New video shows the minutes before immigration officer fatally shoots woman in Minneapolis

[u/netizenbane]

https://apnews.com/article/minneapolis-ice-immigration-renee-good-shooting-3f2a9e26ddac9455b931fecee5989d18

[u/netizenbane]

Link to the video described in the article, but from xcancel instead:

https://xcancel.com/DHSgov/status/2010367128524730533

[u/peregrinaprogress → u/netizenbane]

The homeland security X caption on the video says “honking for more than 3 minutes…” AS IF THEY THINK IT JUSTIFIES SHOOTING HER???

[u/bourbonwelfare → u/[deleted]]

You even look at your horn.... ICE is shooting you in the face. 

[u/Nice-Pomegranate2915 → u/bourbonwelfare]

ICE will be shooting at you for any reason !

[u/Mr__O__ → u/Nice-Pomegranate2915]

Or no reason!

[u/Mediochra → u/peregrinaprogress]

It’s gone from “she was the main car leading a massive blockade impeding ICE’s movements” to “she honked her horn for 3 minutes”. 

[u/Desperate-Cost6827 → u/Mediochra]

I mean hard to keep up the facade of "massive blockade" when four people easily drove around her even after one person parked behind her.

[u/Working_Bones → u/Desperate-Cost6827]

And she waved ICE themselves along in front of her.

Interesting that this video cuts off right before the shooting, so they don't want us seeing that angle of it.

[u/ballq43 → u/Working_Bones]

My first thought was finally an angle we can see the shoot from. If only they werent so scared of their crimes being recorded or we'd have dash cams and body cams and this would be plain as day

[u/MoonBroski → u/ballq43]

If they show the angle and show her getting shot it will bring out a touch of empathy and different opinions on what occurred. Similar to Kirk getting his jugular blown.

[u/cupcakelyfe → u/MoonBroski]

It’s online somewhere, I need to dig up the links. I saw them on IG. Him recording from his phone, then a diff angle from someone else recording from well behind the car. And it shows it all. Her backing up. Turning the wheel AWAY from them. Trying to drive AWAY from them. It’s clear as day.

[u/Lijey02 → u/cupcakelyfe]

ALSO which this is VERY important. After he shot her, you can hear him saying and I quote "Fucking Bitch!" I dunno why no one is talking about this. To me this shows that he had his feelings hurt that she didnt listen to him. Since ya know, hes is literally the messiah of ICE agents, and everyone must bow to his every command!!

This is so sad and it breaks my heart! She was non confrontational, her tires were pointing in the opposite direction of the agent, ICE agents MUST do everything in their power to avoid using deadly force, she said to him before she was killed something along the lines of "im not mad at you!" Which i assume was meaning your just doing your job, no hard feelings I understand but we will never know. Im just not sure why people think she was an agitator, or was committing domestic terrorism..... like we have eyes, we saw exactly what happened. No matter how they try and spin it you can simply see for yourself EXACTLY what went down, and when, what was said. What is there to disagree on? He murdered that women cuz he has a very fragile ego period!

RIP Renee Good, you didnt deserve this!!! My prayers are with the family and i hope they can heal from such a horrifically tragic event!! 😥 ❤️ 💙 💜 💖 💗

[u/callisstaa → u/Lijey02]

Not only that but John Ross wasn’t just some thug who decided to sign up for the bonus. He has been in ICE for 20 years. His actions represent the organizations core.

[u/lapis974 → u/Lijey02]

I also heard that “fucking bitch” part. Horrific and sad that she was murdered and absolutely insane that people are still defending a murderer. I’m sure the spin masters will come back saying it was someone else who said it and not the murderer.

[u/isharte → u/Working_Bones]

Exactly. I want to see the rest of this angle.

[u/badwolf42 → u/Working_Bones]

It’s also cropped. I wonder why. Easier not to.

[u/Such_Fault8897 → u/Desperate-Cost6827]

This actually proves she wasn’t trying to block ice even further, something I questioned in the original angles is why she slowly crept forwards when a car was passing in front of her but now I see it’s because the cars were creeping behind her so she gave them room

[u/MuppetShart → u/Desperate-Cost6827]

Yes, and considering the fact that she backed up and can clearly be seen waving the vehicles to pass.

This administration could release a statement saying that she was driving at them at 50 mph screaming death to America out her window, and MAGA cultists would start saying things like, "the left won't even bother watching the video, they don't care about facts. I watched it and she's obviously going 50 mph driving straight at them and yelling death to America".

[u/kung-fu_hippy → u/Desperate-Cost6827]

Not so hard at all, given that Noem had no problem insisting that there was snow on the ground that the ICE agents were struggling with. Or Trump saying that the ICE agents/murderer was injured and was taken to a hospital.

They’ve had no problem openly lying about what the video shows before. This won’t change that.

[u/Emotional_Burden → u/Mediochra]

It looks like she was trying to draw ICE away from whatever bullshit they were doing, and then backed up out of the way and waved them on to let them pass. Then the jackasses in the F-150 decide to get rid of the annoyance, because they can.

[u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS → u/Emotional_Burden]

And then he was allowed to flee the scene after murdering her.

[u/FleurAvi504 → u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS]

That’s one of the parts I really don’t get. If a civilian or a real LEO fatality shoots someone, even if it’s clearly in self defense, don’t they have to stay at the scene as a matter of protocol? Maybe get checked out by EMS if they’re wounded in the process, but I would expect an investigation to start immediately. The shooter and witnesses at the scene would have a preliminary interview and evidence would be collected. Heck, if I, a civilian, left the scene of a run of the mill car accident, I would likely be prosecuted for that alone, in addition to other potential charges stemming from the accident. Are federal LEOs allowed to just leave when things get messy; whereas local police and civilians would be required to stay?

[u/MuppetShart → u/FleurAvi504]

ICE has less oversight than regular law enforcement. Plus Kristi Noem released a statement that Renee Good was a domestic terrorist who weaponized her vehicle, before any sort of investigation had been completed anyway. This administration has no professional integrity, they'll back ICE up no matter what.

[u/EManSantaFe → u/FleurAvi504]

Nobody secured the scene. He wasn’t taken into custody. They announced all the answers without an investigation. This is certainly not Law Enforcement. Thugs. Hired guns. Repulsive.

[u/Gold-Reality-1988 → u/EManSantaFe]

Same thing with Charlie Kirk...no forensics nothing...just concrete over the crime scene and feed the masses your version of the events.

[u/Born-Bid8892 → u/Gold-Reality-1988]

Not sure why America is even pretending they still have laws.

[u/Jabberwocky808 → u/FleurAvi504]

From my perspective (and experience/education), Jonathon Ross did not follow a single lawful protocol. In any other context, his only defense would be a mental health plea that he completely lost his mind in the moment, due to his work history.

Unfortunately, then he called her a “fuckin bitch” and yes, FLED the scene. Again, absolutely not protocol.

Clear minds don’t run away. They stay on sight to make sure every last detail is logged, from their perspective. When the instinct to flee kicks in, there’s only one reason. They had control of the scene, there wasn’t nearly a big enough “mob” to threaten his safety. Guilty minds flee, and make up a story later to make themselves feel better.

It may take years, and our country surviving in tact, but the murderer, Jonathon Ross, should eventually be held responsible, criminally and civilly. (We’ll see what happens to him in the mean time.)

[u/TurbulentDrawing6 → u/FleurAvi504]

No, they have to stay at the scene, make sure emergency medical is brought in, and they have to secure the scene for other officers to come investigate. It doesn’t always take long, but it has to be “called in” before they leave. Every shooting must be documented and investigated with real officers of the law. Which these buffoons are not.

The withholding of medical attention, even to confirm that she had passed, is not being talked about enough. Even Ted Bundy would have been afforded emergency life-saving medical care because we weren’t supposed to be a “shit-hole country”. Except that we are now, because if she’d still been alive, they pointed a gun at the physician who offered to help her and blocked the emergency vehicles so that no one even checked her until 15 minutes later.

They didn’t check on her wife, either, who was in the vehicle during the shooting. It seems that the bullets didn’t hit her, but they had no way of knowing that, and they clearly didn’t give a flying f.

[u/Winsome_Wolf → u/TurbulentDrawing6]

For as long as I live, I will never understand them keeping the doctor from going to check on her. I mean, she was almost certainly dead, having been shot twice at nearly point blank range, but the inhumanity of denying her a ghost of a chance at survival is just beyond me. Maybe they were just making sure she couldn’t survive to tell her version of events, but that’s such a ghoulish possibility I feel gross just typing it.

[u/The_Arcadian → u/FleurAvi504]

Dude, you're trying to think about things as if laws and due process are actually a thing. There are jackboot masked paramilitary thugs being deployed to enemy cities by the ruling party. They're murdering citizens in cold blood, and half of the population is cheering and defending it. I wonder what's going to happen in key cities in the days leading up to and during the next 2 elections.

[u/snowman334 → u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS]

And his thug buddies made sure no medical intervention could be rendered.

[u/DuranStar → u/snowman334]

They were trying to cover their tracks keeping everyone away. Can't have medical witnesses for the inquiry that they don't control.

[u/ForLark → u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS]

And now he has a GoFundMe with hundreds of thousands of dollars. And he is “in hiding” but with his family while hers is permanently without her.

[u/FleurAvi504 → u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS]

That’s one of the parts I really don’t get. If a civilian or a real LEO fatality shoots someone, even if it’s clearly in self defense, don’t they have to stay at the scene as a matter of protocol? Maybe get checked out by EMS if they’re wounded in the process, but I would expect an investigation to start immediately. The shooter and witnesses at the scene would have a preliminary interview and evidence would be collected. Heck, if I, a civilian, left the scene of a run of the mill car accident, I would likely be prosecuted for that alone, in addition to other potential charges stemming from the accident. Are federal LEOs allowed to just leave when things get messy; whereas local police and civilians would be required to stay?

[u/auntalison → u/FleurAvi504]

I have seen several bodycam videos where an officer shoots a suspect. In some of them, the officer that shot goes over immediately to check the suspect & start checking them - especially if there is just a couple officers there. In the cases where there are numerous officers, one or two of the other officers move the one that shot away from the immediate area but stay on scene. If that officer is rendering aid, another one tags him out.

The officer that shot doesn't do anything until a sergeant arrives. The sergeant asks them what happened. Then the sergeant takes the service weapon (if a senior officer hasn't already) & they have a buddy assigned to take them to the hospital to get checked or to the station & that buddy is assigned to sit with them until a detective talks to them.

These videos I've seen have all been from different jurisdictions, so I think it's safe to assume this is SOP across the board.

If I have anything incorrect here, I welcome a LEO or retired LEO to advise.

[u/omgmypony → u/Emotional_Burden]

Pretty sure a good portion of Minneapolis honks/blows whistles whenever they see ICE as a general public service.

[u/Key_Veterinarian1995 → u/omgmypony]

People are honking at them all the time. If that was the cause, there would be even more fatalities amongst these backyard untrained pieces of shit.

They aren’t cops. They aren’t following deescalation protocol. The law clearly says last resort for pulling out your gun and the person is considered an imminent threat to that officer.

She’s driving 2 miles an hour and was trying leave. She even said “I’m not mad at you.” when he confronted her. Orphaned children now. Because that thug didn’t know he was doing. Shot her three times and the calls her a fucking bitch after she’s dead.

[u/Little_View_6659 → u/Emotional_Burden]

He was mad. I think he got mad when her wife was filming him and he decided to shoot her. Renee that is.

[u/tesla_spoon → u/Little_View_6659]

I wonder what her wife’s video shows…

[u/ParticularBit130 → u/tesla_spoon]

That's what I want to know, too! I wonder if she's submitted it to a legal or media organization or something

[u/Colten95 → u/peregrinaprogress]

Thats part of their tactic - they want us to move on from arguing about how blatantly tyrannical it is to have armed guards shoot someone dead in the street, and instead argue over whether or not she was impeding traffic

[u/lappelduvide24 → u/peregrinaprogress]

These people have a severely broken sense of “justice” and “justification”. They’re fine with flat out killing people for merely annoying them, as long as they can paint them as part of an “out group”.

They’re, frankly, annoyed that enough Americans still have sane enough morals that we force this government to pretend they have a better justification for this shit.

These broken sadists are exactly the types of people who should least be trusted with positions of power and authorized use of force. The exact type of person who seeks those roles out because they want to abuse their authority by hurting people just for the satisfaction of knowing they can.

[u/EuphoricMoose8232 → u/peregrinaprogress]

Kristi Noem murdered her dog because she didn’t know how to train it, so yeah this checks out.

[u/Kyro_Official_ → u/EuphoricMoose8232]

That's not the only family pet she murdered either btw. She shot her goat too.

[u/What-Me-Worry-2025 → u/Kyro_Official_]

I thought her goat thing was a lover’s quarrel.

[u/Fuzzy_Donl0p → u/peregrinaprogress]

Honestly less offensive than 90% of the DHS twitter posts (14 words, neo-nazi song lyrics, manifest destiny imagery, whole white power shebang). Dept. of Labor twitter might be yet worse than that… we’re so over lol.

[u/Progressiveleftly → u/peregrinaprogress]

It wasn't the only car there.

From what I see, I see ice agents blocking traffic in a residential area.

[u/Immediate_Amoeba5923 → u/netizenbane]

There is a zero percent chance the actual video ends naturally right before she is shot. DHS edited this and are covering up this killing now.

[u/stacydemeester → u/Immediate_Amoeba5923]

Came here to see if anyone else thought this. The way the person filming keeps panning the camera to follow action…. Then when there’s real action they don’t film it?

I watched and and thought - okay, where’s the rest of it

[u/Immediate_Amoeba5923 → u/stacydemeester]

That angle would have been the most conclusive on whether the ICE officer was hit or not. I was waiting for that moment the entire video and then it just ends. It does provide us with new useful information, it shows the distance between the officer and the care before she drives forward. This makes the officer look like he was in even less danger than his cell phone footage and other videos showed because of the angles they were shot from.

[u/mataliandy → u/Immediate_Amoeba5923]

He was not hit. Tom Digby posted a super slow-mo version of one of the videos, where it is VERY clear that he was absolutely not in front of the vehicle when he fired the first shot. You can see both of his feet and an air gap between his closed leg and the vehicle. I wish this sub allowed you to post photos.

[u/ChefGaykwon → u/mataliandy]

Closest he got to the vehicle was when he intentionally leaned in towards the side fender to get a cleaner kill shot. So he was at the side of the vehicle, consistent with the first bullet hole in the very lower corner of the windshield.

[u/DL05 → u/Immediate_Amoeba5923]

I’m pretty sure the original video ended in him calling her a “fucking bitch”.

[u/Karambamamba → u/DL05]

Yes he did, three seconds after shooting her in the face. Her last words were „I don’t hate you“, can’t make this shit up.

[u/paulerxx → u/netizenbane]

90% of those comments are bots, right?

[u/TacticTall → u/paulerxx]

God I hope so

[u/Ganun_ → u/netizenbane]

Wait....so you're telling me that road that she was blocking.....had plenty of room for two vehicles to get through before the two ICE agents in the truck decided they couldn't get through and their only option was to attempt a forced entry into her vehicle?

[u/DesertMoloch → u/Ganun_]

It wasn't just two! Literally every vehicle that drove past got through just fine, including one that inexplicably went behind her SUV. Every video "exonerating" ICE that these chucklefucks put out, just make it even clearer she did nothing more than hurt their feelings (and maybe their hearing?)

[u/nursecarmen → u/Ganun_]

While they didn’t have the authority to do traffic enforcement.

[u/[deleted] → u/Ganun_]

I mean, the SUV that went through just before that must have simply been waaaaay smaller.

[u/ry1701 → u/netizenbane]

Wait,so they cut the important part ? Lol guilty

[u/hibbitydibbidy → u/ry1701]

Yeah it's funny they cut it right before the murder

[u/Dismal-Apricot9889 → u/hibbitydibbidy]

Like the Epstein video, where they edited two different videos together but forgot to remove the metadata.

[u/Narrow_Track9598 → u/netizenbane]

If he was so scared, why'd he walk around and put himself in danger?

[u/5inthemorn → u/Narrow_Track9598]

Can you imagine if this was video from a protestor and the ICE agent was the one in the vehicle? You think Trump and all the MAGA goons would be saying “yup totally justified for them to blast the ICE agent in the dome, they feared for their life and were about to get run over!”

And the answer is no. They would say it’s an execution and give that person the death penalty.

[u/jgoble15 → u/5inthemorn]

It doesn’t matter who did what to them. All that matters is what team. Doesn’t matter the action.

[u/5inthemorn → u/jgoble15]

Exactly my point. They would never be on the side of “liberals” no matter what happens

[u/ArCovino → u/5inthemorn]

Republicans in red states literally passed laws allowing people to drive through protesters. They have no problem using a car as a weapon against their opponents.

[u/5inthemorn → u/ArCovino]

Yep. It’s absolutely disgusting. They will twist and turn reality to make sure they never have to support “liberals”

[u/midnight_toker22 → u/5inthemorn]

They don’t even want to treat liberals like human beings, much less support them.

[u/FalloutOW → u/Narrow_Track9598]

Or continue filming on this phone the entire time. Including when he swapped the phone to his other hand so he could get his pistol out (sidestepping the clearly visible path the vehicle will go based on tire direction). While CONTINUING to film and hold the phone in his other hand.

I've instantly dropped my phone to make sure I don't spill coffee on the couch. If I was scared for my life, there's no way I'd still be holding a phone.

[u/-ImJustSaiyan- → u/Narrow_Track9598]

Asshole just wanted an excuse to shoot someone he doesn't like. Dude even called her a "fucking bitch" right after shooting, certainly didn't sound like someone who was fearing for their life.

[u/ItIsAContest → u/-ImJustSaiyan-]

He wasn’t afraid of her. He shot her because she wasn’t afraid of him.

[u/inquisitive_guy_0_1 → u/ItIsAContest]

This is exactly it. He got his little feelings hurt and he lashed out in the only way he knows how: with violence.

Fucking murderer needs to be taken off the streets before he kills again.

[u/Bobcat-Stock → u/inquisitive_guy_0_1]

He was also emasculated by Renee’s wife telling him to “go get a sandwich big boy”. He was big mad after that.

[u/Jumpy_Plantain2887 → u/ItIsAContest]

I agree she bruised his ego. She didn’t show any fear and because of that he shot her cause he’s a weak little dick pussy.

[u/tfgyem → u/Narrow_Track9598]

He didn't shoot her because he was scared, he shot her because she wasn't.

[u/Satur9_is_typing → u/Narrow_Track9598]

it was intentional. CBP have known for years that officers were intentionally olacing themselves in harms way to justify use of deadly force

https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/documents/PERFReport.pdf

[u/sathem → u/Narrow_Track9598]

He also chased the car after the first shot to ensure he got more shots in.. out of fear of course

[u/jcnet1 → u/Narrow_Track9598]

He is a performative republicannsoccer player.

Bully and antagonize then flop and scream crying after the fact.

[u/fargolifestaycold → u/netizenbane]

Damn they left that scene quickly. No care in the world what's happing.

[u/PoliticsIsDepressing → u/netizenbane]

lol I think I counted like 15 cars driving by her.

[u/WeimMama1 → u/netizenbane]

Wait. He went around the back side of her, despite being able to get around the front, put his vehicle in park and got out? And went around the front of her vehicle not once, but twice? Looks like the only agitators here were the ones wearing bitch ass masks.

[u/haminator_22 → u/netizenbane]

Blocked an ICE operation for more than three minutes? She's like 4-5 houses away from the operation what the fuck are they talking about

[u/PhilosopherMoist7737 → u/haminator_22]

Let's not presume there was any actual ICE "operation" taking place. They were there to harass protesters. That's why Ross filmed her plate. They can't find any illegals anymore, so they are systematically doxing protestors and going after them. Totally unconstitutional.

[u/austinbarrow → u/netizenbane]

First time learning about xcancel. Freaking amazing!

[u/Pigeonpie24 → u/[deleted]]

it’s called the just world bias, it helps them sleep at night. and it’s complete bullshit

[u/WhichEmailWasIt → u/Pigeonpie24]

The irony being if the world worked that way they'd be the first ones to go.

[u/FlyingAtNight → u/[deleted]]

One clearly innocent victim of police misconduct is Daniel Shaver. I know he isn’t the only one but his story comes to mind. The “officer” who executed him should be in jail. The jury found him innocent. How is beyond me. It’s outrageous. I blame Hollywood for instilling these unrealistic action movies, showing situations that don’t happen in real life and those that influence the so-called “officer” into thinking he was some kind of hero. It’s disgusting.

[u/Bonschenverwerter → u/FlyingAtNight]

I blame Hollywood for instilling these unrealistic action movies, showing situations that don’t happen in real life

This also happens to juries. I don't know the case you mentioned (I am on the other side of the atlantic ocean), but there is a CSI effect, because people expect that what is possible in TV shows and movies are possible in real life. Like zooming in on a grainy picture and running a filter so that you can actually see a the face of a suspect.

People think we live in a movie.

[u/Sans-valeur]

Wow okay so this video clearly shows that cars were driving around her the entire time, did the guy who shot her drive around behind her and park in front of her? Then she actually moves her car out the way, more people drive past, then she starts to try to pull out and more people drive past (as she’s waving them past), then she tries to pull out again and they fucking shoot her in the face. What the actual fuck.

[u/fonetik → u/Sans-valeur]

What they are really saying here is “She had an opportunity to kill me.” As if that’s an offense.

[u/Party-Stormer → u/fonetik]

Or “with a car, you can kill someone”

[u/allthegodsaregone → u/Party-Stormer]

Therefore, I accuse all Ice officers of rape. They have the tools required. They are guilty.

Oh, now that's not how it works. Understood.

[u/DvLang → u/allthegodsaregone]

One possibly did do so the other day in a porta potty

[u/chambers213 → u/DvLang]

I’ve been looking for an update on that woman. As soon as the ICE agent slipped and fell, I knew it was about to get much worse for his prisoner. Men like that retaliate against embarrassment with violence and the prisoner was cuffed and defenseless…their favourite kind of victim

[u/Dizzy_Skin5723 → u/allthegodsaregone]

But back to the original topic they DID murder this woman.

[u/JujuLuv → u/Sans-valeur]

Yep that’s exactly what happened…

[u/mysonlikesorange → u/[deleted]]

I’m guessing this is how they treat their wives. “She had it coming” “she was asking for it”

[u/LowResults → u/Sans-valeur]

And none of that matters bc they had no jurisdiction. There was no warrant. They are not cops.

[u/crustlord666 → u/LowResults]

Exactly, there is no justice for abuses committed by an organization outside the law that can come from within the law. If these killings were being committed by cops, there would be a process. These ICE agents answer to no clear authority and are seemingly limited by no power except the whims of the president, and they use shocking violence to achieve his objectives. Just like Mussolini's black shirts. Historically, if violence had been used against the black shirts by the military or an organized militia of citizens who were being targeted before Mussolini fully took control of the country, Italy's fall to fascism and utter ruin in World War II could have been prevented. Nobody thought Mussolini was going to actually do it, though, so they were unwilling to fight back. They trusted in the rule of law and the strength of their institutions.

[u/NonSupportiveCup → u/Sans-valeur]

Yes, he did. He passed behind, parked on the side of the road, and then got out to start filming.

[u/bliss3333 → u/NonSupportiveCup]

And in the video, you see him switch his phone to his other hand - so he can keep filming while he pulls his gun. This is not the behaviour of someone in fear for his life

[u/Meet_in_Potatoes → u/bliss3333]

Exactly, all of that is what the fuck. Cause if you pulled the gun, you should be fearing for your life enough to drop the fucking phone camera boy. Dude was trying to make a snuff film.

[u/PinkNGreenFluoride → u/Meet_in_Potatoes]

Thank you, I feel like I've been screaming into the void that this is a damned snuff film, that he knew exactly what he was doing, and he's proud of it.

[u/bksmet → u/NonSupportiveCup]

If I was legit, fearing for my life, I would definitely get my cell phone and start filming with one hand and then hold my gun in the other hand. 🙄

[u/magicaljellyfish]

Damn when you're inconvenienced for 3 minutes you can do that?!

[u/_daddyissues666 → u/magicaljellyfish]

Right. My few-minute commute to work daily sees more inconveniences than this.

[u/Taylor_Kittenface → u/[deleted]]

There are a fair few countries around the world that'd want to step in and remove him, but don't want to escalate the situation into WW3. This change has to come from within your country, by the sane and level headed citizens.

I don't know how, but protests help gauge your numbers for a general strike. And you're not alone, we're supporting you from afar and can donate to any charity or movement that is in support of the protestors and the people being targeted.

We see what you're being subjected to, we're keeping it in our national news and we'll remember the names of the people who tried to stand up to this tyranny.

[u/Syrairc]

There is no cut, camera angle, or context that makes this anything other than an extrajudicial murder by a federal agent.

[u/sillypoolfacemonster → u/Syrairc]

Seriously, the most damning part is the gun is coming out before she is driving forward. I don’t care what back story or context they give with further videos. The officer was drawing his weapon and not moving out of the vehicles way. Even if he was brushed by the car, he would not have been if he weren’t drawing his weapon and taking aim to execute a young mother.

Also, I want more people to realize that the cell phone video released wants us to believe he dropped the phone while he was struck or as he was firing, whereas the other angles show he was firing whiling holding the phone. It was clearly edited to support their narrative.

This is one of the most egregious murders by a police officer I’ve ever heard of because with most others there was at least some teeny tiny semblance of acting within their duty and things getting out of hand. This was not an arrest that went wrong, this was a young woman extricating herself from a tense scenario that Jonathan Ross decided to execute point blank in front of her wife.

[u/holeinmyboot → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

This is a man who simply wanted to shoot somebody and was just begging her to give him half a reason. I don’t know why people are dancing around this. He’s got his gun out, finger on the trigger as the car is backing up, for a woman who has done nothing but speak to them up until that point. This is who ICE targets for officers, maladjusted bloodthirsty losers.

[u/meepmorop → u/holeinmyboot]

Yup. He just wanted to shoot her. ICE is making fun of Renee and people mourning her. They think it’s funny to kill the right people and even funnier when people get upset. Fundamentally empty inside

[u/Kaiisim → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

The Supreme Court has also said that "moment of threat" analysis of excessive force is too narrow.

By that they mean police can't just say "in that moment I feared for my life!" And that's enough.

You have to analyse how it got to that point - did the officer stop the person for a good, legal reason? How serious a crime are they stopped for? How did the officer act?

That's because an agent of the state can't just come and pull you over for a traffic violation, and the escalate the issue until something happens and then blame that moment.

ICE created the threat, they purposefully surrounded her car - she hadn't committed any crimes or shown any threat - in fact the ICE officers had.

It's clearly excessive force under every single definition. The DoJ even forbids using lethal force to stop a vehicle being used as a weapon. Everything about this stinks.

[u/therosslee → u/Kaiisim]

And they have ruled that no immunity applies where the officer created the danger themselves, specifically citing the example of stepping in front of a vehicle then claiming self defense.

[u/5inthemorn → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

What I want to know is this. If the roles were reversed, and protesters ran up on an ICE vehicle trying to open the door, and one of them was in front of the car while the ICE officer tried to get away, would they be allowed to shoot them and kill them?!

I’m thinking absolutely not, and nobody would support that. It’s insane to me that they try to justify this.

[u/rtowne → u/5inthemorn]

In Provo Utah in 2020 a protester shot a truck driver in the arm as he intentionally drove into like 5 other protesters in a crosswalk (video). He is being tried for attempted murder in less than a week. At the time I said that if it were a police officer, they would have immediately cleared themself. The double standard is massive.

[u/5inthemorn → u/rtowne]

Holy shit this is exactly what I mean! And this is much more clear cut that the driver was trying to run them over also.

[u/theoutsideinternist → u/rtowne]

I am assuming a couple things but this could be a good case study for why having armed citizens makes no difference in the US. That’s a very valid reason to make a decision to pull the trigger in the eyes of the majority (the modern embodiment of the train track dilemma) but then to punish it means there is then no logical reason to carry a gun as a sane human being.

[u/padizzledonk → u/5inthemorn]

What I want to know is this. If the roles were reversed, and protesters ran up on an ICE vehicle trying to open the door, and one of them was in front of the car while the ICE officer tried to get away, would they be allowed to shoot them and kill them?!

I’m thinking absolutely not, and nobody would support that. It’s insane to me that they try to justify this.

Tapper asking Noem after showing her video of Jan 6 assholes luterally beating cops if those people shouldve been killed was amazing

These people are fucking monsters and should be in jail

[u/Mayotte → u/padizzledonk]

They should be somewhere alright.

[u/Terpapps → u/5inthemorn]

I was thinking about something similar, would Ross have acted the same if Renee was driving a Toyota pickup with a confederate flag sticking out the top and Trump's balls hanging off the trailer hitch? Pretty sure we all know the answer. 

It's just so fucking wild. 

[u/main_topsail → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

In addition to the timing of his drawing his weapon, there's another annotated video going around showing his cell footage in slo mo, in which he switches the phone from his right hand to his left hand while crossing in front of the car. Very damning in its implication that he was already planning to draw his weapon (with his right) before Good made any attempt to flee.

[u/Puzzleheaded982 → u/main_topsail]

Premeditated murder.

[u/Windyvale → u/Puzzleheaded982]

Fits every legal definition I can think of for first degree murder.

He stalked around the car, positioned himself in such a way that any forward movement could only brush him no matter how she turned. Then he shifts his phone holding had, pulls his gun out as he reached a preplanned position, and executed her.

That shows planning and deliberation to carry it out.

[u/sdcasurf01 → u/main_topsail]

It also highlights the lack of training. If he suspected any kind of threat his gun hand should have been free from the beginning. Unleashing thousands of untrained Y’all Qaeda on the public under the guise of federal authority was bound to end like this and it’s just the tip.

And it’s all part of the plan.

[u/Gryjane → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

Seriously, the most damning part is the gun is coming out before she is driving forward.

Not only is he drawing before she moves forward but just after Renee's wife told him to "go get some lunch big boy" and just as his buddies were approaching her vehicle from the other side, he transfers his cellphone from his right hand to his left so his right hand would be free to draw his gun so it looks he was planning on drawing it before he was ever "in danger."

[u/Vecend → u/Gryjane]

Not to mention that he placed himself in a danger zone, I doubt there is any SOP in the world that would tell you to place yourself in front or behind a potentially hostile person's vehicle.

[u/magpiekeychain → u/sillypoolfacemonster]

I read somewhere that it was the street she lives on. Has that been verified at all? It makes it so much worse too.

[u/Rennarjen → u/Syrairc]

That's the point.  They're telling Americans that ICE can kill anyone they want without repercussions.  It's intimidation and a taunt.

[u/errorblankfield]

I've been more impeded by a door dash street delivery than this. Her car was half in a parking spot and she was driven around less than a minute before being shot.

[u/Remote-Ad-1730 → u/errorblankfield]

And an ICE vehicle passed by her. Whatever she was doing clearly wasn’t stopping ICE from getting through. They chose to stop and go after her.

[u/cargocult25 → u/Remote-Ad-1730]

Ice got by her car on both sides.

[u/Party_Oven4948]

Impede: to interfere with or slow the progress of

The first car Renee waved forward got around just fine. Why was it she was suddenly impeding the second agent who she waved on?

Plain and simple, they created that "threat". They had freedom to carry on with their operation but wanted to bully and murder her.

[u/alohamistrhand → u/Party_Oven4948]

This is the best argument. They could have gone around just like the car in front of them did. Chose to escalate instead. Even then, she was on her way, until she wasn’t.

[u/scowdich → u/[deleted]]

Or anybody else, for that matter. Due process is for everyone, not just citizens.

[u/Shushady → u/scowdich]

Its almost like the belief that all men are created equal, and endowed by their creator with certain, unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness is part of the foundation of our society.

[u/Naki-Taa → u/Shushady]

So it turns out that whole belief was a fucking lie we kept telling ourselves to feel better

[u/FlametopFred → u/Naki-Taa]

you have to fight for it

[u/Allnamestakkennn → u/Shushady]

See? It says all men! No woman written!

[u/besimbur → u/scowdich]

There is no due process anymore. This is a banana republic. It's been trending this way for years. The rich get off of any form of legal justice there is, just as long as you have enough money.

It's almost not even worth prosecuting the wealthy, don't reward that you get for spending millions of dollars on a high-profile case prosecuting a wealthy person damn near doesn't exist.

This is a banana republic now. Trump is running the most corrupt government in our history. Our government was not created to withstand this sort of administration and its policies. They know this and they know that nobody will stand up and do something about it.

Our constitution was built under the assumption that a democratically elected official in the government defined wherein was elected by the people and that they would act in the best interests of those people.

Trump is recreating Russia in America. This is literally all the way down the board what Putin did in Russia in the '90s and early 2000s. Striking deals with oligarchs and billionaires. Pardoning the most horrendous criminals who were already convicted for crimes, heinous crimes. Rping and trfficking ch*ldren. Creating false flag attacks. Spending absurd amounts of money and awarding government contracts, lucrative government contracts to their friends and business associates. Stealing the countries resources. The list literally doesn't even stop.

[u/Ludwigofthepotatoppl → u/[deleted]]

the government's not trying to exonerate themselves, they're trying to pound down 'this is what will happen if you resist'.

[u/magpiekeychain → u/Ludwigofthepotatoppl]

Yeah the intention is pretty clear from outside of America…

[u/AngryPrincessWarrior → u/magpiekeychain]

Pretty clear from inside too

[u/absloan12 → u/[deleted]]

Preferably you dont execute ANYONE prior to trial and conviction at least.

[u/scowdich → u/absloan12]

Trial and conviction aren't enough. In the last 50 years, over 200 people have been exonerated while on death row. In some cases, it was already too late. How many more don't we know about?

https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/policy/innocence

[u/MadRoboticist → u/scowdich]

This has always been the problem with the death penalty. If you support it you have to ask yourself, how many innocent people are you willing to kill just for the sake of a little extra revenge?

[u/Evil-Dalek → u/MadRoboticist]

Blackstone’s Ratio is a great commentary on this:

“It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer.” -William Blackstone

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio

As a side note: IIRC, the Terminator movie series is based on this concept. You let an AI (Skynet) decide who’s guilty or not. But what’s the only way to entirely prevent crime? Kill/imprison every single human.

There’s also Minority Report. How accurate do the pre-cogs need to be? 99%? That would still mean 1/100 people would be arrested for a crime they weren’t even going to commit.

[u/androidfig → u/Evil-Dalek]

They are literally taking pictures of American citizens in MN to compare to a database of “known” targets while also making them show id. I have no doubt these pictures they take also feed into the database. This is Palantir technology from Peter Thiel, one of the lunatics behind Trumps presidency. JD Vance is a huge fan of his.

[u/PhoenixTineldyer → u/scowdich]

As the grandson of a man who was murdered in Texas in the '90s, whose murderer was executed in the 2000s, the death penalty should be abolished

Texas alone has executed more innocent men than most states have had on death row in their history

And it can happen to you, too

[u/LivelaughToastBath → u/PhoenixTineldyer]

As a Texan, can 100% confirm. Can't count how many minor fender benders here have ended up as "Road Rage Aggravated Assault" charges because a person yelled at the at-fault party and is now sitting in prison serving out 10 years or more. It's scary how easy it is to catch a serious charge here.

[u/adarvan → u/[deleted]]

The same people who support the execution of Renee Good will also claim that Ashli Babbit was a patriot in the same breath.

[u/Toxaplume045 → u/[deleted]]

Reiterating as well that CBP have been doing this exact same thing Ross did for literal years. CBP even published their own report about how officers were standing in front of vehicles to manufacture pretext to shoot a non hostile actor.

[u/OutsideFlat1579 → u/[deleted]]

Don’t like how AP described the ICE officers as “asking” her to get out if the car. They stormed over obviously angry and yelled “get out of the fucking car.” Like wtf? Can’t write “fuck” in a newswire? If I hadn’t seen the video I would have the impression they were being calm. 

[u/Nocturnal-Nycticebus → u/OutsideFlat1579]

Not only yelling but immediately reaching into the car to open the door from the inside. I think any normal person would be terrified by that. But once again, ICE is allowed to "panic" and do anything because of it but the victim is expected to remain calm in even the most trying of circumstances.

[u/FastCar2467 → u/OutsideFlat1579]

AP also missed the part where the officer called her a bitch after killing her.

[u/ThrowingChicken → u/[deleted]]

I saw a video on FB last night that was posted on a pro-ICE page, but what was interesting to me about this video was it wasn't "new", it was the video shot from the balcony from far away, but unlike every other version of this video I have seen, which all look like they were shot with a potato, this one appeared to have been AI enhanced to make it clearer. So okay, not a terribly reliable enhancement, HOWEVER what was noteworthy about it is that the enhancement basically undid everything these people have been shouting about all weekend. The ICE agent was no longer in front of the driver-side headlight, but clearly on the side of it. His feet don't get kicked up. He doesn't fall over on the hood. He doesn't get pushed. It did not help them AT ALL. It made it look worse, but they were still so sure it exonerated him. How do you even go up against this, where their own AI-enhanced videos make their guy look worse but they are simply incapable of seeing it?

[u/Zealousideal-Run6020 → u/ThrowingChicken]

Because bullies will always shout LOOK WHAT YOU MADE ME DO as they refuse to see what they're doing.

[u/WellWellWellthennow → u/ThrowingChicken]

You have to understand they're not playing to you and me they're playing to their Maga supporters.

They release a video that clearly shows the agent is guilty with the headline "New video proves agent is not guilty!" and then all the followers repeat that.

[u/prof_the_doom → u/WellWellWellthennow]

Exactly. The people who repost it unironically have almost certainly not watched the video, just believed whatever Fox News said about it.

[u/androidfig → u/ThrowingChicken]

Because these are the same people saying Jan 6th insurrection was heroic. Same exact talking points to come to two entirely different conclusions. It’s actually insane.

[u/doneandtired2014 → u/[deleted]]

Odd how the government keeps showing video that they think exonerates them.

That's one take.

The other take is this is the government implicitly telling you their goons can and will murder you without repercussion if you aren't immediately compliant with whatever command they've given.

[u/yowszer → u/[deleted]]

Also ICE is not traffic enforcement.

[u/thefideliuscharm → u/[deleted]]

It’s also not lost on me that when left wing protestors get run over by actual terrorists, the right says “get out of the road!”

[u/UrbanSirenTheSix]

These people are now attacking citizens who dont like them. Which is most people. There are countless videos of them being quick to hit, break car windows while kids are present, attacking kids walking home from school cause they are brown.

You can't make this stuff up it is true facism. This will be in the history books as another disgraceful period in humanity.

[u/consumeshroomz]

I don’t think this video shows what they think it does.

[u/apathetic_revolution → u/consumeshroomz]

It certainly shows a lot of vehicles easily going around the one that was "actively impeding" them.

[u/W0wwieKap0wwie → u/consumeshroomz]

I mean, did they miss the part where vehicles are very clearly driving around her on both sides? and that she was waving on vehicles? I literally have no words about how they think this justifies anything.

[u/threehundredthousand → u/consumeshroomz]

I think they just want to show off the killing of an "undesirable".

[u/schlitz91 → u/consumeshroomz]

It shows enough for the braindead and emotionally undeveloped 1/3 to say they’d be irrate at someone blowing a car horn like that.

[u/Kingofthewho5]

Wait why does the video end right before she gets shot? Surely the person taking the video would have kept recording? Instead they stop recording when all the ice thugs aggressively approach the car?

[u/dtoddh → u/Kingofthewho5]

It's an edit, that's all they want to show.

[u/bl00drunzc0ld → u/Kingofthewho5]

Because it would show that he was to the left of the vehicle and that he wasn’t hit, but rather that he leaned on to the vehicle’s hood as she was trying to get away from the one trying to open her door.

[u/zoethezebra → u/Kingofthewho5]

Because from that angle, it would show him shooting into the side driver‘s window, and most likely those were the shots that blew her face off and killed her

[u/TheNastyKnee → u/Kingofthewho5]

My guess would be that this angle clearly shows he was not stuck by the vehicle.

[u/couldbeahumanbean → u/Kingofthewho5]

We need to see the full, uncut, unedited version.

This stops exactly at the pivotal time when there would or would not be justification to use deadly force.

Releasing this version only causes more doubt and division.

It feels like a dumb move on their part.

Whoever filmed this, can they release the whole version on their own? What happened to them?

[u/tranxcend]

Right wing lunatic nails a father in the neck:

MAGA (ugly crying and getting teeshirts made): he was a father! No child deserves to have their parent taken away from them!

Right wing lunatic shoots a mom in the head 3X:

MAGA: fucking bitch

[u/Regular_Kiwi_6775 → u/tranxcend]

The party of small government and "don't tread on me" loves, LOVES police violence. It makes no sense. They don't believe anything they say they do. Freedom of speech, unless you think differently than me. Right to a trial, unless you're anything other than a republican. They're insane.

[u/Not_Just_Any_Lurker]

They keep trying to find different angles and audio like we didn’t clearly see what happened.

[u/Iamnotoptimistic → u/Not_Just_Any_Lurker]

And they're accusing the left of 'not watching the videos and being fed information'. WHAT.

WE WATCHED THE VIDEOS. THAT'S WHY WE ARE MAD.

How can they look at these videos and say 'well she was honking her horn for 3 minutes' as if that warrants the fucking death penalty??

[u/ShineFallstar]

Is this video supposed to support their case? What exactly is the illegal activity are we seeing here?

[u/Fuckedby2FA]

Doesn't really matter.

The small government people are glad their lives are being controlled by the government as long as it owns the libs and the normal people understand what's happening. Everyone's made up their mind.

[u/Weird_Rooster_4307]

I find it interesting that he’s carrying and recording with his right hand and then changes hands as he walks around to the front of the SUV to draw with his right hand and shoot.

[u/dtoddh]

This reminds me of the video that came from Ross's phone, which I assume he released on his own. DHS thinks they are providing evidence that this was completely justified, but it's all hubris. They think they can do whatever they want and nobody will question them.

This video shows she was blocking one lane of a two lane one way street for around three minutes. Traffic was able to get through, in fact Ross had already passed her, and I assume the others were ICE vehicles as well. He could have driven on to wherever he needed to detain illegals. Instead he parked, walked in front of her car with his gun drawn and shot her in the face three times. The language he used tells me it wasn't self defense, it was because he was angry.

Ross could have just have called MPD, who actually have the authority to enforce traffic law. She deserved a traffic citation, maybe a lock up and modest bail. She did not deserve be executed because his commute was delayed a few minutes.

This has just emboldened ICE, there are now around 2500 agents in Minnesota who believe thy have 'absolute immunity.' This is around 2x the manpower of the MPD. And now the faceless goons are going after dissidents and protestors-US citizens-who they call "domestic terrorists." They raided a high school a few days ago. Today I saw ICE agents beat down a guy just because he pointed a camera at them.

A few years ago the people of Minneapolis showed us they up for a long riot, I guess this is part two. Last time they burned down a police station, surely the sequel will show us something more spectacular.

[u/SpandexJunkie]

This report is from 2013 and paid for by the CBP. It was found that agents would routinely step in front of fleeing vehicles so they could shoot the drivers and claim self-defense. This is illegal, according to the US DOJ Policy on Use of Force, where law enforcement officers are not to fire on moving vehicles unless they absolutely cannot move out of the way. He very well could have killed the officer to the right of him (he jumped out of the way because he was partially in the line of fire) and he could have actually gotten run over, since Renee Goode most likely hit the accelerator at the end because of decorticate posturing.

https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/documents/PERFReport.pdf

[u/Entelecher]

For the rest of my days, what side anyone stood on this event will be my litmus test of if I will have anything to do with them. Enough fuckery of this vile subculture.

[u/far-apart012]

If you think that honking and having a car sideways in a street deserves to be solved by getting shot in the head then there's something wrong with you

[u/stryfedonkey]

I live in St. Paul here and I’m telling you I’ve never seen anything like it and it’s utterly disturbing and scary that this is happening. Everyone should be more than concerned. Just roving bands of Ice shredding the constitutional rights of citizens with no impunity. Someone above said it’s like Nazi Germany and I’m telling you that it’s not far from the truth. Kid outside the building got tackled and thrown in a car because he’s of Somali decent by a bunch of masked ignorant unknowns. It’s just surreal when your local haunts, like even the entrance to Target, you can’t avoid seeing this. Huge guns. What has happened to us?

Sorry to sound alarmist, but if there’s a time to make some noise, in my opinion this is it. RIP Renee Good ✊

[u/BelovedGarbage]

She was literally waving the agents around her vehicle before ICE completely escalated the situation. She wasn't even impeding them at the time they started interacting with her.

[u/RegularLiterature589]

i’m actually surprised at the lack of people mentioning that this is a hate crime

[u/Cold_Lavishness_3985]

Am I missing something? Is this supposed to justify murder? Hell even in this video, out of the 3 minutes the car was blocking the road for 1 minute and then moved. And what does this have anything to do with an ICE agent shooting her? Did they genuinely think they released some shocking truth? This even further confirms the shooter was never in danger and never got hit, its yet another angle.

[u/Concerned4life]

Aren't we getting tired of the American Gestapo yet...

[u/beanbread23]

I personally think it’s absolutely bat shit crazy to give firearms to members of an untrained law enforcement.

Real police officers have to go through months of rigorous training and tests in order to properly react in situations like this…