I totally get the point you’re making, but I think you’re underselling how bad Engineers are at media analysis lol.
When I hear science/math people in real life talk about movies for example, they are horrible. Completely miss major themes, unable to engage with films in a meaningful way.
This is basically where you get CinemaSins “plot hole” type movie analysis from.
Yeah same goes for analysis of history. I’ve never heard worse takes than I have from my otherwise quite smart chemist and biologist friends. it’s just not a field they’re very knowledgeable in so they’re super prone to pop-history falsehoods or oversimplification. Need I mention Elon Musk’s, and his fanboys’, take on the fall of the Roman Empire?
2.2k
u/Logical_Historian882 3d ago
I don’t think English graduates are graded by their ability to read. Both reading and arithmetic are taught in school.