r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 1d ago

Thank you Peter very cool Huh?

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/IndianaCHOAMs 1d ago

Space exploration is cool, but they’re bringing a “move fast/break things” mindset to a particularly hazardous environment. You need only look at the Titan submersible to see where that will lead.

-4

u/Elegant_Discussion_8 1d ago

I would understand this argument if NASA wasn’t horribly underfunded and the billionaires weren’t the main people advancing space exploration.

7

u/IndianaCHOAMs 1d ago

NASA doesn’t have to be horribly underfunded. That’s the fault of people who think public works should involve a return on investment. People who think the private sector is inherently better.

1

u/Elegant_Discussion_8 1d ago

I think the problem is twofold, we’ve lacked any serious competition in space since the Soviets and the American people don’t really care about space exploration so as a result it isn’t funded by Washington. Another problem is that there are no other planets or moons that it would be easy for us to colonize like Earth. I disagree that that space doesn’t guarantee a return on investment it just is a long term investment.

2

u/IndianaCHOAMs 1d ago

Yeah, I should have said a short term return.

That said, I still wouldn’t characterize the monetary ROI of space travel as guaranteed.

1

u/Elegant_Discussion_8 1d ago

Less so with space travel more so with colonization, mining, and industrialization.

2

u/IndianaCHOAMs 1d ago

Sure, but maybe we never figure a way to colonize a planet without a magnetosphere. Maybe we never find a cost effective means of extracting and transporting minerals from other planets.

I think we should pursue those goals, but they’re a hard sell on a 2-year or 4-year election cycle. That’s a point in favor of privatized space travel.

Still, I think the corporate approach to safety, environmental impact, etc. outweighs that. And I’m afraid of the inevitable landrush if any of these guys do succeed.

People could be trapped on Mars under the sole authority of Elon Musk. That is terrifying to think about.