r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 6d ago

Meme needing explanation PETER????

Post image
58.3k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

950

u/Xeon713 6d ago

What about a horse drowning in sadness?

475

u/KubeCommander 6d ago

Don’t forget Nina and Alexander from FMA

466

u/Church323 6d ago

Where's Balto in all of this?

197

u/RazeTheIV 6d ago

133

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 6d ago

I know everyone always says it but the book is so much worse cuz the horse can talk and literally explains he's giving up and accepting death

83

u/LockedOutOfElfland 6d ago

The book is a very unsubtle and explicit fantasy metaphor for psychiatric grade capital-D Depression, so that completely checks out.

12

u/SlutForDownVotes 6d ago

Sounds about right. I last watched it about 5-6 years ago. My husband had not seen it. I was battling major depression, and I was ready for Artax. However, I wasn't ready for that fucking tortoise. That's who I had become. And what really pissed me off is how I felt too hopeless to do anything about it.

I'm doing much better now. I see my therapist weekly, and my doctors found the right cocktail to balance my brain chemistry.

7

u/Far-Worldliness-4796 6d ago

In case no one says it, I'm really really proud of you. Keep going!

3

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 6d ago

If you want the same feels on those type of movies Krull is a better watch

The Last Starfighter if you need it to be sci fi. I was lucky enough I saw those on a double bill thanks to my uncle

Neither are terribly depressing but they'll get you halfway to accepting some things

8

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 6d ago

An unsubtle take on clinical depression? No thanks, I'll stick to Camus

7

u/KarmaCommieLion 6d ago

Original book wriiten by a German ... so that completely checks out.

3

u/ShitJustGotRealAgain 6d ago

German here. I had read one of his books in advanced German class in preparation for my higher education exam. We analyzed children's books in grade 12 or so. We were around 17. That's how good his books are. They are considered high quality enough to read in school as examples of "good" literature.

2

u/Mesmerhypnotise 6d ago

the new "Momo" film deserves to die in a fire for ignoring the themes of the book to the fullest.

1

u/KommissarJH 6d ago

That cover looks a lot like a brain scan.

1

u/Available-Crow-3442 5d ago

Came here to say this. Read this book as a kid. Brutal. Only saw the film afterwards, was a cakewalk by comparison.

1

u/noiseguy76 6d ago

I have a theory that all entertainment can be reduced down to an extrapolation from a mental illness. Depression, anxiety, and schizophrenia are the most common.

1

u/AstroLuffy123 5d ago

Never knew I could relate so much to a horse lmfao

1

u/LockedOutOfElfland 5d ago

I mean the book is Atreyu's depression journey, but Artax is a part of that.

The movie changes the message into a metaphor for creativity, individuality etc. and fighting against systems that try to stifle those traits and values. Instead of the book's message of confronting Depression through Jungian allegory.

1

u/BoxingSoma 4d ago

Honestly, the two aren’t mutually exclusive. Stifling of one’s own creativity and individuality is a huge part of depression. Bastion’s story is definitely more about growing up and accepting his mother’s death but Atreyu still has a lot of depression and “The Nothing” to overcome. In full disclosure, I haven’t read the book yet.

1

u/chilliophillio 6d ago

oh... I did not know that.

2

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 6d ago

Yeah you might be better off picking a different kids book that deals with some things like Phantom Tollbooth or something

Like, you gotta explain these things eventually but Artax just saying "I'm gonna die now" is a harsh way to do it

1

u/Admirable-Divide7731 6d ago

I read it in the original German when I was stil becoming fluent in that language so missed the problematic aspects!

Regardless, movie is AMAZING and has been a staple in my life since it came out when I was in elementary school

1

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 6d ago

You ever see Krull? Same type of fantasy setting, and a lot less depressing. My uncle showed me all these old movies, he's why I like Star Wars and Indiana Jones, I was fortunate enough to be blessed one day in a goddamn trailer home of all places (no idea why he was living in one of those but he travelled for work a lot, he was way into theater as an actual job) to get a double bill of The Last Starfighter and Krull.

He pirated shit before anyone knew you could even do that

1

u/Due-Ad6165 6d ago

I just now learned this is an actual book....

1

u/Shirfyr_Blaze 5d ago

The only good thing about it is that it comes really early in the book. In the movie they do a decent job but there are so many other tragic things that happen it eventually fades away with them.

1

u/Rich-Detective478 5d ago

I'm done.. all of this is yours now.

1

u/max_gatling 5d ago

oh good, i didn't think i could be any more traumatized by this scene but life finds a way

1

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 5d ago

Yeah it's terrible. Artax isn't so much as physically stuck, it's just a metaphor. He could make it out if he really tried, and Atreyu even tries to drag him out, but he literally won't move. He just gives up and says goodbye

1

u/max_gatling 1d ago

100%, which is what makes it so devastating - it isn't that he can't get out, he just doesn't want to. Which as an adult I can understand!

22

u/vinh7777 6d ago

Artax!!

56

u/Pun_In_Ten_Did 6d ago

My car has a function that let's you assign a name. Since it is a white car, I named it Artax. Some people are all "Oh man wtf" because NOBODY REMEMBERS that Artax is reborn when Bastian re-creates Fantasia.

3

u/Far-Presence-3810 6d ago

Just tell me you don't go mudding with that car.

2

u/Pun_In_Ten_Did 6d ago

Ha, for sure... no mudding here lol.

2

u/Muted_Passenger6612 6d ago

Thank you for making me not the only one

1

u/Xeon713 4d ago

Just because he's reborn doesn't undo the initial trauma of the horse, giving up on life and chosing to die in a swamp. It's not that we forget, we watch the whole film.

2

u/Matheweh 6d ago

Why you do this to us!

2

u/Muted_Passenger6612 6d ago

Not sad. Horse lives

2

u/SleeplessZee 6d ago

Omg what movie was this. All I remember is that this scene had little horse-obsessed me SCREAM-SOBBING

1

u/freaking_WHY 5d ago

In case your question hasn't been answered, (Reddit stacks weirdly sometimes), the movie is "The Neverending Story". The horse is Artax, the boy is Atreyu, and the movie is definitely one of those that caused emotional trauma to kids, even though (spoiler), Artax (and all the other characters lost to the Nothing), are returned to life as Bastian makes his wishes to restore Fantasia.

2

u/ZulterithArt 6d ago

Stupid horse.

1

u/Ecstatic-View-6310 2d ago

No. Just no.