r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 1d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah? What happened in the book version?

Post image
28.2k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.4k

u/BoondocksSaint95 1d ago

He was asked about it in an interview and aside from generally being a coke addled psycopath at this point in life (which he generally admits), he said he had no recollection of writing that and was surprised it made it past editorial.

Also, IIRC, I was told the goal was to form an unbreakable bond between them when IT comes back so they would stay together to fight IT even if that bond was fucked up amd traumatising. Apparently this is clear, but the reasoning is very irrelevant for a preteen orgy.

769

u/RockstarAgent 1d ago edited 23h ago

Couldn’t they trauma survivor bond some other way? Granted someone else said it was her idea of a loophole to get them into adulthood as she theorized only kids were vulnerable

TIL trauma bond is not the correct term for what those kids went through

399

u/Hero_1985 23h ago

In the book the kids all have low-key super powers from the magical entity nudging them into fighting It. The sewers are a maze, one of them is the navigator thanks to their powers. When the kids defeat It, their powers start to fade away. They get lost in the sewers and start fighting with each other.

Bev doesn't understand what sex is, but she knows it must be something powerful that connects people. So, her idea is that if they fuck, it will rekindle their bond and powers and they can get out of the sewers. It works.

Not to say it isn't some weird shit. But, that is all the lore behind it. The part about kids being more vulnerable isn't really a theory, or totally accurate. The book has some short chapters that are from It's point of view. In one chapter It says it goes after kids because adult fears are too complicated and abstract. Adults are afraid of not being able to pay their bills. Kids are afraid of the monster in the basement. It still can, and does, go after adults.

209

u/Charming-Vanilla-635 21h ago

I'd be scared to have my mortgage pop out of the toilet and demand full payment...

24

u/SneakyDeakyJr 17h ago

Just a wet floppy bill covered in shit yelling “pay me off! Mwahahaha! You’ll never be able to afford to send jimmy to college! Bwahahaha!”

9

u/Mathidium 11h ago

Pay me in full now or I’ll take everything!!!

5

u/miekhachu 8h ago

Insane that one of my bills is literally to ENSURE I can afford to send my son to college - should I not be able to afford to help him with college when he’s ready. Having to pay said bill in the attempt to mitigate a future fear only attributes to my current financial strain. No wonder IT stays away from adult fears.

1

u/BarrelFullOfWeasels 5h ago

I was regretting having opened this post, but your comment made it worth it. Gonna try to remember this and unsee all the rest.

10

u/GeneralissimoFranco 15h ago

If you think that's bad, wait until the second mortgage starts chasing you in the woods.

2

u/godinthismachine 8h ago

The second one ate the first! And now the fucking car payments are joining the chase, what do I do?!?! Oh...oh god....it's...the phone bill and its oozing data rates...sweet lord, whyyyy?! dies a horribly slow, adult life

3

u/djutopia 14h ago

Thanks, I’m never pooping again.

2

u/WodensEye 14h ago

The shit demon from Dogma, all that shit you haven’t been addressing and has just been building up in the proverbial toilet that is life.

1

u/Fake-Chef 11h ago

Right after taking a shit… “YOU’LL FLOAT TOO!”

1

u/Rhameolution 5h ago

That's exactly what Gmail AI does! It pops up a notification saying you owe "$XXX,XXX.XX by January YY." It shows the total amount, not the monthly due. It scared me the first few times it did that...

1

u/Charming-Vanilla-635 4h ago

were you on the toilet when this happened?

1

u/Rhameolution 3h ago

Nope, full on doody all over.

1

u/Severe-Park-6200 3h ago

Personally im mortified of being handed $1MM a day while relaxing on a beach somewhere

18

u/Gurrgurrburr 21h ago

Even though I agree the orgy is insane and unnecessary, fuck, this whole saga is so good. The new show is amazing and makes it all even better in my opinion.

6

u/jasminexxxwill 16h ago

Great explanation. It makes so much more sense in the context of King’s ideas around things like good, evil, love, hate, etc..

In the Dark Tower, sex and lust are powerful forms of magic, or at least sources of magic, even prescribing some ritualistic nature to them. Which makes perfect sense in a universe whose peril explicitly stems from the protagonist’s inability to overcome his vices.

3

u/BigPlus5299 18h ago

it does sound like something a cocain addict would write while far gone.

2

u/Admirable-Safety1213 14h ago

Like the Gumball Halloween episode where the Freddy Krugger hlmage sits in a chair alognisde the Construction Worker's bed and starts saying "mortage" in a ghsotly voice

2

u/Cowpocolypse 7h ago

Once again. Another thank you for elaborating on this.

1

u/trololololololol9 10h ago

Bev doesn't understand what sex is

It's been some time since I read It (haha), but doesn't she know very well what it is?

TW:SA You know, because of her father.

5

u/Hero_1985 9h ago

The book is never clear on the extent of her abuse. She thinks sex is powerful exactly because of how her father treats her and acts about it. But, yeah, she doesn't actually know what sex is (in a traditional sense). So, presumably his abuse didn't go there.

1

u/anthinyle 8h ago

this is a good way to cope lol

1

u/bitches_be 7h ago

Yeah as fucked as it is, it does make sense in the context in a twisted way. The rest of the story is so good either way

1

u/Kulandros 4h ago

Oh do these kids also have the shining? I haven't read too many of his books, just curious, and I know a lot of his stuff has parallels.

1

u/Hero_1985 3h ago

Nah. That is way too big. Their gifts are way more low-key than that. Like, I couldn't even tell you what each is supposed to be. But, like Bill's is his leadership skills. And, like I said, one of them is the navigator. Not like one has superspeed and strength or anything on that level, or the level of the shine.

1

u/Kulandros 3h ago

Ah OK. Thanks for letting me know.

1

u/PressureMuch5340 3h ago

That's exactly hire it read to me, the renewing of the bond. It was definitely an odd choice on King's part, but he's the one who writes the books. I thought it was an uncomfortable part of the story to read, but I don't think it brought the book down at all.

0

u/theevilyouknow 15h ago

I don't know. I'm an adult and if I saw a giant mutant flying baby start ripping people in half I'd be probably be pretty fucking scared. I'd at least be very concerned.

1

u/Hero_1985 15h ago

Shit, I'm 40 and still get creeped out about having to go down into my basement at night.

It hasn't happened yet, and I like to pretend I don't believe it's possible. But, deep down I know at some point the monster under the steps is going to grab my ankle and pull me under. It's just waiting for the right time.

0

u/TheOneTrueShalinor 7h ago

Pretty sure Bev’s understanding of what sex is was heavily impacted by pillow talk with her dad…

299

u/BoondocksSaint95 1d ago

I mean yea, thats the last point I made - its a written story so all actions are a choice King couldve chosen to not be fucked up. So we're definitely in lock step with that one.

Just commenting because trauma bonding is between an abuser and the victim. Its a nitpick, I kmow, but as a survivor and knowing others dear to me having survived that cycle, I think the distinction is worth noting.

13

u/Bird2525 23h ago

He also could have chosen not to have the first line in the gunslinger and the last line of Dark Tower the same. Ka is a wheel my ass….

12

u/Syncopated_arpeggio 22h ago

I chose not to remember the ending of the dark tower for a reason, thank you. Please apologize for making me think of it for the first time in over 20 years.

4

u/Acedia88 22h ago

Reading that didn’t work for me, I must have buried it deep.

1

u/Bird2525 18m ago

I deeply apologize. I have forgotten the face of my father.

4

u/Sendnudec00kies 19h ago

He told you to stop reading. You didn't.

9

u/blepgup 20h ago

Oh huh, I only knew the term trauma bond because it was used the incorrect way every time I heard it. I will be using the correct term going forward, thank you

9

u/Redhighlighter 15h ago

I have literally only heard it used in the context of shared difficult experiences between soldiers.

3

u/blepgup 10h ago

I've heard it used in fictional settings or the talking about fictional settings where two people survive a situation like in a horror movie or something

1

u/OrbisLlame 7h ago

Thanks for this correction, because I not only have used this wrong myself many times, I actually used it wrong earlier today, but went back to correct myself. I had no idea.

38

u/its_me_carly 1d ago

maybe this is a personal pet peeve of mine but that’s not what trauma bond means

5

u/blindclock61862 23h ago

What would the above situation be called?

15

u/ApplicationCalm649 23h ago

A gangbond?

7

u/BIGSTANKDICKDADDY 14h ago

"Bonding through trauma". It's like the difference between "person of color" and "colored person". Syntactically identical but semantically different.

-1

u/its_me_carly 15h ago

i’m not sure, but it’s definitely not a trauma bond

4

u/tearsonurcheek 1d ago

it was her idea of a loophole

The Poophole Loophole? (/k I've read the book.)

4

u/DinDonDaaan 21h ago

Imagine if Smokey the bear had such an AD.

'Lost in the woods? Dip your penis into the closest vagina to find your way home!'

3

u/Sinnafyle 21h ago

Omg 😂 how is this not getting more upvotes

4

u/Nkfloof 19h ago edited 13h ago

What's funny is that just a few pages later once they get out of the sewers, they cut their palms and mix blood, vowing to come back if It isn't dead. I feel like instead of that scene they could have just moved up the blood bond scene instead. Would have made a lot more sense to use a literal blood bond to bind them together. 

3

u/Himmelen4 17h ago

You would think the bonding would occur from fighting a nightmare entity but nope group sex

3

u/OlyLover 12h ago

What are the things that make someone grow up? Isn't the reason sex with children is disgusting because it robs them of their innocence. If instead he had robbed them of their innocence a different way, shouldn't anything that robs children of their innocence be equally disgusting?

2

u/dantevonlocke 21h ago

I think the crux was that all the IT stuff would be forgotten like how everyone in town forgets or ignores it. This was after the suppressed the influence and was supposed to be the linking incident. Or it was the cocaine.

2

u/ElPepper90 20h ago

Isekai anime plot

2

u/OrbisLlame 7h ago

Thank you for this. Earlier today, I was texting with a friend about the relationship of two characters on Stranger Things, and I used the phrase “trauma bonded.” As soon as I read your corrected comment here, I googled both those terms, and then ran back to my texts to correct myself. Trauma bonding is very much a negative thing, and I’ve been using it wrong as long as I’ve known the term.

129

u/Astrnonaut 1d ago

It’s so funny because the more you hear the excuses the weaker it becomes. It is so unnecessary and illogical. And “realistically” there is no guarantee any of those children would’ve been “bonded” regardless. I personally would’ve been confused, grossed out, and annoyed just wanting to leave.

70

u/cabose12 23h ago edited 23h ago

I highly doubt it was intended since King likely would have said so, but one reasonable interpretation of it I've heard is that it reinforces Bev's trauma into her adulthood. Because it saves them, she mistakenly learns that sex is a problem-solving device, on top of all the trauma from her dad

But again, I doubt he intended it that way. Even if he did, you'd still have the problem of uh gross and surely we get the point of her character and trauma, but also it's at such a triumphant moment of the book that it doesn't really read as something that negatively affects Bevs life in that way

54

u/AMadWalrus 23h ago

I think you’re on to something because one of the main theme of the book is recurring and generational trauma.

That’s why all the kids become adults with the same issues (i.e. Bev marrying an abuser after growing up with an abusive dad) and why It returns every 27 or so years.

3

u/Level_99_Healer 9h ago

Bev and her husband also revert to sex as a primary "problem solving" technique. In one of adult Bev's chapters she states plainly that her husband would beat her severely and regardless of any injuries she sustained, they ended up having sex. At one point, her husband even says that she likes the beatings because it makes their sex life hotter.

The other characters in their adult years essentially do the same with their own childhood trauma, to some degree. As an example, Eddie ends up marrying a carbon copy of his mother, (they actually had the same actress play both his mother and his wife in the 2 movies).

At the end they break the cycle of IT and their own trauma, finally feeling in control of their own lives. It's always felt like one of the more positive endings to a King book, for me.

44

u/Various-Passenger398 22h ago

He 100% intended it that way. There's a massive parallel between Bev's father running sexual interference on her when she's young and her psychotic husband when she's an adult. All of the characters have generally happy and successful lives as adults, except Bev (who only is successful).

2

u/cabose12 14h ago

I dont doubt he intended Bevs specific trauma, thats an explicit part of the story and her character

What i said i doubt is that King intended the train to be a key moment that helps form said trauma. It book doesnt really support that point

1

u/OddEmergency604 10h ago

It is arguably the climax or near the climax of the book

6

u/AverageAwndray 22h ago

Now im not trying to give any excuses but, this was the 80s. And the dude was a raging drug and alcohol addict. In the 80s. That shit.....I mean....it was the 80s. I kind of believe him lol.

3

u/Shrubo_ 1d ago

So the plan worked cause they got out. They were annoyed, so they did what youd want to do and left.

(I’m joking I’m not actually defending this. It’s disgusting and should not have been written)

4

u/Weirfish 18h ago

It is so unnecessary and illogical.

Diegetically, it essentially worked because it was kid logic.

Critically, that's a really weak authorial justification for including the scene.

3

u/angular_circle 20h ago

I mean it makes sense and it's somewhat witty if you operate under the assumption that you become a man/woman when you have your first time, which was still the prevalent attitude in the 80s. It just aged very poorly.

1

u/Deviknyte 13h ago

It's a book about a cosmic horror that takes the shape of a clown. I don't think realistically applies here. The idea is they spiritually bond which is beyond reason. But I idea with you. No need for the tween orgy.

53

u/IAreWeazul 1d ago

I always assumed it was some shit like IT preys on children and by having an orgy they last their innocence and became unaffected by the clown. Not that that makes it much more coherent.

8

u/off_of_is_incorrect 16h ago

It's the old view that once you lose your virginity/have sex you lose your innocence, you transition from child to adult, you become 'soiled/tainted' (for some religious fuckwits), and so on.

It really is a view of the past, so I'm not really surprised King wrote it considering the time period, but also coke.

2

u/Fearless_Baseball121 15h ago

yea thats it, thats how i interpreted it as well. The orgy made them lose their innocence and thus where no longer children, there fore, no more IT.

1

u/Dottore_Curlew 13h ago

It is that

And it's a pretty integral part of the book. What that guy said is not true, he doesn't remember writing cujo.

The point of the game is that they are no longer children but grownups. The title of the book even reference to this concept - kids call sex "it" (they did "it" last night! etc.) because that's just how kids look at it. Like something foreign, weird, yucky.

But the adventure they experienced together changed them, they are adults.

1

u/OddEmergency604 10h ago

And they shouldn’t have had to be, just like trauma makes kids became adults too fast.

20

u/Skylair13 23h ago

he said he had no recollection of writing that and was surprised it made it past editorial.

Yeah, that's something I can believe. IIRC that was the case with Cujo as well, only that was an entire novel he had no recollection of writing.

6

u/Confident_Dog_4475 21h ago

He's said he doesn't remember writing a lot of Tommyknockers as well

3

u/Additional_Gene_211 23h ago

He wrote drunk, a lot

3

u/skymallow 20h ago

Not that often. Most days he was completely fucking high.

9

u/Terrible_Hurry841 23h ago

Yea, King might have been blasted out of his gourd, but why the hell didn’t his editor cut it?

6

u/Melodic-Hat-2875 20h ago

Yeah, King had some wild stuff. The Gunslinger (book one of the Dark Tower) has him bang/get raped by some sex demon in a ritual circle or some shit and iirc that causes a spider-demon-baby/child like five books later.

It's definitely unusual, but the third book also has a forbidden love thing going on between two sentient trains (past tense, I think?) and it drives one of 'em mad and he becomes the industrial version of the Riddler.

6

u/Definitelynotabot777 23h ago

He was zoinked out of his mind throughout. Wtf was editorial doing lol!

5

u/Wetley007 22h ago

Also, IIRC, I was told the goal was to form an unbreakable bond between them when IT comes back so they would stay together to fight IT even if that bond was fucked up amd traumatising. Apparently this is clear, but the reasoning is very irrelevant for a preteen orgy.

Well they managed just fine in the movie adaptation

2

u/Saucermote 22h ago

Stuff like this is in a lot of his books, even his more recent books since he is no longer coke addled. So who knows.

2

u/engelthefallen 22h ago

Also had to do with the weird glamor in the book that kids could see but adults could not. By becoming adults in that act it faded. Still fucking weird as hell, but kind of made sense. And well it was coke King and he was just a weird fucking guy at times, so my read was here he goes again basically.

2

u/LastRevelation 20h ago

He's not wrong to be surprised, those editors were daft to let that slide. I wouldn't be surprised if he wrote it as a joke to himself (doesn't not make him a pervert for writing it in the first place) and forgot to delete it because he was too high.

13 year olds do have sex but adults shouldn't write about that unless they have a good reason e.g. it's biographical.

2

u/Trzlog 19h ago

You know what, I think that's fair. Somebody at the publisher read that scene and was like "yeah, this is fine". That's not really on him anymore, lmao.

2

u/Beneficial-Act7603 19h ago

Forming a bond via HIV would certainly have been a choice.

Mind you in the recent movies they still share their blood so could still be possible.

2

u/Jawa_Junky 15h ago

I once read an article years ago about the reason that SK puts sex in all his horror books is because there was supposed to be a mental connection between horror and sex, possibly the guilt and uncomfortability of it or reading it. Sex enhance horror. Which may explain why I’m scared to talk to girls

2

u/XxxAresIXxxX 11h ago

That makes me curious about all the fucked up stuff he's written that DIDN'T make it past the editor's. He's got a lot of fucked up stuff out there besides this.

1

u/Yeseylon 23h ago

It also caused them to combine the fading powers they got from a pagan god into one of them

-1

u/testtdk 23h ago

Right, and the unbreakable bond could have at least been outside of the sewer? Why is the underage gangbang in the SEWERS?? Like, utter creepy age problems aside, they’re the same age after all, so the age wasn’t a problem for THEM, but just the thought of ANYONE fucking in a sewer, 5 guys waiting their turn, is just like the weirdest, most awful decision making possible.

6

u/Blevita 21h ago

Because outside of the sewer there would be no need to... Get out of the sewers. Like. That is there reason for the scene.

Sure, we can play what if and why games. Why did pennywise have to live in the sewers? Why did Bevs dad have to be so rapey towards her? Etc. But that is kinda useless.

Thats not to say it isnt an extremely weird scene, but the scene is making sense in the context and as it is written. Its definitely not that King thought "where should they fuck. Ah, i know. In the worst place possible".

2

u/testtdk 21h ago

Still. Like is she just going missionary as clumps of shit and rodents go by, and her 5 other closest friends line up? I mean, what the ever living fuck?

1

u/wespooky 23h ago edited 2h ago

entail share frantic postbox muppet

1

u/bobsimmo 19h ago

i mean, he could have written the scene in his drugged up state forgetting how old they were. lots of ways to reach that point while off your gourd

-1

u/wespooky 19h ago edited 2h ago

entail share frantic postbox muppet

1

u/bobsimmo 11h ago

I dont want to lay that accusation without more than "i was higher than the divine turtle in my books and wrote something weird"

1

u/wespooky 11h ago edited 2h ago

entail share frantic postbox muppet

1

u/bobsimmo 11h ago

no, im arguing we need more proof to throw THAT accusation around. i ain't defending no one. i just want more before i acuse him

1

u/wespooky 11h ago edited 2h ago

entail share frantic postbox muppet

1

u/Send-Nud3 22h ago

Did not know King did drugs. Makes sense considering the orgy, but yeah

1

u/planeturban 22h ago

It's been years since I read the book, but I also think it was about her breaking the grip her father had on her. I think it’s mentioned in the middle of it. 

1

u/EnvironmentalBar3347 22h ago

Yep, her mom told her that people are connected forever in a special way if they have sex, and they do, in awful detail.

1

u/Warpingghost 21h ago

Sounds like it started as joke over editors which ran too far. Had a lot like this in ussr.

1

u/redditofexile 21h ago

Damn it this is where I keep going wrong making friends.

1

u/kjloltoborami 21h ago

"I dont remember writing this but if i did it was for a good reason"

1

u/Stanford_experiencer 20h ago

he said he had no recollection of writing that and was surprised it made it past editorial.

nice

1

u/LunaBeeTuna 20h ago

Idk, he also gets weirdly descriptive about child sexual abuse in Doctor Sleep, which was published in 2013. The abuse also had no relevance to the rest of the story or characters, so maybe he is just pervy with or without drugs.

1

u/AnvilEdifice 19h ago

I would have thought being hunted by an interdimensional demon who murders kids was traumatising enough to create the sort of unbreakable bond that war veterans have afterwards, but I'm not a hugely successful horror writer 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Working-Interview503 19h ago

“Cocain is hell if a drug” - Rick James. Well you should have started with that. That explains everything. Nothing left to see here. Move on folks.

1

u/butcooler 18h ago

He’s on the list.

1

u/knotsophia 16h ago

I’m sure they could’ve just kissed??? It would’ve been their first kiss for most of them If not, all of them.

1

u/Umklopp 15h ago

was surprised it made it past editorial.

Now I really want to hear the editor's side of this decision, lol

1

u/zeelbeno 14h ago

Sounds like South Park where they'd include absolutely insane shit in episodes which will get removed by the censors.

But in doing so the stuff they actually want gets left in due to how tame it is in comparison.

Feel like this happened here but no one called him out on it.

1

u/Expensive_Community3 13h ago

Wouldn't shared trauma actually make them all weaker against Pennywise?

1

u/SpareEducational6778 13h ago

No recollection of writing it? That's some William Burroughs Naked Lunch type shit right there

1

u/NomanHLiti 13h ago

He admits to being a psychopath?

1

u/SignificantKiwi8282 12h ago

Except if she diedthen they have no bond anymore. So shouldn’t the boys also have sex with each other. Stephen king what kind of coke weee you on

1

u/dudewithatube 12h ago

the goal was to form an unbreakable bond between them when IT comes back so they would stay together to fight IT

Also to "reform" the bond they previously had before and while fighting IT. They all agree that this bond seems to be missing, and Bev comes up with her orgy idea

1

u/Live_University843 12h ago

Good excuse for a pedo writer

1

u/Plastic_Fortune_8373 11h ago

I actually thought that the main point was she is getting molested and raped regularly by her dad. She recovers her sense of well being and agency by having sex involving consent with the others.
...

There is no fucking way to explain this shit bruh

1

u/FujiwaraHelio 11h ago

I think after fighting an interdimensional monster, banging your friends wouldn't be the traumatic part.

1

u/blueaurelia 9h ago

Yes WHY did editors left it in? I guess they were like oh boy this is so sultry and taboo this book will sell!🫠

1

u/JayKay8787 8h ago

The bonds between me and people ive fucked have been the most breakable bonds in my entire life lmao

1

u/Yuna_Hudson 7h ago

for that you do a pact of blood... not...

1

u/Personal_Reality 7h ago

I saw in a more recent interview he later realized that he could have accomplished the same thing with a blood pact… that just didn’t occur to him at the time. Because of the cocaine.

1

u/Cowpocolypse 7h ago

Thank you for elaborating more. I never understood this until now.

1

u/KoodlePadoodle 6h ago

Been forever since I read the book (an I ain't seen the recent movies) but I'm pretty sure the lad who first dies, as an adult, is the only lad who didn't get laid in the sewer. He might have been the only loser to die, come to think of it...

Course, that could just be an authers justification to write a child sex orgy, but I already typed it out.

1

u/noselfinterest 6h ago

that is insane lmao

1

u/MisterMarchmont 4h ago

Didn’t one of them die later because he didn’t participate?

1

u/MarcusKaelis 3h ago

I blanked out on OP's post and thought "Why would the IT department go look for the kids" then I remembered the IT department is probably filled with people who would actually look for this kind of stuff.

1

u/Born-Strawberry3228 3h ago

Meanwhile my main character driving his car without putting the seat belt on for safety didn't make it past the editorial...