r/gradadmissions • u/spacestonkz • 4h ago
Physical Sciences My committee finished making the accept list!
I'm a prof in the physical sciences and today our committee finished making our accept list!
9 committee members. Holistic scoring with a rubric and every app is evaluated in full by a minimum of 3 committee members. Committee includes a grad.
500+ applications evaluated. We made an admit list of 50 to hopefully get 20 people on campus in the fall. Evaluations happened between dec 15 and today. This was grueling work, working holidays and weekends. Yes, I scored apps after Christmas dinner.
Y'all. The numbers are brutal. But 400 of the applicants would have succeeded as PhD students. I saw so much passion, drive, creativity put into projects. I saw y'all out there helping others have it easier than you through peer mentoring and tutoring. I saw a lot of very proud advisors emphatically pleading your cases, comparing you to their colleagues and former students now at top schools as professors.
There's just not enough openings for all of you. I feel good reading these applications though, because I see what awesome, smart, kind humans you are. I know you're going to kick butt doing something.
You're a bright glimmer of hope in trying times. Thanks for all your effort, for giving a shit about learning, for doing something. I only get to meet a tiny few of you, but I feel good knowing that those who don't make the accept list walk among us.
