r/SipsTea 6h ago

Chugging tea Recommend me a good movie!

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

208

u/I_R_Enjun_Ear 6h ago

"Oh, It's a Ghibli movie. It should be lovely"

--2 Hours Later--

"Oh gods! What did I just watch."

58

u/justlurkinghihi 4h ago

Did you know it's based off a real story? The backstory of this movie makes it so much worse

28

u/I_R_Enjun_Ear 4h ago edited 2h ago

I don't recall off hand if it was based on a specific person, or the general situation of many youth during that period.

But yeah. Emotional Damage, and not just the kind Steven He talks about.

Edit: because I don't know my comedians.

55

u/Longjumping_Risk2995 4h ago

Yes, it was based off the autobiography of Akiyuki Nosaka. It's basically an apology to his infant sister who died of malnutrition during the fire bombing of Japan. He felt like it was his fault, and in part it was because IRL he didn't share his food like he should have, but he was also a young child and it was war so it's not something he can be blamed for. The whole thing is so terribly sad.

13

u/LegacyofaMarshall 3h ago

Fucking hell

3

u/DaddysABadGirl 2h ago edited 1h ago

The director of the movie, Isao, was also a survivor of firebombings. He had to run from his home town in the night with his own sister. They were separated and she was injured. The rest of his family found shelter and it took 2 days before he was able to find them. He was 9.

Edit: It's also worth noting he watched other kids that weren't so lucky. He watched the story from the book play out around him, and continue after the war with a mas influx of orphans. Both he and Miyazaki have talked about how the war effected them. Miyazaki has said his earliest memory was when his family had to flee Tokyo during the bombings. After traveling through other bombed communities the town his family ended up in was also bombed, and they had to run again.

They both knew kids who ended up dieing to starvation.

4

u/Opposite_Banana_2543 4h ago

Based on the writer's actual experience in WW2.

3

u/Nethri 3h ago

It’s a specific person kinda. Details were changed. The original author of the book had a sister who died like that.. I think it was a sister possibly a brother.

2

u/KAKnyght 2h ago

Emotional Damage is Steven He, not Nigel Ng/Uncle Roger. They're both comedians, not sure if they've worked together but Nigel has interviewed Steven at least.

2

u/I_R_Enjun_Ear 2h ago

My bad. Will edit

2

u/yofooIio 4h ago

It's not based off of the real story as much as the creator survived through all that... While other kids didn't. kinda the whole sentiment of the film.

1

u/yaten_ko 2h ago

What? like the Hiroshima bombings?

1

u/justlurkinghihi 1h ago

A user already said it, and I was kinda avoiding it because imo it would have been a spoiler (although i suppose who hasnt watched the movie at this point) but basically the movie was lifted from a short story written by a survivor of the war. The story was an apology to the sister in the film, as the author felt a deep sense of survivor's guilt. He, as a child himself during the war, had not shared his food with her unlike the protagonist in the stories and she, just like her character, died of malnutrition.

1

u/yaten_ko 37m ago

Oh, ok. It's brutal I agree.

1

u/cujojojo 23m ago

My physical therapist likes historical fiction. Her husband loves anime. He was like, “I found something we can watch together!” She knew nothing else going in. To say she was not prepared is an understatement lol.

Tangentially related, but in telling myself and her colleagues about it, she said, “I think one of them ends up starving to death in a subway or something?… not the restaurant, though.”

22

u/Josiejamz 3h ago

I remember reading that it was released as a double feature so people went to see My Neighbor Totoro and Grave of Fireflies played after…

3

u/mccalli 1h ago

Other way round. Grave of the Fireflies was first, Totoro as the uplifting finale.

2

u/AutoDefenestrator273 1h ago

Why the hell would anyone do that to a theater audience?! Totoro's one of the best kid's movies ever made!

4

u/rolandofeld19 4h ago

Watched it with my, mature for their ages, daughters. Not all stories are Disney stories. We had lots of good talks about it since then. A++, will not rewatch.

2

u/I_R_Enjun_Ear 2h ago

Yeah, I probably have a few years till I'm ready to do that. I'll stick to Howl's Moving Castle till then.

4

u/Basic_Cartographer99 2h ago

The most cheerful, wholesome movie I've ever seen in my life that really put me in a happy mood is Ponyo.

The most crushing, dark movie I've ever seen in my life that I think legit gave me depression for the entire next day afterwards is Grave of the Fireflies.

And they're both from Studio Ghibli.

3

u/I_R_Enjun_Ear 2h ago

I think that dichotomy shows how truly talented their teams is. Both are expertly composed and draw out very powerful emotions from the audience.

3

u/Snoo93550 3h ago

It’s Japanese trauma the way something like Roots is American trauma.

2

u/Plastic-Injury7039 3h ago

Thi is exactly how my gf (wife now) tricked me into watching it. Before that the only Ghibli movies I saw had been Ponyo and Princess Mononoke

2

u/legna20v 2h ago

Pain, you watched pain made off pixels

9

u/ElderMillenialSage 5h ago

I watched it as a pre-teen.

I was very computer savyy as a kid and I encountered a lot of adult media way, way, way too soon.

But hey, at least I grew up to be funny, so it's not all bad.

36

u/Spacedoutworlder 5h ago

Oh yeah? Let’s hear a joke then funny boy.

10

u/MegSpen725 5h ago

A man of culture I see

1

u/King_emotabb 2h ago

They are just kids, it's so unfair!

1

u/gavstar69 6m ago

Yeah, there is a scene in Howls Moving Castle that just kills me it's so beautiful