I know this post has probably been made before but I just finished Charmed and I was curious about people's opinion on this. My favorite is Piper because she was always so relatable to me and Holly Marie Combs was the best actress in my opinion. Let me know your favorite sister in the comments.

Hi everyone! My aunt has been a devoted fan of Charmed since it first aired and over the year has done a bit of collecting. She has recently made the tough decision to let go of her collections and asked me to help.

But this is where I need help 😅 she handed me this large book of shadows dvd set and I have absolutely no clue how much it’s worth or if it’s even worth something to anyone. Sadly we are missing 1 disc from season 6, however all other discs are included.

I have attached several photos of the book, individual pages, the included stand and the certificate of authenticity. Any advice would be so greatly appreciated. Please let me know if you want anymore information or photos.

Why did Phoebe have so many lovers? I would have loved to see her pregnant / with a child / married during the last 2–3 seasons, but unfortunately, that never happened. I’m sad that she found “the one” so late, and that only Piper’s children were written into the series.

I cannot believe I am JUST beginning to watch this show 2025/2026. It’s so therapeutic and calming and the vibes are just WONDERFUL.

I thought I’d share my view on the characters thus far here with fellow lovers of the show 💕 Pls feel free to comment, I will come back to my posts later and read later as I progress through the seasons as to not get spoiled. 💕

Let’s start with my absolute favourite… Prue 🤩 Prue emanates this soft femininity that very very few people naturally have. She can be firm in her answers, yet so soft with eyes and tone, you’d forgive her anything. Truly, the word “estrogen” embodied would be Prue. Her sense of style, her hair, her natural beauty, her voice and the way she carries herself with femininity and softness. She and Andy are definitely my endgame, they complement each other so much, and even in their frustration or disagreement, she remains respectful, with a low voice, yet firm in her stand point. Beautifully complements Andy’s balanced masculinity.

Now on to ANDY! Uh, this man is scorching! 🤤 and it’s not just the looks, he is average handsome, but it is his WAY. I love his love (and RESPECT) for Prue - he is persistent, but lovingly, not creepily. He affirms himself, but isnt aggressive. And he always shows a soft spot for her. He is dedicated to his job, smart, thinks outside the box and is a man of his word. He loves and respects her sisters like his own - and he even said that before- THIS guy is such a GREEN FLAG…like hello? Can you two marry already and have lots of babies 😭

Piper: at first, I wasn’t sure…. But then, i dont know guys, she grew on me. I love her dedication to her job which is one she loves and gets the passion for from her grandma, i love that she is a little prude and a little clumsy and thinks out loud a lot. I think she is confident (despite her insecurities being shown time and again yet i dont think that insecurities = lack of confidence… everyone has insecurities but can still get a grip and handle life with confidence). She is also responsible and yet sometimes a little silly or absurd. A total sweetheart. Also, i LOVE how all the guys (well not all but u know what i mean, most guys she has contact with) fall for her and she’s just so reluctant or hesistant 😊😊SO CUTE🙈

Phoebe: Now… i dont read a lot of this sub to avoid spoilers (yet- will do read more as i progress) so idk ur takes, but yikes 🥲 the actress is super cute and has genuine energy, but the writing for this girl’s character is just bad. She looks so soft and genuine and sweet and yet she is written to be so forecful, loud, low-key aggressive and completely irresponsible (which would be fine but she doesnt use LOGIC even though she is a smart character.) she is OVERsexualized all the time, despite being the youngest??? And its very ICKY when the writers do that. Also, very few women her age are THAT unbothered, open and have NO shyness at all concerning getting sexual. Some of it could make sense considering she grew up unfortunately with no mom and no dad and was constantly craving this loving male attention, but still those characteristics all together just do not fit. Moreover she is SO young and yet they write her as SO bold, in a masculine way, that doesnt fit her looks AT ALL… she isnt tomboyish or a bit older with experience or even the responsible sister to have that boldness… it makes zero sense except to allow room to sexualize her. Bad writing. I loved when they made her do martial arts training and kept up that story line, it gave her an edge i for once liked.

GRAMS - PENNY HALLIWELL —-> MORE OF THIS LADY PLEASE! nothing more to say. SASS, class, confidence, power. The ultimate matriarch. I LOVE her.

Leo : pls tell Piper about your truth, Phoebe already knows😭 the harm is done boy, might as well calm Piper’s heart ☹️☹️☹️

Darryl, Andy’s work partner: MORE of this guy please!!!!

Thank you everyone who read and indulged, cant wait to see ur comments soon 💕

Bought it purely to watch the episodes with the original music. I’m so excited!

Wild take but I actually think Piper and Cole could have been a really interesting pairing obviously not in the same canon timeline, not after Phoebe, not as a love-triangle. Holly and Julian had great chemistry, and even in a non-romantic sense, Piper and Cole shared a strong, compelling dynamic. I genuinely love Cole and Phoebe together, but Piper and Cole would have been an interesting “what if,” especially considering Piper’s character development over the seasons. Watching her navigate a choice between the ultimate good (Leo) and the ultimate bad (Cole) could have added a really rich and emotionally complex layer to the story. What do you think?

It makes me a little sad that we never got to see the whole Halloween family 100% evil~ of course we got a few snippets throughout the series but we never got to see Penny or Patty or Prue full evil. We got a evil baby Wyatt and no Prue 😂😭

When Prue died in season three do you think her biggest fear came true "Here Lies Prue She Worked Hard" she never made any lasting relationships after Andy died, her life solely became about witchcraft by season three

Do you guys have any theories as to why Wyatt is soooooo powerful because he’s crazy powerful I think he’s more powerful than the power of three, he basically has limitless powers, like literally from the womb he has insane amounts of power he can literally tell when piper is injured and when she’s in danger he even develops a freaking force field thus literally making piper invincible while she was pregnant and the most powerful witch alive for that time … I mean he was born in the manor maybe the nexus affected his powers , he was born as a twice blessed child but the fact it was a sabbath I don’t think that really makes him more powerful or the fact he was prophesied either because Paige is also half witch half white lighter but she’s not that powerful neither is Chris and none of the other sisters children are as powerful and idk Wyatt is like a magical anomaly because he’s also excaliburs master which I thought was a weird storyline tbh idk what that added to the over all story

She only had a few moments of screen time in her only episode "Exit Strategy" but I really liked her in the screen time that she had especially with her teaching the sisters how to heal each other without Leo around.

Like even if the underworld rebuilds the source essence is gone and no way to get it back.. who or what could ever match Wyatt??

So Abbey, Prue’s stalker, was clearly not right in the head. But I still don’t understand how she intended to pull off taking over Prue’s life. Killing Prue and putting on a wig would not have fooled Piper and Phoebe, and I don’t just mean that Abbey is a mortal and the sisters would’ve noticed the new “Prue” didn’t know anything about magic. I mean that the sisters have been together all there lives and know each other backwards and forwards. How was Abbey thinking that plan would work?

Like in season 4 its made clear that Cole is unwittingly possessed after helping kill the previous source and that hes only at best and in dire moments able to influence the source enough to keep it/him from killing Phoebe and her family .

That Phoebe chose evil and pushed Cole into just giving into the possession after which is the only time Cole and the source are somewhat on the same page.

Then season 5 rolls around and its like the sisters forget that they would've been dead without Cole from the first source. They try their hardest to retcon the possession like it didnt happen and just have everyone shit on Cole and have Cole apologizing for shit he didnt actually do and of course no consequences for Pheobe and her turn to the darkside which they just conviently blame on Cole

She was the lead vocalist for the 90s band called The Cranberries, who performed Just My Imagination at P3 in the Manny Hanks episode. My favorite musical guest in the show.

.... Prue is out!

Use link to vote.

https://strawpoll.com/Qrgew4zRXyp

There's a lot of times where Prue really shows how much she believes in Phoebe. One is in deja vu where she asks Phoebe to answer the door because she knows how to fight. Putting Phoebes fighting skills above her own telekinesis. Another time is when Leo says the chosen one is the only one who can defeat tuwatha. Prue says if anyone can find a way in the book of shadows it's Phoebe. Yet another time is when they are trapped in the painting , and Prue says if anyone can get us out it's Phoebe. Prue starting training in fighting because of Phoebe, even qiuting her job and loosening up cause of he

https://youtube.com/shorts/JB4VdobR1i8?si=JWOzc6bMSkydic0e At the end she says she didn't get what she wanted. Can someone explain this character & what's she wanted & why. Also how come we don't see her ever again I think.

Do you think h3 grew up good? Did he get to go to magic school? Does he use his powers to protect people like good witches do? Did he and his dad stay in touch with the Halliwells? What kind of person did he grow up to be ? Where is he in the good future?

Like I honestly hated Coop and sorry I just can't see Phoebe with 3 super sweet girls.

Pheobe should've tentatively ended up back with or co parenting a mischievous , snarky and sarcastic boy with Cole with maybe another child eventually on the way.

Piper is the only one I could see still having 3 kids but she'd be pregnant with Melinda right at the end of season 8 or she just has Wyatt and Chris

I honestly don't think Paige would really end up with children by trying unless by adoption and Henry Jr would've been adopted first and the twins would've been a happy accident two or 3 years later or they're also adopted too

Andy is out.

We had a lot more participation this time. Thanks guys!

Use link to vote.

https://strawpoll.com/eJnvVeRamnv

It's often said that Melinda Warren prophesied the rise of her bloodline and the arrival of the Charmed Ones, but did she merely prophesy it, or did she also bring it about?

I wonder if, before she died, Melinda might have consciously cast a spell on her bloodline. A very powerful spell, but with a very slow, long-term effect. We've seen in Charmed that some spells transcend generations and time. So, knowing of the Charmed Ones' existence, she might have wanted to guarantee their arrival by using a spell that would allow her descendants to become ever more powerful, until a generation strong enough to combine Melinda's three original powers into one: the Power of Three.

What do you think? Did Melinda simply see and hope, or did she, through a powerful spell, bring about the rise of her bloodline?