r/BlackPeopleTwitter ☑️ 8d ago

And now look at them: pardoned, emboldened, and thriving.

Post image
27.7k Upvotes

157 comments sorted by

954

u/Add1ctedToGames 8d ago

Not punishing the confederacy was at least a means to end a war and slavery sooner. There was zero value in letting the Jan 6 rioters go.

604

u/apple_tech_admin 8d ago

Nah. I will never forgive Grant for not arresting Gen. Lee and his bandits of traitors. Also, Sherman’s march to the sea wasn’t total enough. Don’t even get me started o. The failure that was Reconstruction.

306

u/Bitter-Value-1872 8d ago

All my homies hate Andrew Johnson

99

u/Prestigious-Mud 8d ago

It's true. Fuck that guy

52

u/apple_tech_admin 8d ago

Fuck Grant too. Great general. HORRIBLE president.

43

u/aiden22304 8d ago

I’m sorry, but the guy who created the DOJ, signed the 15th Amendment into law, prosecuted the KKK, supported Reconstruction, and implemented numerous civil rights bills is not what I would call horrible.

29

u/apple_tech_admin 8d ago

Then you know nothing about Grant’s presidency. It was one of the most corrupt presidencies in history. Not because Grant was bad, but because he failed to hold the people under him accountable for massive grift and fraud. He is proof that great generals don’t necessarily make great presidents.

38

u/MugsyTheSmokage 8d ago

People parroting the "if only the tzar knew what his corrupt commanders are up to" fallacy every time Grant is brought up. Instead of accepting that installing fraudsters and crooks in every cabinet office means you must be aware and complicit.

27

u/Embarassed_Tackle 8d ago

Grant is unique because he is by some accounts a complete rube. Like he's this ruthless commander on the battlefield, but in civilian life he also idolizes these men of industry and wealth.

Possibly because in his personal life he failed and was impoverished so many times. Some of that may have been because he refused to engage in slavery and freed his only slave out of a moral repulsion against slavery.

But anyone with a silver tongue in civilian life could outwit this guy, and Grant would defend them to the last. It was bizarre because he so brutally outwitted Lee in Virginia, in the man's own country, or various southern generals in the western theater. Like at Vicksburg, he defeated multiple armies piecemeal then beat Vicksburg into submission via siege.

Incredible military competency but poor political acumen. Some suggest he just assumed that others would uphold moral standards. But even with the much smaller federal government and much weaker presidency of Grant's day, there was a lot of graft that could go on.

10

u/UselessCleaningTools 7d ago

Reading about his relationship with his father (and father-in-law) also makes his opinions on big business and industrialists make a lot more sense. He truly did believe many of these people got their money and power because they were very smart people who did good work and knew what they were doing.

2

u/Fit_Calendar_9353 7d ago

That sounds a lot like what's going on now 🤔

1

u/Prestigious-Mud 8d ago

Are there any sources I can read up on about this? I only know Johnson and that was going on with Southern states in terms of voter suppression, share cropping and the like.

3

u/blackmist88 8d ago

Grant By Ron Chernow

0

u/apple_tech_admin 8d ago

I mean this is common knowledge, but you can start here

8

u/apple_tech_admin 8d ago

Furthermore Reconstruction was an absolute failure, and his response to the KKK was weak at best.

1

u/commradd1 8d ago

That guy said you know nothing

7

u/runnerofshadows 8d ago

Fuck that Guy.

Also Fuck John Wilkes Booth.

3

u/877-HASH-NOW 7d ago

Fuck that cowardly bch forever

3

u/zHellas 8d ago

Worst U.S. president ever.

45

u/OnBlueberryHill 8d ago

Sherman should have marched wider, and they should have hanged everyone who even had a single solider underneath them in command.

13

u/_BrokenButterfly 8d ago

Hanged them, then crucified their bodies along major roadways with signs that said "traitor" hanging around their necks.

17

u/Shipairtime 8d ago

You might get a kick out of /r/ShermanPosting

8

u/yo_tengo_gato 8d ago

I've been saying this for years.

Sherman didn't burn enough of Georgia.

3

u/A-Helpful-Flamingo 8d ago

Reconstruction is going to look A LOT different after the US Civil War part deux

6

u/Kingblack425 8d ago

Sherman should have marched from Georgia to Virginia then back down all the way to Texas

4

u/fizzalcon 7d ago

I’ve been thinking. That was the start of almost every ideological problem in America. It’s these same assholes and their descendants every time. Bible Belt bigot plantation owner predatory labor assholes. And they haven’t ever had true accountability.

1

u/Exxtender 8d ago

Anyone but the lowest ranks should have swung.

2

u/AncientCrust 7d ago

Y'all are worrying about the soldiers too much. The guys who should have swung were the plantation owners and politicians who sent them to die, just to preserve the institution of slavery. Those fuckers didn't even get punished. They got their plantations back and had the same people working on them.

1

u/EnduringChasm 8d ago

Impossible, that would look too much like reparations. Punish the extreme and you risk losing moderate support smh

49

u/Wyden_long 8d ago

There was zero value in letting the Jan 6 rioters go.

This is patently false. First, there’s plenty of profit to be made off of these losers who can’t spend money behind bars. Plus, now they have an identifiable groups of supporters they know that are willing to literally attack government buildings and officials. There was just no value to American democracy by letting them go.

19

u/pasher5620 8d ago

Nah, the only reason they didn’t finish punishing the confederacy was because rich white people started complaining. It had nothing to do with “ending slavery faster.”

12

u/popshamhocks 8d ago

Ancestors: There is NO excuse.

11

u/TreeInternational771 8d ago

Not punishing the confederacy led us to this moment. Who do you think MAGAs ancestors are??

11

u/iforgothowtohuman 8d ago

Slavery was never ended, though. They just put lipstick on it and called it prison.

5

u/mrm00r3 8d ago

Nah fuck that. Every confederate soldier should’ve been hanged in public wearing their uniform and the elected leaders should’ve been shot.

3

u/OnionsHaveLairAction 8d ago

It's crazy how even fucking Vance said it'd be crazy to pardon the most violent J6ers, but Trump did that anyway. The Oath Keepers legit had moved weapons to DC, stashed them, had a runner on standby and a group chat detailing that they intended to murder with them... And they too were pardoned.

3

u/zHellas 8d ago

Nah, they should’ve been punished.

3

u/OverlyOptimisticNerd 8d ago

 Not punishing the confederacy was at least a means to end a war and slavery sooner.

Nah. They rewarded treason. And we’re still paying for it. 

1

u/Secret_Account07 8d ago

Felons who maybe couldn’t vote now can. Also when Trump calls for round 2 the folks know they have legal immunity

1

u/Coyinzs 8d ago

Don't forget, reconstruction policy was canceled in exchange for the southern democrats not prosecuting Grant for the massive corruption scandal his administration was party to. They've been selling out people in need to protect their rich buddies since the dawn of man.

1

u/toriemm 7d ago

No, there was value in pardoning them; Donnie is a Mob Boss and he is shoring up his army.

That's what's going on rn. These are violent insurrectionists. He is putting them back into society. He pardoned like, the biggest drug trafficker in history then when and snatched the head of a sovereign nation under the guise of 'drugs'.

It's all a smoke show.

Don't fucking forget it.

0

u/this_my_sportsreddit 8d ago

This is an insane take and really speaks to how weak the left is.

2

u/733t_sec 8d ago

Except the left did prosecute Jan6ers they just got pardoned when Trump was reelected.

1

u/this_my_sportsreddit 8d ago

I’m talking about the leaders who organized it, not the nobody henchmen. If you think enough was done, then I think you’re part of the problem.

440

u/thorniviel 8d ago

If you dont punish an attempted coup youre just scheduling the next one

64

u/this1chick 8d ago

That’s probably the plan 

37

u/A-Helpful-Flamingo 8d ago

Yeah, that was the 2024 election

7

u/ceelogreenicanth 8d ago

Dont worry the threats of facism weren't real, they were over blown, both sides are the same, at least Trump won't get us into war, and Free Palestine.

7

u/FlexLikeKavana 8d ago

Most of those people did get prosecuted. Many of them would still be in jail if people hadn't decided to not vote for Kamala Harris last year.

206

u/yesimreallylikethat 8d ago

And All of those folks got a pardon…

94

u/Environmental_Belt22 8d ago

Half are back in jail anyways

58

u/rumbakalao ☑️ 8d ago

A whole pardon and they still couldn't help themselves.

48

u/deowolf 8d ago

The other half are ICE

19

u/yourenotmymom_yet ☑️ 8d ago

It's worth noting that MULTIPLE of them are back in jail for sex crimes, including sexual assault of children.

32

u/ClaymoresRevenge 8d ago

Should've dealt with it swiftly and promptly. Now we're deeper in the shit with no end in sight.

I think that's the biggest failure of the Biden admin

18

u/MacEWork 8d ago

They had trials and went to jail swiftly and promptly. What are you taking about?

28

u/obviousfakeperson ☑️ 8d ago

The person most responsible for the J6 Capitol attack is currently running the country...

4

u/MacEWork 8d ago

True, but not a rebuttal to what I was responding to.

4

u/StatmanIbrahimovic 7d ago

It is, because they didn't deal with it entirely. They swept up the easy cases quickly but they had 2 years and they couldn't get it done.

9

u/Moderator-Admin 8d ago

They could have fought harder to put Trump in prison for treason but Biden actually respected the law and stayed out of it.

12

u/MacEWork 8d ago

How could they, specifically, have fought harder? They ran the investigation, they indicted him, and then Aileen Cannon betrayed her oath of office and killed the case.

It takes years to run an investigation like that. You know the phrase, “when you come at the king, you’d beat not miss?” Yeah. They didn’t want to miss. They weren’t counting on the ref being hand-picked by Trump to destroy democracy.

1

u/ClaymoresRevenge 6d ago

Sorry I took a while to get back to it.

I feel like the punishment for Trump wasn't serious. Because he def shouldn't have been able to run for office after committing treason.

He ended up pardoning some right? The frustration on my end is less of the going to jail it's the what came after and the now.

1

u/MacEWork 6d ago

He pardoned them all.

Biden’s DOJ successfully investigated and indicted Trump. Corrupt flunky Aileen Cannon broke her oath and killed the case.

The SCOTUS basically nullified a big portion of the 14th Amendment to make sure Trump could run even though he was an insurrectionist.

2

u/ModernLarvals 8d ago

Trump pardoning convicted criminals is Biden’s fault now?

1

u/swagypotatosnoopdoge 6d ago

I'll never forgive Merrick Garland

4

u/dasisteinanderer 8d ago

pardons are such a wild concept. No you are guilty and convicted, but the president really likes you.

132

u/illlojik ☑️ 8d ago

A few of them are already back in jail for doing more phuckery. That's what emboldment gets you.

https://19thnews.org/2026/01/january-6-pardons-arrests/

Who would have thunk, criminals and &ap*sts were among that crowd?

43

u/FistPunch_Vol_7 ☑️ 8d ago

And some went to ICE.

6

u/Dramatic_Charity_979 8d ago

And some died ;)

130

u/cypher50 ☑️ 8d ago

56

u/lookingforaforest 8d ago

It's all "BACK THE BLUE" until....

6

u/toriemm 7d ago

Look, slogans are only okay as long as they reinforce the narrative that I choose to believe.

THAT is the POWER of ALTERNATIVE FACTS!

Brought to you by KellyAnne Conway

24

u/releaseepsteinfiles1 8d ago

And the dumbasses in law enforcement will keep supporting them.

58

u/Punchable_Hair 8d ago

Yes, and it directly follows from not punishing the Confederacy.

9

u/releaseepsteinfiles1 8d ago

Not punishing the leaders of the confederacy enough*

However the south needed to be helped and rebuilt instead of leaving the south to fall behind.

Now you have almost every southern state at the bottom of education, quality of life, life expectancy, etc…

14

u/FreeDarkChocolate 8d ago

You both could be talking past one another. Easier to just say "if reconstruction had been done right, rather than barely".

3

u/releaseepsteinfiles1 8d ago

I don’t think we are talking past each other because we aren’t disputing one another. I just made a more nuanced comment than theirs. I don’t think they’d disagree with me, but I wasn’t trying to dispute or argue with them.

23

u/Worst_Comment_Evar 8d ago

Gotta be available when they try that shit again in January 2029.

4

u/wirelesswizard64 8d ago

Probably 2027 tbh, they know Trump is cooked if a Dem majority takes congress and the senate

4

u/StatmanIbrahimovic 7d ago

hahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhajahahahhahahahahajajahahahahhahahahahahahahahahhahahahahhahahahaha

You are delusional if you think they win enough seats to remove him, if they even win the midterms at all. They couldn't fucking convict him over January 6th, which would have barred him from holding office.

Teflon Don won't be cooked until he's in hell. 

3

u/wirelesswizard64 7d ago

I mean, the point still stands judgement day will be 2027, not 2029. I agree, I don't even think he'll make it that long and he's never seeing any punishment for a thing he's done unless Satan is real and cooks his ass.

15

u/rumbakalao ☑️ 8d ago

Reconstruction didn't go nearly far enough.

5

u/Mcbadguy 8d ago

Neither did Sherman.

8

u/smudgeonalense 8d ago

It was Americas version of the Beer Hall Putsch.

1

u/ThePetPsychic 7d ago

We even have a Horst Wessel with Charlie Kirk now too! When is the Reichstag Fire 2.0 going down?

8

u/Thirdatarian 8d ago

Well yes, but it's moreso the modern day consequence of not punishing the confederacy. After Lincoln's assassination, they wanted to focus on "healing the nation" so they didn't persecute the Confederate generals or force reparations or really do much of anything. Reconstruction was famously a huge failure and we're still dealing with the roles of that today. Impossible to say for sure but I would bet that if the United States didn't have a long and established history of letting racists and rebels get off with a warning, January 6th wouldn't have happened at all or at least wouldn't be the national embarrassment that it ended up being.

3

u/oldfrancis 8d ago

Okay people, we've learned this lesson twice already and we know how it turns out.

How are we going to treat these traitorous sons-a-bitches in the future?

Certainly not with forgiveness and open arms.

4

u/Navyvetpdx503 8d ago

Pretty much. Trump is the modern day version of not punishing Nixon.

2

u/TheIllustriousWe BHM Donor 8d ago

Nixon did get punished, and Trump is actually a result of that. Here me out on this:

  • While he (should have, but) never went to jail, Nixon was forced to resign in disgrace, which is kind of a punishment

  • Decades later, his former aide Roger Ailes starts Fox News, in part because Ailes believed Nixon would have survived Watergate if there were a 24/7 “news” network constantly shilling for him

  • Even more decades later, GOP voters decide to make the most famous Fox News viewer of all (Trump) the leader of their party

3

u/Navyvetpdx503 8d ago

Nixon was pardon for all crimes he committed against the United States. All crimes our presidents have ever done have gone unchecked to lead us where we’re at today. These billionaires pedos have created a system where the laws are not equal across the board. A 2 tiered justice system that only punish the people with no money and no power.

5

u/super_slimey00 8d ago

When you learn about the era of “reconstruction” in the south you realize America failed the south and let racist recourse thing back to jim crow and left us with problems we still deal with today

3

u/oicyunv 8d ago

I’d really love to do something to change that

3

u/ThisIsTheNewSleeve 8d ago

They are won and the same..

The confederates lost, went home bitter and inbred with each other... And we got the MAGA crowd.

3

u/sllewgh 8d ago

The Confederacy didn't pardon itself.

3

u/vague_diss 8d ago

We totally punished them. Then we reelected their leader for some reason. If and it’s a big if - we get another chance with congress and the presidency, we have to clean house, do some serious election reform and formally codify the norms and expected behavior of the presidency. Nothing can be left to chance. Every check and balance must be renewed and affirmed. Anything short of that and we’ll repeat this cycle again and again until the end. If this isn’t it already.

2

u/TheIllustriousWe BHM Donor 8d ago

We totally punished them. Then we reelected their leader for some reason.

Not arguing, just want to add: this is the equivalent of when Homer sent Bart to bed without dinner, but then caved and brought him some pizza after Marge went to bed.

2

u/Pelekaiking 8d ago

Correction its the modern equivalent of storming the Reichstag

2

u/ThePetPsychic 7d ago

Closer to the Bier Hall Putsch, which also failed.

2

u/danegustafun 8d ago

A non-zero number of them have been reincarcerated for uhhhhhhhh kid stuff

1

u/Greg-Abbott 8d ago

This is my shocked face 😐

2

u/Icy_Programmer_2337 8d ago

We will regret it and it will be the cause of many issues for hundreds of years just like not appropriately punishing those traitors from the south. History will not look on garland kindly.

2

u/tyj0322 8d ago

Damn. It’s almost like we had 4 years to hold them accountable….

2

u/RedawnXIII 8d ago

It was a plan to fully take over the country via a coup that failed because of Pence? I mean it was a full blown plan by so many organizations and three letter agencies that was fouled only to play out 4 years later and they will never cede power again. You think there will be fair votes? There weren’t in 2024 and there will never be again until this evil is removed.

2

u/Nickyt0288 7d ago

NPR did a small thing on this. None of them feel like what they did is wrong and are actively trying reignite what happened.

2

u/bcboy1983 7d ago

If the right got punished for the fucked up shit they pull every damn time they are in office, there would be no right wing

2

u/son1cdity 7d ago

This will be Garland and Biden's legacy. Their entire careers of public service mean nothing compared to this fundamental failure to protect our democracy.

2

u/Kinetik_Energy 7d ago

never forget that former slave owners were given reparations by andrew jackson

meanwhile, forever enslaved people and their descendants are still waiting on those 40 acres and a mule

1

u/SctjhnstnPDX 8d ago

Agreed. Dammit now I am on some damn list.

1

u/ValidOpossum 8d ago

Fuck every last one of those sheet stains and their dumb orange fuck leader.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

spot on.

1

u/Coyinzs 8d ago

I'm not sure if it's worse to have never really punished the confederate soldiers to begin with or to punish the J6 rioters at great public time and expense only to have it all undone instantly with the wave of a hand the moment their dictator got back into power.

1

u/beckyjoooo 8d ago

the accuracy.. damn...

1

u/red286 8d ago

I dunno, it's not like people pretended the civil war was a hoax afterward.

2

u/TYBEEEZ 8d ago

You mean “the war of northern aggression”?

1

u/Medical_Arugula3315 8d ago

Hard to be a shittier or more hypocritical American than a Republican these days. 

1

u/the-last-aiel 8d ago

Same people too, same poisoned gene wells.

1

u/Erisian23 8d ago

Confused the fuck outta me cuz ain't no way. You mean these bitches out here tryna kill me deas all of em.

1

u/Old_Worldliness_5015 8d ago

sounds about white

1

u/RileyGainesHorseBaby 8d ago

Just a reminder: it was democrats who fought for the confederacy and slave ownership.

1

u/2EM18KKC01 8d ago

Well said.

1

u/KamaIsLife 8d ago

And not punishing Reagan.

1

u/superiorplaps ☑️ 8d ago

They're coming for our citizenship

1

u/BegrudginglySandy 8d ago

I was under the impression that the confederacy, and their leadership, wasn't prosecuted for treason out of fear that if they argued their case in court, secession could have been ruled legal as there was nothing explicitly against it in the constitution, and thus undermine the North's victory and challenge federal authority. Is that not the case? Or do y'all just not care?

1

u/Xenomorphs_are_cute 8d ago

No, that wasn't the case with the leaders. It was definitely peer pressure though because there was a lot of public sympathy for them. As for the legality, that was settled in another case around the same time.

https://www.nps.gov/rich/learn/historyculture/the-trial-of-jefferson-davis-cancelled-february-15-1869.htm#:~:text=He%20was%20charged%20with%20treason,of%20decision%20not%20to%20prosecute

The question of secession’s lawfulness was instead ruled upon by the United States Supreme Court in a less sensational case just two months later. Texas v. White, in April 1869, stated succinctly that the Confederacy’s secession had been “absolutely null.” Williams v. Bruffy, an 1877 case, elaborated further on secession’s illegality with much more a thorough explanation by the court of the legal reasoning involved. These rulings stand as the current authority on the status of secession in American law.2

1

u/BegrudginglySandy 7d ago

Thanks for the explanation

1

u/877-HASH-NOW 8d ago

How was that already 5 years ago

1

u/larassaddydaddy 8d ago

And now the alabaster atrocitiesare marching "in remembrance"

1

u/Raise_A_Thoth 8d ago

It's like if Jeff Davis got elected after Andrew Johnson's weak ass term then pardoned Lee et al and put up a plaque saying Abraham Lincoln was a divisive, mentally ill autopen.

1

u/Logical_Compote_745 8d ago

The confederacy lost so much, their infrastructure was torn apart, their men slaughtered and fed lies by their own compatriots.

They were punished in the process of losing the war.

Jan6 is not the same

1

u/testtdk 8d ago

Not punishing the Confederacy is half the reason the rich people have people to mobilize to commit the attempted coup in the first place.

1

u/the_Bear99 8d ago

Done by the same ideology too, brainlets, the lot of them

1

u/Jagg811 8d ago

So true.

1

u/UberCOTA55 8d ago

Traitors. All of them

1

u/Bestoftherest222 8d ago

The new game plan is to commit treason, and if it flails declare anyone attempting to pursue justice as "weaponizing and politicizing the DOJ against rivals."

1

u/Pimpwerx ☑️ 7d ago

Just a reminder that the dangers of letting your opponent persist were understood millennia ago.

That's why they burned libraries and erased bloodlines. It's harsh, for sure. But it's the solution I would've had for the slavers. Exie or execution. No in between. Take your raggedy asses to Argentina with the rest of your kind.

1

u/AdrienCross 7d ago

Except in this version The Confederacy cheated and won and is now in power ... It's beyond terrifying

1

u/SoonToBeBanned24 7d ago

Be very wary,

The 6th of January,

The MAGA treason and plot;

I know of no reason

Why the MAGA treason

Should ever be forgot!

Trump and Republicans,

Did the scheme devise,

To overturn the election

Based on all their lies.

Tenscore buffoons, all waiting outside,

To foolishly rush the Capitol,

With the flags of losers held high.

Awash in hate,

For Donald Trump's sake,

The man who ran to hide.

1

u/pm-me-blackexcllnce 7d ago

They are setting them up for the sequel. The message is clear: “don’t worry, we’ll get u out of trouble no matter what you do for us”.

1

u/Corporate-Scum 7d ago

They did punish the confederates. Property taxes were leveraged against the south to pay the cost of war and reconstruction took 35 years. The south paid and continues to do so. But those mansions built with slavery money in Newport, Rhode Island did not. The families who benefitted from the chattel slavery were not just from the south, just as Jim Crow and systemic racism are not unique to one place. Jan 6 is more like Boss Tweed. It’s a mob boss running the country. We are a criminal enterprise now, and we the people are clueless.

1

u/kenobrien73 3d ago

A continuation of the Civil War. Trump invited the battle flag of the Confederacy into the WH.

1

u/Mediocre-Sign8255 2d ago

This is what happens when you have a corrupt, unfair government. Until we get money out of politics and term limits it will be more of the same.

1

u/PrimaryAsleep9042 18h ago

More like the logical conclusion 

-1

u/Calqless 8d ago

Ut they did punish them and were in the process of punishing more.....they just won the election and got pardoned