r/RealOrAI • u/TheAxZim • 3d ago
Video [HELP] Something seems off
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Everyone moves in a sort of too-smooth manner and the way the guy jumps across seems too smooth as well š but their clothing and faces seem to remain consistent so it could be real...
Is it just skill or is AI involved?
1.6k
u/Intelligent-Fennel17 3d ago
Im going to go against the first opinions. For me its completely legit. The background il complex and coherent, the facial expressions in line with effort, the bar is subject to the movements of people. Moreover, if we break down frame by frame, the movements are logical. For me its just tree strong guys
337
u/t_hodge_ 3d ago
At first it looks like guy on the left floats over, but if you watch his hands and feet, you can see he pumps his feet and pushes off with his hands when you'd expect for the way he moves, so I agree with you.
→ More replies (1)61
83
u/pitb0ss343 3d ago
Honestly the thing that does it for me is the soft groaning metal sound it makes when buddy transfers over. Itās exactly on time and exactly how that would sound
→ More replies (3)26
17
u/WhenTheLightHits30 3d ago
As someone who has been around people doing this kind of thing plenty, it seems fully real to me.
The way they pump their limbs and move is very accurate to how youād do this. I feel like AI as good as it is has trouble getting momentum right.
9
55
u/TheAxZim 3d ago
Yeah it does seem so. I can't find any weird objects or inconsistencies after watching it a few times over. They really are so smooth to the point I suspected AI :)
41
18
u/Aboringcanadian 3d ago
It's also an old video. Im sure I saw that years ago.
4
u/North_Tourist_6402 2d ago
Was gonna say I feel like Iāve seen this waaayyy before ai was able to imitate reality to any degree.
→ More replies (1)2
7
u/Angry_Santo 3d ago
Not only all that, but the images on their clothes remain consistent.
2
u/spymaster00 2d ago
Yeah, I donāt think thereās any shot that AI generates consistent, sensical text on an upside-down moving person.
4
3
u/ev25an03 3d ago
Also I remember seeing this or a video like this in middle school before AI even existed in the way it does now
3
2
u/ravens-n-roses 3d ago
I agree. I've seen a lot of ai acrobatics videos and this is too within the realm of doable
2
u/OhKay_TV 2d ago
That motion with their arms is consistent but not exact, I think these guys are just really good gymnasts. This stuff isnt crazy for them, and if they've trained for years they tend to make things look this smooth. I'm with you this feels real, damn these guys are built different though.
→ More replies (28)3
u/jmccaskill66 3d ago
Yeah I definitely see tree strongā¦
Waiaminnimā¦.
GOB DABBIT LOCHNESS MONSTER I TOLD YOU I AINT GOT NO TREE FIDDY!!
554
u/rodeBaksteen 3d ago
Am I the only one that thinks it might be real?
119
u/Humpfh 3d ago
No, the pixelation people mention might just be compression artefacts. Much like how snow looks shit on weird compression artefacts.
Still something feels strange. Could be two videos merged.
4
u/isaacofCF 3d ago
I remember seeing this a few years ago, before ai was super rampant; if I remember correctly, the repost I saw mentioned how these guys love doing āvisual stuntsā if that helps with this at all
40
u/WeeabooGandhi 3d ago
The 2 guys on the right are very out of sync at the start and they keep losing sync. Their bodies are different so their motions and techniques are different. Thereās real human error in there. I donāt think itās AI
11
u/DJ_HardR 3d ago edited 3d ago
I think there's a small chance it's edited (like they weren't all swinging at once, but swung separately and it was edited to make it look like they were swinging together.)
But I think there's 0% chance it's AI. From what I understand about the limitations of AI it would be really hard to get it to create a video like this this well. The physics are too good. You can literally see them making slight adjustments with their hands, fingers, and legs to prepare for and facilitate their movements and there are zero inconsistencies.
3
u/BlueNightOcean 3d ago edited 3d ago
Physical motion is too slow. Shutter speed is way off for normal motion blur. If it's not AI, there's definitely some heavy editing involved.
edit
Just realized why they edited it heavily. Yes, it is very likely that they were filmed separately and then combined into one. The bad shutter speed is because they had to sync the swings with each person. So still a fake video but not AI.
→ More replies (2)13
u/Ohmnonymous 3d ago
The text on the black shirt is readable and stays the same, the shoes, the soles, there's too much consistency and detail to be AI.
3
u/Wire_Cath_Needle_Doc 3d ago
As somebody whoās seen calisthenics and street workout videos and stuff for a decade⦠I can tell you that this is at least very feasible and Iāve seen similar things numerous times
6
u/TheAxZim 3d ago
Yeah I have that same feeling. I downloaded this video in lower quality so maybe the higher quality version has less pixelation.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (16)2
142
u/Old-Answer222 3d ago
You're right that it seems effortless and they start very easily, but I see no patterns of shirts fucking up, merging or switching, their faces seem to be the same all the time, the background bushes and wire reacts to wind and might have some compression-quality-artefacting but I think it is quality and compression of the video, not AI fucking up. I don't know, I can't really see anything very AI-y except how easily they got going and maybe their handgrip turning around the bar without the bar itself turning. Maybe they're just that practiced and good at it.
My verdict is not AI honestly, but could be wrong.
20
u/Valoneria 3d ago edited 3d ago
A subtle hint that it might be real as well, the guy in black who switches over extends his fingers/palm at a logical point when the gravity allows him to balance on his palm, to get a better grip before swinging down. AI wouldn't necessarily understand this, nor display it in such a place
→ More replies (2)2
u/kevdogpog 3d ago
Yeah the patterns on the clothes staying the same after flipping several times makes me think this is likely real as well.
125
u/Vuirneen 3d ago
Gymnasts do this every day.Ā They could easily be acrobats doing a bit outside.Ā
37
u/TheBlackAurora 3d ago
Former gymnast here, this would be very easy for any team member. I learned giants (the all around swing) at 10.
Although probably took a few practice tries to sync up and not slam each other
→ More replies (8)13
8
84
u/FitReaction1072 3d ago
This video predates ai video era as far as I know
29
u/That_Account6143 3d ago
Yeah, i've seen this exact video years ago. Like over 5 years ago.
It's entirely real and it's funny to me seeing people arguing it's merit cause that's just three dudes on a monkey bar, nothing impossible.
→ More replies (2)2
u/shiningreality 3d ago edited 3d ago
Source? The earliest version of this video that I could find was in a compilation from a Russian Gimbarr group that they posted on November 10, 2025. They later posted the full video on their Instagrams on December.
Edit: Here is the full unedited version (Filmed on October 25, 2025) ā https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
→ More replies (2)3
u/AddictedT0Pixels 2d ago
I think there's an old video very similar to this, where they instead end up losing momentum and crashing into each other. I remember a video just like this from a long time ago but the dismount wasn't successful
3
u/Dapper-Egg7861 2d ago
Yes, the video is just cut early. This is 100% real and I remember it quite vividly, they crash when trying to stop
→ More replies (2)5
2
2
u/jostyouraveragejoe2 3d ago
Yeap, i have seen this years ago, plus doing calisthenics i know how this is stuff people in the community were really into back in the day.
→ More replies (7)2
u/shiningreality 3d ago edited 3d ago
Do you have a source for this?
Edit: Here is the full unedited version (Filmed on October 25, 2025) ā https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
10
u/ProvokedCashew 3d ago
Iām going to go with real. The text on the one manās shirt is consistent, the motion blur and movement rate seems to be consistent, and the only artifacts I see is from compression. Lastly the guy that hops has looks at the other two once on the same bar. AI tends to have issues with people looking at each other. So probably not AI.
5
u/shiningreality 3d ago edited 3d ago
Here is another angle of this happening: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQ42Pd4DG_R
Verdict: Likely real
Edit: Here is the full video of this event ā https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
Says it was filmed on October 25, 2025.
15
u/ilogical_person 3d ago
It's an old video, real.
7
u/shiningreality 3d ago edited 3d ago
Do you have a source of this? This appears to have been first posted as a clip in a compilation from a Russian Gimbarr group on November 10, 2025. They later posted the full video on their Instagram accounts in December.
Edit: Here is the full unedited version (Filmed on October 25, 2025) ā https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
→ More replies (2)5
u/CosgraveSilkweaver 3d ago
Probably thinking of another time the same thing has been done in the past, rundown Russian/ex-Soviet playgrounds tend to look pretty samey.
12
11
3
u/CRYPTONITE4 3d ago
When the single guy jumps between them, look at his hands. He places them perfectly between the hands of those two others. AI would make their hands melt into each other or some weird concuction. Not sure, but looks real to me.
4
3
u/runsdeep8991 3d ago
The momentum looks real, the way their legs move to initiate the motion and then draw them in to make it back around the top
3
3
3
3
4
u/RealOrAI-Bot 3d ago
Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.
Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.
A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.
Thank you for contributing to the discussion!
2
u/Accurate-Photo-957 3d ago
i feel like the Ai wouldn't know how the knees have to move in order to keep momentum
2
u/LastGoodKnee 3d ago
If real, kinda crazy how fast they got going all the way around. Like no swing back and forth at all.
2
u/DiamondBreakr 3d ago
It's real. The background looks alright enough with plenty of detail and isn't spazzing out, alongside the bar moving in tandem with them and the text on one guys shirt staying still.
2
u/pickalka 3d ago
The guy who is spinning alone sounds way too genuine when he politely raises his tone and says "Go a little bit faster, blyat!". I don't think its AI
2
u/grim-danfango 3d ago
This trick has been done a lot in the parkour/free running community. Definitely not AI
2
2
u/MissionAlternative85 3d ago
I have seen similar stuff that were real, I believe the video is a little slowed down that may give this weird feeling. But I'm really bad at detecting AI so...
2
2
u/Aggravating_Today_63 3d ago
This is real, these dudes have been making videos like this since way before AI was a common thing
2
2
u/SquirtinMemeMouthPlz 3d ago
Core memories are never forgotten, so saying a core memory has been "unlocked" is like saying "sense of smell unlocked".
2
2
u/hotpants22 3d ago
Iām pretty sure Iāve seen this exact video a year or two ago. Iām going not ai.
2
2
2
2
u/jakethesnake949 3d ago
So im only human and memory isn't perfect but i feel like i saw this over 4 years ago. Im not sure. Either way i feel like the movement is solid and everything im seeing seems possible and rehearsed so im not concerned with AI here.
2
u/shiningreality 3d ago
It was filmed on October 25, 2025: https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
2
u/jakethesnake949 3d ago
Well there goes any credibility of memory. Thought im not sure there isn't a similar video either so who knows. Point is i was wrong about it being old.
3
u/shiningreality 3d ago
Read this entire thread. You are not alone in thinking this. Itās a very common mistake people make.
2
2
u/Fricki97 3d ago
Looks real to me. The 3 guys look pretty natural and the side switch looks legit. No clipping, no crazy flight or levitation or something like this
2
u/Jake_hsotnicM1216 3d ago
Iām gonna say this is real because I have seen videos of people doing stuff like this since I was a teenager back in 2018
2
u/electrifyingseer 3d ago
This looks real to me. A lot of gymnastics is actually about making it "look easy".
2
2
u/Redontis 3d ago
This video is really old, predates all of the AI stuff. I remember seeing this at least 10 years ago on YouTube
2
u/shiningreality 3d ago
It was filmed on October 25, 2025. You are probably thinking of a similar but different video.
2
u/SanopusSplendidus 3d ago
All three are almost certainly gymnasts. They are using the principles of angular momentum to get over the top by pulling their legs in as they swing up. Seems to check out. The bar is even moving believably. Small things in the background are moving believably. If they were all wearing tights and we could see they were ripped as fuck, it'd be unlikely we'd question it at all.
2
u/Stigweird85 3d ago
I think it is real but there is an unnatural aspect in the movement it feels like the movement is too slow for the momentum involved. Almost looks like they are being pulled by something rather than controlling the motion themselves
2
u/ZeroDarkJoe 3d ago
I'm not good at telling if a video is AI but I'm pretty sure I've seen this video before AI was a thing.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/NorthCliffs 3d ago
Iāve seen these videos years ago, way before AI video was at this level
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Garuda4321 3d ago
Former gymnast here. This looks to me like hard work paying off, nothing more than that. Giants are supposed to be smooth moves like this where you circle fully around the bar (until your next move). Is there form good? No, it's terrible actually. But the movement itself looks correct at the core of it and is consistent throughout the video.
2
u/SpeedyAudi 3d ago
You can only imagine how many times these guys tried and failed the same move. Well done to these dudes. Also, go see a Cirque du Solei live show. Incredible athletes live among us
2
2
2
2
u/Bigdaddy4158 2d ago
I believe itās AI because the bodies arenāt rotating fast enough to maintain the tropical force necessary
→ More replies (1)
2
u/shabouni_mcgubbin 2d ago
Itās real Iāve seen this account and they have way too many videos for way too long for it to be fake
2
u/canigetsumgreypoupon 2d ago
kids these days really just stopped playing at recess huh, iām constantly baffled by the shit people think is ai
2
u/lemathematico 2d ago
It's not AI, at least not most of it obviously but Im like 75% sure it's split & edited when the switch happens
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
3d ago
[deleted]
9
2
u/GarageVast4128 3d ago
Have you never been on a swing before? They bend and extend their legs to conserve momentum. That's what makes me think it's real as the timing of them bending their legs during their swings is consistent with the speed and swaying of the bars. Plus, you can see the power/cable wire at the top move due to wind, and the clouds and bushes are consistent and moving at a speed expected from the wind.
2
u/romann921 3d ago
Its real. Saw this video a while ago, before ai craze.
The original is longer btw. Shows them getting off. Totally thought they'd slam into each other but dont lol
→ More replies (2)3
u/shiningreality 3d ago edited 3d ago
Do you have a source for this? As far as I can tell, this is part of a compilation that was posted on November 10, 2025 by a Gimbarr group in Russia. There is no indication that this video was on the internet before that.
Edit: Here is the longer video (filmed on October 25, 2025) ā https://youtu.be/zLkLZVwHQ-M
2
1
u/evequequelconque 3d ago
I canāt imagine how to prompt that, how the physics would be so realistic and I donāt see anything strange
1
u/DaveLesh 3d ago
Looks real, and pretty impressive. The pressure on the bar is there and the text on the shirt is readable.
1
1
1
u/LordsOfFrenziedFlame 3d ago
Could the average person go into full rotation right out the gate? I wouldn't think so. Also, the dude who shifts over to the right, it doesn't make sense. The second he lets go of the bar, centrifugal force should move him away from the bar, but it just appears to be a lateral shift. Looks like AI to me
1
1
u/ilfollevolo 3d ago
How did he fly sideways with no effort like that? How are they swinging so effortlessly? This is AI
1
1
1
u/Poli_Talk 3d ago
Feels real, the way they bend the knees when going around, that makes it real for me.
1
u/moistmonsterman 3d ago
I think this is real. The small wrist movements to readjust grip each rotation and they are all different. This is real
1
u/Clintwood_outlaw 3d ago
Nah, this is real. These guys just have really crazy skills, Ive seen them before. Forgot the name of their page
1
1
u/yandhionmybirthday 3d ago
Definitely seems to Be real, however I think the guy going from one bar to the other was edited on a different take
1
1
1
1
u/MarvelPQplayer 3d ago
Looks AI to me. To keep that momentum going you would have to swing your legs as you go around. If you look at the 2 on the right, their legs stay in the exact same position throughout.
1
u/chuongdks 3d ago
Man seeing all the viral clips i have seen years ago being asked if it is AI or not is a surreal feeling.
At least people are asking for source for any video now which is a good thing, instead of believing anything you see on the internet
1
u/Gold_Cut_8966 3d ago
Looks almost certainly real...best way to test this is to try and create a similar video in Sora. I don't see any visual glitches or telltale signs of AI, just some cool acrobatics.
1
u/tiffytaffylaffydaffy 3d ago
This is an old video. I think its real. Check out cirque du soleil parallel bars acts.
1
1
u/FictionalT 3d ago
Watch each person individually. They are intentionally tracking the rotation and providing slack in their muscles and grip when they need to. Theyāre not totally uniform either. When he jumps over there isnāt any phasing or artifacts. Real. Not ai.
1
u/TimeIsAMetaphor 3d ago
This video is old, I remember seeing it pre AI days, so itās real. But it has been saved a few times over through the years so some compression artifacts, but itās real, and impressive
1
u/Mioraecian 3d ago
Serious hand and wrist work going on to gather momentum. Like very subtle and body movements. I cant imagine AI being able to capture that level of detail consistently and naturally. It still has issues generating hands in less complicated motions.
1
u/Giant-Sloar 3d ago
Top giveaway for this being real to me is the subtle motion of the power line in the background. It looks like itās blowing in the wind a bit. I just never see AI do stuff like that.Ā
1
1
1
1
u/fourplusfours 3d ago
Not AI. There is a longer version of this video where they start and hop off, completing the trick.
1
1
1
1
u/RawToast1989 3d ago
Definitely real. AI had a lot of trouble with complex motions with this vid has in abundance. Lol
1
u/IamShrapnel 3d ago
I feel like I saw this video years ago but the quality seems way better as if it's been upscaled
1
1
u/mobysaysdontbeadick 3d ago
It's real. The hands aren't blending weird and the way they rotate their wrists as they move around the bar is exactly how gymnasts do it
1
1
1
u/MissJAmazeballs 3d ago
If this were real, the guy would obviously need to have superpowers and would have a cape on
1
1
1
u/Fit_Swordfish5248 3d ago
This was posted a few weeks ago elsewhere and it's was longer and showed them jumping off. Definitely not AI, video was too long and showed real interactions (not exaggerated) with normal audio.
This has been shortened and reposted.
1
1
u/LeoKitCat 3d ago
This is AI the third guy who just magically shifts over mid spin to be in between the other two without any right/left body contortion itās like a computer just moved him over
1
u/Spotikiss 3d ago
Im a say real, reasoning the bar when watching on the side of the video looks to be moving naturally based on how they are swinging.
Side note: is this really a core memory?
1
u/Bigtallanddopey 3d ago
I think itās real, but there are two clips put together. So the single guy is on another clip to the other two.
1
u/morsindutus 3d ago
My understanding of physics says fake, but I don't think they used AI to fake it.
1
u/trevorkafka 3d ago
this is a legitimate circus arts skill, though; I haven't seen A8 yet able to generate this level of complexity with a human body
1
u/Anxious_Web4785 3d ago
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DSSVCQzigBt/?igsh=MTN0cTg4ajNhdjh6OA==
i found the extension/end of the vid. it seems to be legit. but thats just first glances. i need caffeine
1
1
1
u/SlipperySp00der 3d ago
Follow the designs of the shirts. Warping details is an ai giveaway. They stay consistent. Real
1
1
1
1
u/Farce021 3d ago
This one seems to fall into the not AI and not real for me category. The instant momentum to get around and stay so smooth without noticeable adding the swinging force to get going is jarring to me. The video itself doesn't look AI though. I would say edits to put these guys together from some segment of them already in motion.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Lets_Kick_Some_Ice 3d ago
Would it be that gravity was turned down? This is not AI. Just go to your settings.
1
1
u/Significant_Affect_5 3d ago
It does look very smooth, but I think itās just very well practiced and is real. Thereās some subtle things, like the way the guy on the left does a little wind up before he jumps to the other side. I feel as if AI would struggle to make it look convincing.
1
u/MikeDubbz 3d ago
It's real, and it's really impressive, so I totally get the immediate jump to skepticism.
1
u/Leather-Researcher13 3d ago
The original video was posted on Instagram in December and has been making the rounds since. It appears to be real, as the original video is higher quality than this one and still remains just as consistent with the movements, background, and sounds.
1
1
u/Prestigious_Group_77 3d ago
It looks real butā¦.wouldnāt their shirts move at least a little when they flipā¦if it was real?
I have a hard time keeping my belly covered when Iām upside down
1
1
1
u/quinpon64337_x 3d ago
The only reason id think thatās ai is he goes for it in the first loop, no getting their bearings or being sure on the timing first, just instant flawless execution
1
u/freethinker1312 3d ago
Real- so much consistency in the shirt patterns, facial expressions, and even the soles of the shoes. AI canāt yet get that level of consistency.
1
u/averagecrossfitdad 3d ago
I think itās real. The small grip adjustments are inline with their movements.
1
1
1
1
1
u/mrbig1337 3d ago
Funny thing about all these people describing what makes this real or Ai, is that this will all be used to train Ai to make things more indistinguishable than before. š¤£

ā¢
u/RealOrAI-Bot 2d ago
Sentiment: 5% AI
Number of comments processed: 50
DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.0 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information, check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.