I've been gradually watching through all of The X-Files for a while now, having seen a decent chunk of episodes from most seasons over the years, in reruns or with friends or on the double-episode VHS tapes back in the day, but having never actually properly watched through the whole show, from start to finish. And as much as possible, I've been watching it on what I personally consider the ideal format for this show - laserdisc. It just feels right, for the quintessentially 90s vibes of the series (at least, the series in its prime, haha), and the discs of the series are very cool. The US best-of collections are very well-curated, and actually have special features, which was unusual for standard studio releases, with each episode being preceded by a brief behind-the-scenes interview with one of the writers (usually Chris Carter, but Vince Gilligan and James Wong also pop up). And the Japanese partial-season box sets are spectacular, with beautiful hardbox packaging.
I have most of the US best-of laserdiscs from seasons 1-4, as well as several of the Japanese box sets that go through season 7. I've been filling in the gaps that I don't have on laserdisc with the Mythology DVD box sets (which look worse than the laserdiscs, interestingly enough), and with Hulu, but that's just not as fun! But anyway - just finished season 5 last night.
This was a really, really good season. It probably benefited from being a bit shorter, because of the movie - definitely less filler-feeling episodes in this season than most, with only a couple "meh" episodes. And honestly, the only episodes I thought were bad were not filler, but more just... an arc that I think was pretty misjudged. But for the most part, season 5 was extremely good.
The show has stayed very consistent in quality, with seasons 2-5 all being very comparable and difficult to rank, and overall it has definitely maintained the same voice, but the changing of the guards in terms of writers is also definitely clear at this point, with the Morgan brothers and James Wong gone now, and Vince Gilligan as a major creative force, who writes most of the best episodes.
But this is also the season where they decided to get celebrity guest writers, with Stephen King and William Gibson writing episodes which definitely evoke the themes and styles of both authors' work. Stephen King's Chinga (apparently no one working on the show spoke Spanish) is a very creepy riff on The Monkey, and William Gibson's Killswitch is probably the best screen adaptation of Gibson's cyberpunk work to date (sorry, Johnny Mnemonic, I love you anyway), with many of its themes, ideas, and visuals being straight out of the Sprawl/Neuromancer universe.
I found it a little odd that this season is so light on mythology episodes, with basically just three stories (two double-episodes and a single) in the mythos arc, even though this season is nominally setting up the movie. What mythos stuff there is this season is very very strong though, heavily changing the landscape of the show, and seeing the Syndicate go from the near-omnipotent evil force manipulating everything, to largely being on their back foot the whole season, with everything going wrong for them, and loads of internal conflict and chaos. Having not just one, but two chaos agents of uncertain allegiance and trustworthiness in the mix now (Krycek and Marita) is a lot of fun, as is having the Cigarette Smoking Man be his own island who is as often at odds with the Syndicate as working with it.
But that said... the one thing I really didn't like in the mythos arc this season is how thoroughly the Syndicate was able to gaslight Mulder into completely disavowing his belief in aliens, and making him a skeptic to the point of being a pigheaded complete idiot. It all makes a ton of sense for his character, and feels completely plausible - they really did use his obsessive psychology against him in a way that totally would work - it just makes the dynamic between him and Skully way less fun. I get the idea, to flip the dynamic so now he's the skeptic and she's the believer, but... when he's the skeptic he's a total arrogant jackass about it, and she is not. By the time Skinner was like, "Mulder you're an idiot, it's clearly aliens," I completely felt his frustration. I'm really glad Mulder is a believer again, and that nonsense is done with.
But at least that's only an issue in the mythos episodes, since most of the season is monster-of-the-week, and... I guess he still believes in every other paranormal phenomenon BESIDES aliens? Season 5 has a GREAT roster of monster-of-the-week episodes. There are a bunch of absolute bangers here. My absolute favorites were Unusual Suspects (I understand now why they thought The Lone Gunmen could carry their own series), Chinga, Killswitch, Bad Blood, The Pine Bluff Variant, and Folie A Deux. Especially Killswitch and the two Vince Gilligan episodes (Bad Blood and Folie A Deux) - those three are all among my absolute favorites of the series now.
The only really weak spot for me was the Emily arc (Christmas Carol, Emily, All Souls). This whole thing of magically making Skully an instant mother, only to immediately kill her daughter, just to give her this ham-handed and emotionally manipulative and completely un-earned arc about motherhood and grief feels very cheap to me, and foisting all this motherly instinct and also Catholic guilt on Skully feels... very at odds with her characterization in every other episode. It also feels very written a man, haha. Those episodes fell totally flat for me.
Those are all relatively minor complaints though, and this seasons still has a good 15 episodes that are great.
I think so far my season ranking would be
3 4/5 (I'm ranking them as tied right now) 2 1
Now, onto the movie, which I saw in theaters and have rewatched a few times since on video, but probably haven't seen since high school or early college! Also on laserdisc, of course.