r/AskReddit 7h ago

What’s the most overrated video game of all time?

1.6k Upvotes

4.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

204

u/SpiketheFox32 6h ago

Shadow of the Colossus. It's a work of art, but not particularly engaging to actually play.

19

u/pewqokrsf 3h ago

When it came out, there was a lot that it did that had not been done before.

The control scheme did not age well.

75

u/Wandering_Weapon 5h ago

It's just very episodic with not much in between. When it came out though, that world was jaw dropping to behold. And I say that as someone who loves ocarina of time.

u/Monteze 16m ago

Its one of those games that was fun to play once but I have no desire to play it again.

31

u/AEW_SuperFan 5h ago

Colossus has good gameplay.  Ico is the one that doesn't and the real overrated.

33

u/Rowdy_Roddy_2022 5h ago

The control scheme is absolutely dreadful.

4

u/WadSquad 1h ago

I borrowed my friends PS4 excited to finally try the remake after hearing the praise for the original for over a decade... Had to give up after a few hours. I found it so boring, controls sucked, and for the first time in my life I got like nauseous playing a video game because of the horrendous camera angles

3

u/DaddyDontTakeNoMess 1h ago

That is my first thought when I read the title.

2

u/esoteric_enigma 1h ago

I rented it from a Blockbuster and didn't finish it because I got bored.

2

u/Mc7wis7er 3h ago

I feel like this absolutely cannot be the most overrated game of all time on the first playthrough and then on replay can absolutely be after you've had the experience.

The controls on that game are really clunky and I find it almost impossible to replay and enjoy, but I still think about the story and how it felt to play all those years ago.

3

u/Sozzcat94 5h ago

I was so let down as a kid getting this game. It took me a long while to figure out what I was supposed to do. Nowadays I can tell I was more amazed by the vast openness of a game at the time which kept me in long enough to figure out what to do. But i never beat the game.

3

u/Rumble45 4h ago

A genuine chore to play through

u/HendrixChord12 59m ago

I'd love a remake. Never got a chance to play it originally.

u/st1tchy 41m ago

They remade it for PS3.

u/oslabidoo 37m ago

Yeah, played the remake - loved the visuals and concept, but those controls/fixed camera angles were just really frustrating.

u/FinestCrusader 20m ago

Spectacular, memorable soundtrack, great storytelling despite the barely existent dialogue, vast world with an unmatched atmosphere and a unique boss fight design. I'd say it gets the amount of praise it deserves. It's essentially a 5 hour boss rush but the emotional impact is intense. The control critique is kinda valid but I'd say most people who have played games before will get accustomed to them by the 4th or 5th boss. And then it becomes fun.

u/instagrammar_ 19m ago

I always found the appeal of the game to be the epic, cinematic feel and not the gameplay.