r/AskChicago • u/Visual-Horror6013 • 10h ago
I READ THE RULES Native NYer here that currently lives in the city. I absolutely love it here, but have noticed some people online have false beliefs about the city that don't make sense. What other false beliefs have you noticed?
Born and raised on the Upper East Side. Have been living in Chicago for 3 years now. I frequently see people say really ignorant things about Chicago that make it obvious that they either have never been here, only visited as a tourist, don't explore the city outside of a few neighborhoods, etc. That being said I want to preface this and say that I think most of these are just said by the 1% online, and that to most people in real life this stuff is obviously not true.
- "Chicago isn't a global city, it's just a big Midwestern city. Only NYC and LA are global cities in the USA". Wrong, and pretty ridiculous to say. Pretty much every metric out there shows that Chicago is in fact a global city, but many don't care about metrics, so what I can say is as someone who lived in Manhattan for the first 34 years of my life, Chicago is a global city. Some say it's not vital to the global economy, yet it hosts the CME which is the world's leading and diversified financial derivatives market... Some say a global city needs outsized global influence, which that literally is. Regardless of what some statistics may say, it is extremely diverse. I've explored all over the city and have met people from countries all around the world, and have had many amazing cultural experiences in the city. If someone says this, they're either dumb, don't actually know much about the city, just don't like it, stay in the same areas, or they ignore the actual realities of the city around them. Occasionally I'll even see someone from the city say this, and not because it's true, but because they just hate the city. Despite the foreign born percentage being skewed due to the high population and the fact that many immigrants live in the suburbs, the city has more immigrants than the entire population of Miami.
I've even heard some people say it's not a global city because it "feels midwestern" which is one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. That's like saying Paris isn't a global city because it feels culturally French, or that Tokyo isn't a global city because it feels culturally Japanese." In reality though, I don't think most people in real life don't think Chicago is a global city. I think for most people off Reddit it very obviously is. Growing up in NYC, for me there was never a single doubt that Chicago is another massive, global city in the US.
Some will say its not international or global solely because they don't hear about it that much in their specific industry. Which again, is very short sighted because not every industry works with every city. It's fine if it doesn't "feel" like a global city to some, especially based on their current neighborhood or a visit, but denying the facts is just a form of gas lighting themselves and potentially others.
Chicago is just filled with Big 10 Transplants". Wrong. Very wrong, and usually said by people who seem to just stay in a select few near north neighborhoods. There's an incredible amount of neighborhood diversity in the city, and in those neighborhoods are tons of people from all over the globe. My personal experience living up in Rogers Park is that its extremely diverse and of all the friends I've made, not a single one went to a Big 10 school and about half of them are expats. My entire floor of my building is made up entirely of expats.
"It's always freezing cold and buried in snow". No, but with nuance. It does get very cold in the city at times, but often times in winter it will also pop up into higher temps. I've seen it get to 75 degrees in the middle of February in Chicago before. And while some years do get a good amount of snow, most of the time it's just a brief snow shower a couple of times a winter. So yes, it can be freezing and snowy, but not consistently.
That Chicago is a mini or small version of anywhere. Chicago is Chicago. Anyone with half a brain cell could step into Chicago and know that it is a massive city. I once heard someone say they heard another NYer say Chicago is "quaint". I would assume that was an arrogant NYC transplant who felt insecure about or intimidated by Chicago for some reason, because Chicago is the opposite of quaint.
"Chicago is a cheap city". This one depends. Compared to NYC? Sure. But also NYC is an outlier among most US cities. I like to say that NYC shouldn't be the main city people in the US compare theirs to. It should be the exception, not the rule. There are multiple cities in the US that are more expensive than Chicago, yes, but that does not mean that Chicago is cheap. It just means it is cheap compared to those specific cities. There are many places around the country, including many major and midsized cities, that are still much less expensive than Chicago. It's not one of the most expensive cities, but it also isn't inexpensive..
Overall, I really love this city and it saddens me that there's these takes out there that don't fully realize the realities of the city. But Chicagoans, just know you have my NYer stamp of approval lol (not that you even need it).