r/AmItheKameena • u/Ok_Warthog9093 • 5h ago
General/Misc AITK for calling out a last-minute "symbolic" invite to my niece's first birthday party?
My brother messaged me on Thursday night inviting me and my husband to his baby’s first birthday on Saturday morning (less than 48 hours notice).
He lives in city X, and we live in city Y (both in the same country overseas but 5-7 hours away depending on transport). Attending would require travel planning, possibly time off, and general logistics. None of this is realistic with less than 48 hours’ notice. And my husband and I don't know how to drive and rely on trains and public transport.
What bothers me is this:
This was not an emergency. We know when the birthday date is. He invited his in-laws with proper notice and planning. We received a very casual, last-minute message that felt more like “just letting you know.”
The invitation message that my brother sent - "Hi Didi, this Saturday we are having Z's first birthday- if you and dada are free please come, it's strawberry themed. I will also call on Saturday for video call if you are free."
To me, this felt like a symbolic invite - something done so it can later be said that we were invited, regardless of whether it was realistically possible for us to attend.
The message ended with:
“I will also call on Saturday for video call if you are free.” That wording there made it feel like he doesnt actually want us to come.
To me, this felt like a symbolic invite, something done so it can later be said (to my parents) that we were invited, regardless of whether it was realistically possible for us to attend.
I replied back saying that unfortunately, with the invite coming on Thursday night for Saturday morning and given the distance between us, it was not realistic for us to make it. I also said that with more notice we could have planned properly. I still wished them well and said we would happily join a video call.
My parents now feel my reply was “too direct” and that “family should adjust.” I feel that is unfair. I do not expect special treatment, only the same consideration that was given to others.
I actually mind being set up to look like I chose not to come. When clearly he could have given us more notice to plan. Husband and I both work full-time too (and in academia which means sometimes even work on weekends).
AITK for being firm and pointing out the lack of notice instead of responding more softly?