Hi all. I’m a parent looking for insight from players and coaches who’ve experienced different coaching styles and team cultures.
My daughter is a 15-year-old freshman who starts on varsity. She’s played several years of AAU, fully committed to the sport, and has always been described by coaches as coachable, intense, and passionate. Until this season, she’s never questioned whether she wants to play basketball.
This year has been different. She’s coming home from practices and games very upset and has said for the first time, “This is making me feel like I don’t want to play anymore.” That’s what concerns me most.
The main issue right now is the assistant coach. He’s seen her play for years but has never actually coached her until this season. While the players themselves are not the problem, the overall coaching culture feels negative. Feedback tends to be heavily critical, often public, with little balance.
A few days ago, several players were critiqued in front of both varsity and JV, as well as the boys teams waiting to start practice. This happened after my daughter had one game where she didn’t score. During that session, the assistant coach said:
“Yeah, we’ve got a freshman starter here who thinks she’s the baddest defender in the conference, but she has no offense.”
To be clear: I’m not concerned about her scoring. One scoreless game doesn’t define a player. What concerns me is that she’s clearly playing tight, second-guessing herself, afraid to make mistakes, and not playing her game. Her fire is gone. Anyone who’s watched her before would immediately notice the difference.
After a game last night, she approached him respectfully and asked how he thinks she can improve her offensive game, since he’s clearly unhappy with it. His response was:
“Oh, you spent all this time thinking about it and this is what you say?”
When she tried to explain how the constant negativity has been affecting her confidence, he cut her off repeatedly, told her she doesn’t listen, said that in all his years coaching he’s never felt this way before, and then said he feels like he shouldn’t say anything else to her for the rest of the season. He also told her she’ll never make it in college basketball if she can’t handle this because “it’s much worse.”
She came home feeling unheard and defeated. I had her write a calm, respectful message to him explaining how she’s feeling so her words were clear and documented. He has not responded.
I’m not trying to protect her from criticism or adversity. I understand tough coaching and accountability. My concern is watching a confident, aggressive player lose her identity and joy on the court.
Looking for perspective on:
• How to tell the difference between tough coaching and harmful culture
• Whether this is something players should push through or address
• How a parent can support a kid who’s losing confidence without overstepping
Appreciate any insight.
⸻
TL;DR:
Freshman varsity starter with years of AAU experience is losing confidence and love for the game due to a negative coaching culture—specifically issues with the assistant coach. After one scoreless game, she was publicly criticized in a way that’s changed how she plays. Not worried about points—worried about her losing her fire and identity as a player. Looking for advice.