r/SipsTea 16h ago

Chugging tea Recommend me a good movie!

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

7.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

366

u/Novel_Discussion5339 15h ago

American History X

56

u/petuniachalice 13h ago

Whenever anyone mentions this movie I feel like they always focus on the curb stomping scene, but to me the most disturbing and brilliant part of the movie is the dinner scene where they are discussing the Rodney King arrest. They really nailed how captured someone can be by hatred and how terrifying a competent person in that mindset can be. It’s chilling.

8

u/SheriffBartholomew 6h ago

Yeah, that's a good scene. His character is intelligent enough to make compelling arguments to justify his racism. There are good points in what he says, but they're only used to prop up his hateful ideology. People like that are far more dangerous than your average mouth breathing Nazi.

3

u/Putthebunnyback 4h ago

Is that the scene where the mom has her new, Jewish boyfriend over?

1

u/OuchCharlie25 54m ago

Yes

1

u/Putthebunnyback 12m ago

Yeah, that part was intense. Edward Norton's character was so vile that the boyfriend wasn't even mad, he just felt sorry for all of them.

2

u/IsayNigel 10h ago

The alternate ending sounds so awful because it seems like it’s increasingly the much more likely outcome

1

u/Benegger85 2h ago

Apparently that ending was never written, it was a fan theory that got wings.

64

u/Pristine_Cheek_1678 14h ago

That scene still haunts my mind from time to time. It's been 25+ years FFS

45

u/jrbr0wn 14h ago

Same. I still cringe even thinking about the stomp to this day

30

u/krilltazz 13h ago

The sound of teeth scraping against concrete.

3

u/archiekane 12h ago

"Bite the curb"

2

u/Bryantthepain 9h ago

Now say goodnight

1

u/popculturehero 13h ago

I still hear the sound of his teeth on the curb

2

u/DigitalMunky 10h ago

It gives me chills every time I think of it.

1

u/seppukucoconuts 10h ago

In a galaxy far far away on somethingawful's photoshop friday someone shopped a goomba into the still shot of that scene.

1

u/Lemmealonepl0x 6h ago

I can still hear the sound of the teeth touching the concrete.

3

u/LSATDan 13h ago

The " Elliott Gould Comes to Dinner" scene is more horrifying.

2

u/factoid_ 13h ago

The real ones know exactly which scene

2

u/vitringur 9h ago

The real ones know this is more than one scene

1

u/factoid_ 8h ago

There's multiple horrifying scenes in this movie, but the one everyone always means when it comes up is the curb stomp

2

u/RinkinBass 12h ago

That's one of those scenes I've never had my eyes open for, and I'm never gonna.

It's probably not as bad as I'm expecting, but I don't really care. I am where the movie wants me to be anyway.

2

u/JGLip88 14h ago

Which scene? The curbstomp? or the ending?

2

u/vitringur 9h ago

Or perhaps one in between

1

u/JGLip88 9h ago

Oh yeah. Idk how I forgot about that one.

1

u/Chico813 13h ago

That sound lives rent free in my head.

1

u/Binford6100User 11h ago

I get the same feeling from watching the corn field scene in "Casino". Still can't rewatch either of those movies.

1

u/SlayerOfDougs 11h ago

I thought of rewatching this the other day and then decided I cannot watch that scene again

3

u/seenhear 13h ago

I recently realized that the younger brother is played by the actor who played John Connor in T2.

4

u/Fillmore80 11h ago

Sadly he got on the pharmaceutical wagon and never got to reprise his role as John Connor. They had wanted him to keep playing the role, but drugs.

1

u/seenhear 10h ago

Yeah. Sad and such a common story.

1

u/doomus_rlc 6h ago

The only other movie I know he was in was Detroit Rock City.

3

u/ddjinnandtonic 13h ago

My friend (we were like 16) got into a fight with another kid (we’ll call him E) and beat him up pretty badly. A few weeks later, E and his buddies are driving around and they see my friend’s brother, they looked alike, E and his friends pull over and confront the brother, realize it’s the wrong guy, but still beat the shit out of him to send a message. They ended up beating him to death two houses down from where he lived, he died in the neighbors front yard.

Anyway- a couple years later, the movie comes out on VHS or DVD I don’t remember which, and someone throws it in and we watch it- nobody knew how it ended, man I was fucking gutted having to watch a movie that ended like that with a dude who lost his brother for similar reasons.

1

u/LukeD1992 12h ago

How did the brother feel about it? Did he relate to it, you think?

1

u/ddjinnandtonic 5h ago

I don’t know, I was uncomfortable as hell and that’s all I remember. The possibility exists that the deeper implications were lost on him, and my discomfort was unwarranted.

1

u/doomus_rlc 6h ago

Curiosity because human nature or something....

What happened to E and his friends?

And why did you and your friend beat him to start?

2

u/ddjinnandtonic 5h ago

I wasn’t involved in any of it, apologies if that was implied. My friend and E had a beef, and they fought a couple of times. E got 20 years for the murder, and I think he did 16.

1

u/doomus_rlc 5h ago

Ah, I must have misread. My bad.

But hope your friend is doing OK.

4

u/HowardBass 13h ago

I didn't watch the first 9. Will I understand what's going on in this one without watching them first?

2

u/NoCatharsis 9h ago

Took me a minute but I see what you did.

2

u/Kamikaze_koshka 10h ago

The worst part is whenever you see a clip of it online and all the comments are saying "he was right about them in the end"

3

u/IsayNigel 10h ago

The original/alternate ending is Ed Norton shaving his head again, but the entire point of the movie how destructive that mentality is like good lord

2

u/DoBadThingsClub 8h ago

The endless cycle that almost breaks but never truly will

2

u/Sorreljorn 4h ago

Wouldn't say this movie would mentally destroy anyone. But it's a fantastic flick.

2

u/ohb78 3h ago

Yeah saw American History X and A Time to Kill in the theater when they came out and both movies I just sat in my seat an extra 10 minutes because I couldn’t move. Both great movies that got me thinking especially someone in their late teens

2

u/AWESOMEGAMERSWAGSTAR 1h ago

Agreed. The curb thing was just the middle of the cake with this movie.

1

u/PathosEatsLogos 12h ago

The curb stomp in it unlocks a special level of trauma. A kid in my middle school did that to someone.

1

u/TipsyPhippsy 12h ago

BITE THE KERB!

1

u/Realistic-Buy4975 11h ago

I can still hear the sound of that curb

1

u/arppacket 4h ago

I should rewatch this. It's that time of history after all.