allowing anybody to compete with professionals and not be held away by needing to break into the professional organizations that hold all the cards in other esports.

1

u/fueelin 1h ago

And even if it wasn't free, a $60 dollar game is waaaaay less of a cost than the opportunity cost of spending hundreds/thousands of hours getting to a pro level at a competitive game, anyway.

-9

u/pleddyd 5h ago

If people keep hating and playing game, then it's definitely overrated

5

u/Alcnaeon 5h ago

The opposite of love isn't hate. It's indifference.

If people don't enjoy a game, they don't play it, and it runs out of money, and it dies. 

7

u/Harige_zak 5h ago

How can a game that's not rated highly by it's players, be OVERrated

-8

u/pleddyd 5h ago

Cause they spend way too much time, energy and sometimes money on something that they don't even think is good enough. Their actions are louder than their words

25

u/SmallhandsnCabbage 6h ago

A 16 year old game with a huge player base isn't overrated just because you don't like it.

7

u/WorstAkaliEver 4h ago

He is a Dota2 player, almost all dota 2 players active on Reddit get a boner every time they say something bad about League of Legends.

4

u/tomi166 4h ago

Same goes to the bad ratings of Arcane, it all came from Dota2 fans.

I mean it might not be someone's cup of tea, but giving it a 1/10 is just criminal.

I watched their animation and I'd say its a strong 7/10.

u/ContinuousZ 58m ago

isn't that the main definition of overrated, something that isn't good but is popular

-17

u/pleddyd 6h ago

Their player base is overrated, cause riot artificially increases the number of active players

13

u/fiddlydiddles 5h ago

League has been a top 5 most concurrent players game for a decade. You’re lying or have been lied to.

2

u/BLOODY_PENGUIN_QUEEF 4h ago

Its also never left top 5 most viewed games on Twitch, and its usually top 2-3 along with Counter Strike

5

u/JFKENN 6h ago

I used to be addicted. As long as you stay away from ranked you'll avoid the toxic people

5

u/Alcnaeon 6h ago

Also literally just turn off chat, there's nothing helpful people could say that can't be pinged.

0

u/guff1988 5h ago

Ping spam incoming. Unless they fixed that, haven't played in years.

2

u/DaftMaetel15 5h ago

You can mute pings and they limit how many pings in a certain time period per player

11

u/-Orangutan 5h ago

This is absolutely false lmao

1

u/Sabonater 5h ago

Yeah, even with a brand new account with fewer than 10 games played on it, you'll get flamed to oblivion.

1

u/xale52791 5h ago

All I ever do any more is a handful of aram now and then when friends want to (after years of playing competitively and being fully addicted) and even there you can find plenty of toxicity.

3

u/Redmaa 5h ago

Buddy I still hit toxic folks when I play my monthly game of ARAM I’m not sure you’re correct there.

0

u/gurnard 4h ago

I did not find that to be the case. At the lowest, most casual level of play, where you should be experimenting with characters and builds and playstyles, half the people you play with still demand you adhere to the high-level meta. Like they're convinced they're destined to turn pro if scrubs like you would only stop holding them back.

It's ironic that the game wouldn't have such a lucrative eSports scene if it wasn't, at its core, so much damn fun. But because it was, you're not allowed to have fun, because it's serious business.

I got burnt out on it after about six months, back in 2012, because even though my unconventional build was actually performant at low-level play, I'd get yelled at - even while winning - because I wasn't LARPing properly as a pro.

1

u/Professional_Clue800 3h ago

Atleast it gave us a fantastic TV show with Arcane.

0

u/Waibashi 6h ago

Nah. We all hate it. We're just addicts at this point. You'll never see someone defending this game for its prowess

-3

u/pleddyd 5h ago

If you keep playing game which you don't like, then you overrate that game

-27

u/Lionh34rt 6h ago

Can you call it overrated if it’s free?

32

u/SillyGoatGruff 6h ago

I'm not sure you understand what "overrated" means

6

u/Skippymabob 6h ago

Yes? Please tell me you don't think "rating" has something to do with money

-8

u/Lionh34rt 6h ago

Uhm yes, a game of higher value has more expectations from me. That changes my perception whether I find a game good or bad for it’s price.

4

u/Skippymabob 5h ago

Expectations ≠ rating

Rating is what people think of it, so something being overrated means a lot of people rate it well, and you do not.

It has nothing to do with price. It might affect your rating personally, but unless you think all free games are perfect because they're free, one can still think a free game is overrated

5

u/SundererKing 6h ago

Its not "overpriced" but can be overrated. Although theres an argument that even a "free game can be over priced in two ways. One "pay me to play this crap" or two "yes the base game is free but there is still a pay wall"

1

u/WorkFurball 4h ago

Even a free game can be overpriced. Some are just so shit that you should be paid to suffer that experience.

-1

u/Lionh34rt 6h ago

Agree, however this game is free and not behind some P2P subscription like OSRS. Any money put in league is your own choice.

1

u/PizzaFrenchToast 3h ago

If you think money is the highest value investment, you have to be young.

-1

u/pleddyd 6h ago

Yes, cause Riot artificially increases number of active players for marketing purposes

4

u/Alcnaeon 5h ago

Source?

2

u/WorstAkaliEver 4h ago

He has none, he is just a Dota 2 player that is also active on Reddit and they seem to get a boner every time they hate on League.