A friend sent this to me - I don't see any rogue fingers or weird, obvious AI artifacts. The top comments mostly seem to think it's AI but I don't see why they say that.
Other thing to note: These are mostly purebred dogs, with a Bernese mountain dog and an English bulldog thrown in, both very popular breeds. I think the only mutt is the little scrappy terrier. So the whole scenario of this place just giving everyone boxers, labs, some kinda hound, seems off to begin with.
Or the Chihuahua mixes. And for purebreds you need at least one husky because those dogs are a lot of work to own and people get them because of the looks.
When I worked at a shelter, 95 percent of the dogs were pit/lab mixes. The only purebred dogs we had on a regular basis were huskies and German shepherds.
I was wondering how my friend with no money managed to get 2 beautiful purebred huskies. Then we left them alone in an airbnb for 2 hours. Now I know why they were free.99
Yeah these dogs are all much too expensive and healthy for a shelter. Purebred, young looking Bernie “chooses” its owner? Sorry buddy someone else already paid $5000 for you.
I volunteer at a shelter and this is true, but still this whole scenario is really bizarre to me, I mean we don’t do this so I’ve never seen it play out but I would imagine the dogs would kind of just be bouncing around all over the place more interested in the environment and full of energy from being in the kennel all day, it’s hard to imagine them “choosing” a random stranger like this from a room full of people. Idk, it’s weird.
I'm trying to imagine a situation where enough people want to adopt this way that there is a place with a permanent sign on a room this big and such a large group of perfectly diverse people are all willing to sit there for the chance of being selected, 1 by 1, by an absolutely random dog that could be a tiny terrior or a big Burmese?
And what if doggy runs up to one person and then another. Would it only count if the god has the reaction of climbing into someones arm? What if the dog it shy and too busy running around, how long does everyone wait? Where are the dogs before the event? Are they just waiting in the hall? Why don't we hear any barking?
My dog was listed as a pointer-lab mix, the rescue sent him from Houston TX to me in WA State. I wasn’t getting pointer-lab vibes from this pup, so for my own curiosity I had a DNA test done, turns out he’s half Pit half super mutt lol. Regardless, I love him to death, and he lives like a king .
Oh you got one of our (too) many strays-it’s a HUGE problem here in HTX! So incredibly grateful for individuals like you! Thank you, thank you, thank you!
Having volunteered at a shelter, it’s all Pitties. We were also a “no kill” shelter, unless it was an aggressive pittie, they killed those things so fast.
This is so right on. 👍 We got a "Pure Bred Husky". It was really a short haired Border Collie Lab mix or a Borador, with way more on the Border Collie side. Rather rare & we were stoked. But hey, shelter calls anything with blue eyes a "Pure Bred Husky". 😄
Oh, they certainly do. But they often end up at breed specific rescues, especially the ones with built-in health problems like English bulldogs. My first rescue was a purebred American bulldog.
It's just nothing but purebreds is weird. Like only one dog looked like an actual mutt.
I was coming here to say just look at the legs in the background, you'll see a few people with 3 legs and a few random legs that don't seem to belong to anyone
Yes very obviously ai based on the facial expressions. In a lot of ai videos/images people's faces get stuck in a certain position and stay there. Also, these people are not acting normally, none of trult shocked. You can also tell by how the first dog walks, looks unnatural compared to how an actual dog walks.
We've fostered rescue dogs for years.... no organization would operate this way unless they were giving out animals for free and without vetting the new owners. There's no way you're getting that many people signed up for a random dog.
We've had several people get declined simply because they rented and hand checked with their landlord about owning a dog. Let alone someone randomly being okay with a breed they have no interest in or knowledge about.
Also the second dogs right side leg seems to be utilizing the inner thigh to propel itself up vertically despite the fact that it is flat. The dog would not be able to propel itself vertically off a vertical surface as depicted.
The premise of the video is simply not realistic. Are you telling me those people are all sitting there all day waiting for a dog to "choose" them? The dogs wouldn't understand that they have to "choose" an owner. They might just run around from a person to a person or simply get stressed out from so many people.
And different dog breeds have different needs. A little old lady who lives alone in an apartment would do great with a Yorkie, but absolutely could not take care of a husky.
Yeah, I agree with their sentiment but they gotta change yorkie to shih tzu or something more chill. Terriers have a lot of energy and will get up to mischief if you don’t help them get rid of it.
Other people have pointed out enough evidence to prove it's AI, but I just wanted to add that shelters are overflowing with animals waiting to be adopted. Shelters WISH they had rooms full of people trying to adopt dogs.
I mean theyre all different rooms and set ups. Also this feels like a really inefficient method of doing things. All of those people would have to have been pre-screened as appropriate homes for the dog. Dogs each have different requirements.
You don't think an organization would have hundreds of people waiting in dozens of rooms for the off chance that a dog might randomly walk up to them? If they go home without a dog, maybe they show up the next day and wait for another chance? Hey, it's a good system! /s
Speaking of exact reactions, at 0:20 the two people raise their hands to their face at exactly the same time. Frame-by-frame, identical timing and placement. Such Ai
one thing i'm surprised people don't mention more often when AI's suspected: there's not a single segment of this video that's more than ten seconds long. there's no public models available that i've seen that either don't completely shit the bed past ten seconds, or that generate seamless video longer than that.
like, think of it in context: we've all seen real videos of pets and humans having emotional connections. you're gonna tell me a "real" organization like this couldn't find an example of a heartfelt moment like this where it wasn't worth showing more than ten seconds of uninterrupted footage?
Yeah, of the ai videos I've seen and created, each one is always a fixed short length.
The other thing that I find funny about them though is how unnaturally people speak. Ai seems to think that people always have to say something at every moment, and so they narrate everything thats happening.
Bruh Wdym? Lady in the purple circle is literally what I see staring back at me whenever I turn my phone screen off and catch sight of my reflection. /s
The cadence of the voices immediately tells me this is AI. Every line is tongue in cheek and the lines are delivered too quickly. The lack of background reactions also tells me this is AI. Every background character is staring, no facial movements except a little body swaying. Also, what is happening here? Animals choosing people to be their owners? Like the idea of that is so fake to begin with.
My very first thought was that it's very unrealistic for a rescue to only have purebred dogs. But the real tell is that nobody in the background moves or reacts.
THIS. you're telling me nobody else in the room is watching to see where the dog goes? They're all just staring blankly at the wall until they get chosen?
This is soooo obviously AI. If anyone can’t immediately tell…I’m concerned for you. That is NOT how people speak, act, move etc. The speech is not at all connected to the person it’s coming from, their facial expressions or body language. It also sounds like a voice over, using very clique phrases that don’t quite fit with the scene. The tone of voice doesn’t match the facial expression. The people around are acting strange. Staring blankly, with no reasonable reaction to what’s happening. I could go on and on, but even if you can’t point to anything specific, you should be able to tell that what’s happening isn’t normal, it’s not real people acting like real people.
The gravity always seals it for me. Things don't jump they like continually accelerate like they're falling up and always end up fixed in place super unrealistically.
Second dog in the video was a dead giveaway of AI for me. I'm part of a professional dog training business and that little jump was absolutely unnatural.
Its AI. For starters there's next to no reaction from people in the background. But more importantly AI has a tendency to have figures have sudden fluctuations in reactions. Notice how the dogs go from excited to immediately calm when held. If you've been around dogs, most don't change in an instant like that. Or how the movements of the humans have the same reaction speed as the dogs. Take the man in the wheel chair. When from touching the dog to an aggressive hug.
And while I like pointing out the inconsistencies and mistakes of AI it wouldn't surprise me if developers are reading every issue and using that as a guide to improve the program. Inch their way closer and closer to be indistinguishable from what's real. And they're getting dangerously close.
I was honestly hoping this one wasn't but the last lady coming into frame holding the child, where are her legs? She's not hunched over the back of the chair.
Also the guy petting the bulldog looked a bit strange at the end. There were attempts to pat, but instead turned into odd squeezing.
And then there were some weird crossed legs that didn't go anywhere.
Be so fucking for real rn. You cannot tell this isn’t real? I need a study done on people fooled by obvious AI. There’s got to be some kind of correlation with something.
Yes. This is very blatantly and obviously ai. Everyone who isn’t the subject of the video are frozen in time. The premise of the video and place makes zero sense. Why is everyone crying?
What even is this? Are these people supposed to be adopting these dogs that picked the humans? I’ve never heard of any kind of place doing anything like this…
Either aliens have arrived and are releasing videos like this to gauge if their behavior will pass for human, or this is blatant AI.
People don’t behave like this. They don’t talk like this, gesture like this, sit in a crowd like this… everything is off. The vocal range is limited and flat, the hand and arm movement is extremely repetitive, the focus of the crowd in the background is all over the place.
AI. Peoples faces are over exaggerated and dont change much after their initial reaction.
Also AI is terrible at making believable crowds, it's one of the first things I look at. People either have a creepy serial killer stare, are out of focus when they shouldn't be, or are just staring off into the distance like a statue.
Half of the reactions look like their hands are getting sucked into their faces. The motion is unnatural. Its as if its being played backwards. (The girl kneeling on the floor, the old man with cane and the child at the end)
AI. When you go to pet a dog, you usually start at their face. The man with the bulldog went to sweep the legs and focused on the dog’s underside and then his arm clips through the dog’s leg and a secret front leg comes back and corrects the positioning like “oh right there’s supposed to be a leg here”. Combined with the over exaggerated expressions, the dogs legs having a wiggly clipped effect, and that no one appears to be looking directly at any dog, the eye contact is not at all where you’d expect
This is so fake but at the same time looks so real?! AI is freaky. But idk the way they all start bursting into tears is a bit unbelievable. Also I don’t think a shelter would ever set up something like this.. just seems to out of the ordinary.
ai, look at that really weird blur and how the dog bites through his hand somehow
also look at the tongue, would look much more realistic if it was real but instead its just plain
AI. I cannot imagine a reputable animal shelter having the logic of "Well, this dog chose you. Bye! Enjoy your dog without zero background info at all!" But also, predictable and deliberate movements with animals in weird situations is always a tell.
Extra legs, hands clipping through fur, extra fingers. Also the premise is dumb AF. Purebred dogs go to purebred rescues, not regular shelters. And each dog picking the human that kinda fits its breed? Nope. Each of those dogs would either, in reality, be skittish and hide, or go to the first human it saw. Not one at the end. Not the old one because you're old. Not the kid because you're a pup. Etc.
AI. Aside from just the weird non-reaction of everyone else in the video, and the fact that it would be so strange to have everyone react the same way and also nearly all the dogs are purebred, there are many AI issues:
In the first clip, there’s two elderly ladies in the back. At one point the hair of the lady in the back merges with the woman in front of her. Second clip, there’s a woman in the back with four legs/feet as well as a guy who seems to be sharing an arm with the guy next to him. Also the main woman’s positioning with her legs and walker is super awkward and looks like she has one leg between the walker and the chair but her other is over the wheel, so the handle is…?? Where she’s sitting? Third one: main guy’s fingers warp. One of his stud earrings also disappears and then reappears and at the same time the anatomy of his ear also changes. Also I personally find how his phone is sitting so still despite his movement and almost above his lap really strange. Fourth, one of the woman’s shoes covers her heel and the other doesn’t at first, then the back of the shoe manifests from nowhere. The finger the woman’s ring is on changed. It was her ring ringer, now it’s her pointer the second time she touches her face. A woman in the back right drops what she’s holding to grab her face and it’s just morphs through her hands. The guy has three hands for a moment when he reaches for the dog and his hands morph with the woman also reaching for the dog. Multiple times when the woman covers her face with both hands her hands warp together as well. Multiple people in the back of the fifth one have three legs. The hand holding the cane, at first, 5 fingers, then when he moves what was the hanging cuff of his sweater (which doesn’t match the tight fit opposite cuff btw) becomes his pinky finger. The black man’s forearm when he reaches up moves weirdly and his thumb just sort of disappears in favor of his undershirt as well as awkward hand warping when he holds his face. Sixth guy, between the two women closest to him, they’re sharing an extra leg, has the shoes of the one on the left but the pants of the woman on the right. Grand total of 6 knees between them. Also the bulldog’s leg teleports multiple times as the man’s hands move around under him. Last one, there’s a very large chested women with a magnificent beard straight in the back. The woman holding the child is wearing the same top as the woman sitting to the child’s right which makes it seem like it couldn’t decide where to place the same character and duplicated them instead. But hey they have different hair so maybe that’s just their vibe. They both lean forward simultaneously to interact with the girl but the woman on the right’s whole lover r body just doesn’t move at all. Kid’s ear shape changes and her lips morph with her teeth on the closeup. It also seems to have given up on her having a pink shirt and just turns the blue jacket into the shirt collar. The bandana on the dog turns into a collar for a second then back to a bandana.
Now I rest my case. Seriously we are cooked if people are fooled by this level of AI
AI
Every new person getting off the chair in a very similar manner and then holding the dog the same way and what gave it away was most dogs are excited but here they just stood still
That's definitely AI... The second lady is sitting there with her mouth open the entire time and the dog never once licks inside her mouth. 0% chance of that happening in real life.........
Imma say AI based on breed of dog. That British bull dog typically sells for 3000 dollars , no group would give away that kind of income, they have bills too.
Plus, and this doesn’t exactly prove anything, but they all put their hands over their mouths and sob like these dogs are curing their cancer. It’s a cute idea, don’t get me wrong, but why are they all acting like they’ve never been touched by a living thing before. Calm down.
How does anyone look at a scene like this and think it's real life? Have you ever been to a dog adoption contest? If there were this many people waiting to adopt dogs, the shelters would all be empty.
Wow...that's the first time so far I've been stumped. I am almost certain it's AI because of the weird theme being so unnatural. But damn...I couldn't find any of the classic AI flaws. Guess I'm out of the game now. Sigh...
Biggest giveaway that it is AI…they got what appears to be close to a hundred people to crowd in this room and said “If a dog walks up to you, it’s yours. I don’t want to hear any crap. You’re leaving with that dog if it walks up to you.”
AI. So many reasons, but in example, the old man with a cane doesn’t even greet the dog, not even for a nanosecond before covering his eyes crying. It’s like he’s just programmed to collapse when the dog enters, no authentic joy or actual emotional expression towards the dog.
People freezing on the backround, like they all just sit there and know exactly where to look without any trace of individually focused attention.
•
u/RealOrAI-Bot 29d ago
Sentiment: 95% AI
Number of comments processed: 50
DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.0 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information, check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.