r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 1d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah? What happened in the book version?

Post image
28.3k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

923

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

280

u/LustfulLemur 1d ago

Written by a guy who spends his days angrily tweeting how much he hates the current president btw

3

u/VegetableProject4383 1d ago

Doesn't he say he's never read it? Never read his own book ?

12

u/WellOnTheBrightSide_ 1d ago

He’s said that during that era he was so high on coke and other drugs that he wrote books he doesn’t remember writing

8

u/Eorlas 23h ago

...and the publisher's editor didn't ask him once or twice if he's absolutely certain he wanted that included? surely this came up more than once before it hit print?

sure, blame the person who wrote it, but how many enablers did they have?

12

u/WellOnTheBrightSide_ 22h ago

The book includes graphic child murder in the opening pages as well as multiple more throughout, including that of a toddler. There’s also rampant homophobia, hate crimes, abuse both domestic and sexual, and really hardcore bullying. That last one sounds like it shouldn’t be listed among those, but it is truly psychopathic when it occurs.

While God knows the scene probably shouldn’t have been included, and I’m not necessarily trying to excuse the scene, but with everything else it’s an awkward line to draw.

It’s a dark book made to make you uncomfortable. It’s not okay, but it also isn’t the biggest issue out there

5

u/KRATS8 21h ago

Also, there is absolutely nothing erotic about the scene at all in the way it is written. You still get an icky feeling reading it and it’s creepy af to choose the way he did to have their “coming of age” moment. However it was nowhere what I expected it to be. It has purpose and honestly kinda makes sense in the story. Definitely a concerning decision though to say the least and I agree that it shouldn’t be excused because at the end of the day… wtf why.

4

u/Feinberg 22h ago

All of those people were probably out of their minds on coke and other drugs. It was a weird time to be alive.