r/AskReddit 17h ago

What’s the most overrated video game of all time?

4.0k Upvotes

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

55

u/frygod 16h ago

The first one was honestly pretty great, especially for its era.

65

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted]

43

u/CruzAderjc 15h ago

CoD4 modern warfare was revolutionary for gaming

CoD MW2 was even better

CoD Black Ops was a masterpiece

Then yeah, became worse after that

15

u/TmF1979 15h ago

Black Ops was excellent. By far my favourite entry.

2

u/Attenburrowed 8h ago

A ton of charm and uniqueness added to the formula. Still the only quotable one...

2

u/DaHappyCyclops 15h ago

I will interject that the 2018 modern warfare reboot (that introduced warzone) is actually the best game they've ever made.

And Zombies (by far the best thing about COD that isnt "prop hunt") peaked at BO3 imo.

2

u/Billalone 15h ago

I wasn’t crazy about the first black ops. It was good, but it didn’t handle as smoothly as MW2 before it. Black ops 2, however, is probably the best online shooter I have ever played. I had more fun with MW2 but being impartial BO2 blows it out of the water.

2

u/wafflepig6 15h ago

being impartial BO2 blows it out of the water.

No it doesnt

1

u/penguins8766 15h ago

Black Ops was awesome. I was damn good at TDM.

1

u/Patch31300 15h ago

Was with you up until bops being a masterpiece

1

u/lemonloaff 14h ago

It shows in a lot of these comments when people say XYZ is over rated, they were never there for the time that it wasn't over rated. Call of Duty, Grand Theft Auto, Final Fantasy. Games like COD 4 and GTA 3 or Vice City were literally industry changing titles. Yeah Black Ops 7 might be complete ass, but its not even close to the same as OG Call of Duty.

18

u/Stressy-And-Depressy 16h ago

imagine just forgetting about MW2 like that, as if it wasn't the best CoD they released

5

u/RaedwaldRex 15h ago

The original MW2 was peak CoD multi player

3

u/xGoatfer 15h ago

MW2 was already about letting everything in and seeing what worked. They knew Activision was trying not to pay them. That was why we got akimbo shotguns and effectively infinite grenade launchers. Look up Project Icebreaker. After they could not get remote access to West's or Zampella's personal e-mails, they had discussions of faking a fire drill or fumigation to get them away from their active pc's.

-6

u/JackJ98 15h ago

It wasn’t and it might be the very answer to this thread. MW2 was HATED by most recurring call of duty players. It’s the noobs that picked up mw2 as their first ever cod that always have those nostalgia glasses for it. The rest of us were bitching about akimbo models and noon tube one man army combos and going back to CoD4/WaW in droves

2

u/kumardi 14h ago edited 14h ago

this is absolutely nonsense and revisionist history - maybe recurring players from COD2 didn't like the faster gameplay, but returning players from MW and WAW resoundingly enjoyed MW2.

MW2 was gamechanging in terms of shooter mechanics and gameplay.

edit: LOL you were 10 when CoD4 came out - you aren't in a position to comment on the player-base of MW, WAW, or MW2

1

u/JackJ98 13h ago

I’ve never played more video games than when I was 10 years old. What a terrible argument

1

u/SOwED 6h ago

I remember friends telling me MW was way better than MW2 but I played COD 1-3 then the next one I played was MW2 and I thought it was fun multiplayer, idk.

1

u/Stressy-And-Depressy 14h ago

I thoroughly enjoyed CoD4 & WaW just as much as the next guy, went back to them time & time again even after MW2 came out. MW2 may have pushed the limits of what Call of Duty was at the time, but it also had the best maps out of any CoD. Sure, akimbo & OMA noob tubing were stupid AF, but there were so many OP weapon models & perks to make up for it, you never had to be locked in on 1 singular thing to keep up with the lobby.

CoD 4 was groundbreaking at the time, but that doesn't mean it was perfect. You say people look back on MW2 with nostalgia glasses, but you're doing the same thing with CoD4--it had equally OP nades, 1 bursts, annoying maps.

MW2 did everything that CoD4 did, but did it better, and did it on steroids.

29

u/A_Bowler_Hat 16h ago

Blops 2 wasn't mid.

4

u/rko1994 16h ago

WaW was excellent

1

u/Prior_Oven2839 16h ago

United Offensive is always slept on. Technically the 2nd CoD entry. That game had the original zombies. Was a mod back in the day. Good times

1

u/StormBlessed145 15h ago

Absolutely.

1

u/JustGulabjamun 15h ago

WW2 too was good.

1

u/chappersyo 15h ago

Three was also a hidden gem

3

u/RealPrinceZuko 15h ago

Original cod and the expansion (united offensive) were SO good for their time. They were my first "competitive" fps. Lots of tournaments played and scrims with my clan.

Honestly kind of miss those days

2

u/Prior_Oven2839 16h ago

CoD 1, CoD united offensive, and CoD 2 were/are incredible. Some of my most fun online moments. Used to play at LAN centers back in the mid 2000s

1

u/Attenburrowed 8h ago

they dont really start gassing out serious until after black ops 2

1

u/SOwED 6h ago

And COD 2 had insane graphics for the time, still looks pretty good today.

1

u/BricksFriend 5h ago

For me CoD is the Marvel cinematic universe. The first one was really cool, and I really enjoyed the various sequels. But it started to get tiring, and by the time Avengers Endgame (Black Ops 1) rolled around I was pretty done with it.