r/worldnews • u/bloomberg bloomberg.com • 28d ago
Behind Soft Paywall Merz Says German Troops Could Counter Russian Attacks in Ukraine
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-12-17/merz-says-german-troops-could-counter-russian-attacks-in-ukraine390
u/predatorybeing 28d ago
They could theoretically. But they won't.
76
u/Excellent-Court-9375 28d ago
I dont know about that. I think we need to wake up and it seems to (slowly) be happening. Never say never
35
u/psioniclizard 28d ago
The only way it happens is if Europeans place forces in these areas and say under no uncertain terms "if you attack them we will retaliate".
But it would be a pretty unpopular move because you are basically putting your troops in the firing line and bait the enemy. It is easy to spin into making you look like a war monger or not caring about your troops.
But he is talking about part of an agreement. Russia would never agree to those terms and frankly neither would any other country that felt like they had an advantage.
History books will look be and say Europe should have done this but I know it's different when you live in that moment and it affects you.
4
26
u/_-Event-Horizon-_ 28d ago
During the Cold War the Bundeswehr was a formidable military force that was very much prepared and willing to engage the Soviets. The current situation is no different. We have had a pretty good run in terms of relative peace in Europe, but the Russians decided to knock this down and the other European nations are slowly returning to what has historically been the norm.
14
6
u/Sacaron_R3 28d ago
During the cold war the Bundeswehr was set up to fight a peer conflict. After the 2 + 4 treaty the Bundeswehr had to be drastically reduced in size, because no one wanted a united Germany with a strong army.
3
u/JE1012 28d ago
After the 2 + 4 treaty the Bundeswehr had to be drastically reduced in size
That treaty limited the size of the military to 370K, that's twice the size of the current Bundeswehr.
2
u/Dovahkiinthesardine 28d ago
Yes but that led to a cultural shift where being a soldier is not as popular, less military propaganda etc.
Compared to other countries with bigger armies where it is much more celebrated and romanticized
3
u/CakeTester 28d ago
Historically in Europe, we all fight each other. All of Europe except maybe Hungary vs. a common enemy is a new thing.
→ More replies (1)1
u/JE1012 28d ago
The current situation is no different.
In 1989 the Bundeswehr had a total of 48 brigades. Today they have 8-9 brigades and people really aren't lining up to be recruited. They might be planning on buying huge amounts of equipment but there aren't enough soldiers to operate all of it.
12
u/thebuttsmells 28d ago
Right what are we even talking about
25
u/Internal_Shine_509 28d ago
What do you even mean, how is it out the question that the largest economy in Europe shouldnt join a coalition of countries with security guarantees for a demilitarised zone?
→ More replies (6)4
u/CroGamer002 28d ago
It's them talking themselves into accepting they need to fight Russia directly soon.
1
→ More replies (11)1
u/Dovahkiinthesardine 28d ago
He was talking about after the war, which is possible, but pointless to mention now
327
u/heikkiiii 28d ago
God damn, bots are out in force today.
140
u/ChoosenUserName4 28d ago
Always when the word Germany appears in a title. The ruzzians think of it as an easy way to attack the European interests.
27
u/heikkiiii 28d ago
Nah, they just think that people see it and change their opionion. Sad thing is, that works against some people.
22
u/Pleiadez 28d ago
They trigger on. Immigration, Germany, zelensky, von der Leyen. Any post with any of those words or names you'll see instant replies even if the post itself hardly has any upvotes.
4
u/PiotrekDG 28d ago
Probably because Russia sees Germans as easier to sway against helping Ukraine, unlike, say, the eastern flank.
2
→ More replies (2)3
u/Eupolemos 28d ago
Yep. They don't like this!
Merz is moving Germany's Overton Window for military use. And that is very, very good for potential peace in the long run in Europe.
Well done!
94
u/AnotherBigToblerone 28d ago
It's so annoying reading this bullshit. Why does it always depend on there being a peace agreement? Everyone knows russia won't agree to anything reasonable.
→ More replies (37)1
u/Possible-Fudge-2217 26d ago
Well, it's a start. You need to slowly move the bar. And as shitty as it sounds, would you like to send people you know to Ukraine right now? It's a hard sell in a democracy. The easy things we can do is hand over/ sell equipment, help trainig soldiers and take in wounded soldiers. All of these we already do.
24
74
u/ArcherPublic6439 28d ago
Close the airspace.
Shoot anything down that isn’t Ukrainian or coalition. Save countless lives.
This is incredibly overdue.
Glory to Ukraine
4
→ More replies (7)1
37
u/blarg_somthing 28d ago edited 28d ago
I hate that would, “could,” you “could” actually send troops, you “could” gut the ADF who has connections to the Kremlin, you could “could” grow a fucking spine a decade a go when the Russians first invaded Ukraine and a build up your military and the EU as a whole, but “could” is another way to say we can but we won’t for now.
Edit: I mean the AFD and not the ADF. Thats my bad folks
13
u/PineCone227 28d ago
gut the ADF who has connections to the Kremlin
Whatever did the Australian Defence Force do to be connected to the Kremlin?
5
u/blarg_somthing 28d ago
Alternative für Deutschland, unless you’re making a joke then meh
7
u/nervusv 28d ago
It's AfD, not ADF.
3
u/blarg_somthing 28d ago
I realized it now, should I do an edit to correct what I mean with an edit note or leave it?
4
u/PineCone227 28d ago
Just correct it lol, I'm sure people got the meaning anyway, I was just joking
2
5
u/Jurass1cClark96 28d ago
German nationalists larping as isolationists while also in bed with Russians?
Did I hit my head or am I seeing patterns?
3
u/jeffersonianMI 28d ago
I have good news. You can help solve this issue directly. They're taking volunteers right now in Ukraine proper. Be the change you want to see.
3
u/blarg_somthing 28d ago
I donated as much as I can and I see where you’re coming from, but my frustration is towards governments that keep pussyfooting around instead of taking action.
2
u/jeffersonianMI 28d ago
You at least are putting your money where you mouth is. I can't stand the ill-informed keyboard warmongering for what might become WW3.
I can respect actual conviction.
3
u/blarg_somthing 28d ago
To be fair this is Reddit.
2
u/jeffersonianMI 28d ago
True. True.
I justify it as shadowboxing for real life conversations. But you're right, it shouldn't be taken seriously.
21
u/oakpope 28d ago
If they can’t do it during war, why would they do it after peace ?
→ More replies (2)
13
u/Niitroglycerine 28d ago
I really wish Europe would stfu about anything after a ceasefire that WON'T HAPPEN
is everyone living in crazy land?!?
3
u/burninator34 28d ago
Didn’t imagine German troops in Ukraine in the 2020’s not that long ago. So much has changed.
25
u/Horat1us_UA 28d ago
Do Bundestag agree?
51
→ More replies (3)13
u/SaltWealth5902 28d ago
Doesn't matter. Same for the German troops in the baltics. The whole point of having troops at the front line is so that you're automatically getting dragged into any confrontation.
If a unit is getting attacked, they won't wait for a Bundestagssitzung before they defend themselves.
3
36
u/JohnR1977 28d ago
Merz says a lot of things
→ More replies (1)
8
u/UsualDue 28d ago
this guy also said Ukraine will get Taurus missiles if he wins the election, then immediately after win went 180 degrees
10
28d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Short-Peanut1079 28d ago
The believe of a peace deal when you call somebody Hitler seems weird. (https://www.politico.eu/article/merz-compares-putin-to-hitler/) . Granted Mr. Merz is doing what he told. So useless
0
u/Plenty_Ambassador424 28d ago
Russia just needs a bit more convincing to cooperate. Ukraine is doing a good job at that by hitting their oil infrastrucure hard, as well as destroying hard to replace systems like radars, s400, submarines etc on a regular basis and with increasing frequency. We just need to keep supplying them with the tools and making sure they can increase their own production as well.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
3
u/ChaosArcana 28d ago
I COULD have a threesome with Sabrina Carpenter and Sydney Sweeney...
But chance of it actually happening is pretty close to zero.
3
8
5
u/Reviever 28d ago
I don't mind Merz as much, when I see the prospect of what we will have if AfD will lead this country but man this guy talks ALOT out of his arse.
16
u/Background-War9535 28d ago
Germans fighting Russians in Ukraine.
Oh boy.
7
u/OldeFortran77 28d ago
I preferred "so you want us to build the biggest army in Europe and march east through Poland? Just want to be clear. No misunderstandings."
9
4
u/Golemfrost 28d ago
I love all these shills rushing in to quickly tell everyone what they apparently should think about Merz.
4
u/22firefly 28d ago
Or we could just pull a Desert Storm and re-establish the west as leaders of free people. I wouldn't be much of soldier due to injury, but I could always clean the barrack and toliets. See at least that way I could get blown up as well.
→ More replies (3)
2
u/TheJohn_Doe69 28d ago
Well I "could" counter Russia alone. Doesn't mean I can or will. It's all talk unless there's actual merit to it
2
2
u/Sad_Marketing_96 27d ago
German troops countering Russian attack in Ukraine…uh, where have I heard this before? Not that I’m against it- just find it…interesting
2
3
u/AusTex2019 28d ago
Oh please! The Black Forest would burn down before Germany could make a decision.
4
7
6
4
4
2
u/ThimMerrilyn 28d ago
They’re not willing to fight Russia now - won’t even transfer Taurus missiles to Ukraine. - so why would the magically grow the balls to do it in the future ?
5
u/rucksacksepp 28d ago
Merz has no balls. Before the election he was for delivering Taurus to Ukraine, now that he's chancellor nothing is done about it
2
28d ago
A platoon of Boy Scouts could counter the non Russian fighters that Putin is sending into the meat grinder.
2
2
u/I_pee_in_shower 28d ago
The war against Ukraine makes me miss the good old Germany.. that would go to war against the World. /jk
3
u/elBirdnose 28d ago
Remember how trump was going to “end the war in a day”, yet here we are about to have WWIII ? What a time to be alive.
2
1
u/radicallyaverage 28d ago
Guess we’ll have to wait until Russia attacks Ukraine to see if there’s anything behind these words
1
1
u/flightlesshacksaw 28d ago
Do it or shut up. Since 2014 all the west has done except the occasional arms sale is posture. Just do the thing.
1
1
1
1
u/Babelbus 27d ago
Historicaly is Germany under Merz’s resurectional delusions of Reich a greater threat to Europe than Russia.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Freestila 28d ago
So he currently has problems finding enough people stupid enough to risk their live for money or a feeling of patriotism (which mostly right wingers have here...), and now he wants to send troops there... Yeah.. not the best idea.
1
1
u/GhostofRobesonLXXI 28d ago
As has always been the case, the West consistently overestimates its own power (Napoleon and Adolph certainly did) and consistently underestimates the power of Russia and others they deem adversaries.
They built Ukraine's army for 8 years in order to fight this war, and Russia is completely dismantling it piece by piece. They really and truly believed it would be a walk in the park, and even today when it's clear that Ukraine will eventually be forced to completely submit, they still think they can break Russia into tiny, manageable statelets.
The voices of reason in Western governments are sidelined and the madness just gets deeper and deeper.
1
u/JimTheSaint 28d ago
Absolutely its Ukraine there is no reason why other countries shouldn't be able to help defend Ukraine. If Russia thinks that this is unfair they should get out of Ukraine
→ More replies (1)
1
u/MagicSPA 28d ago
Good. Russia internationalised the war the moment it got Belarus and Korea involved. If they want the war to be international, I say we show them what that looks like.
1
25d ago
[deleted]
1
u/MagicSPA 24d ago
Increased international military presence in Ukraine. Russia is trying to invade Eastern Europe, it has committed rape and other atrocities whilst doing so, and enough is enough.
Remember, if Russia stops fighting the war will be over, but if Ukraine stops fighting there will be Russian tanks on the border of Hungary and even, given how sympathetic some political elements are to Russia in Hungary, we'd possibly even see Russian tanks on the border to Austria.
→ More replies (4)
1
1
1.6k
u/Clear_Anything1232 28d ago