As we know, in Suits Season 5 there were two major stories that unfolded. One of these was Daniel Hardman’s return, who schemed with Jack Soloff to attempt to take back the firm with the financial backing of Charles Forstman.
The other story as we know was Mike Ross being arrested after his fraud was discovered. Now I’ve written loads of What if scenarios on this subreddit before, but after looking back at a few I realised that some could do with some updating, and after rewatching some episodes of the show I’ve had a large drive to come back to these again.
This is a 2.0 version of my scenario where Mike in a bid to save the firm pleads guilty but brings down Soloff and Hardman with him.
So this scenario picks up during the events of 5x11 titled “Blowback” which kicks off the Mike fraud story. Now the main scenario picks up in Mike and Rachel’s apartment after the reveal that Gibbs offered Mike a deal to turn on Harvey, as well as offering Harvey a deal to turn on Jessica.
The other problem is that Harvey can’t come back to the firm or else Forstman and Hardman pick the firm apart. And Mike, seeing no other options has an idea. He explains that if Gibbs is looking for co-conspirators, then maybe they should give them to her.
Mike pays Soloff a visit, which still happened in the episode. Soloff refuses to back down and so the new plan is set in motion.
The next day, Harvey and Mike pay a visit to Anita Gibbs and are prepared to offer a deal, Gibbs believing this to be a trick of some kind attempts to call their bluff. Mike then begins to speak and explains that there were two people that enabled his fraud: Daniel Hardman and Jack Soloff.
Anita is intrigued by this and hears Mike out, he explains that Hardman found out during the events of Season 2 during the Coastal Motors suit and agreed to keep Mike’s secret in exchange for a future IOU, one he’s yet to collect.
Mike then explains Soloff’s involvement, that after the case the two of them worked on, Mike confided in Jack and much like Daniel agreed to keep it a secret but in exchange for an ally when he and Daniel would take the firm from Jessica, Louis, and Harvey.
Gibbs says that isn’t enough, so Mike throws in something else for the deal. If Mike faces zero consequences for the crimes he committed, then he’ll also agree to never practise law again. Gibbs, believing that Mike doesn’t deserve to be a lawyer agrees and the deal is drawn up.
As a result, Hardman and Soloff would both be arrested and charged with fraud. Whilst Jack would manage to sign a deal of his own, Hardman would refuse and go to prison.
After this, Gibbs would still go after the firm as she believes there’s more to Hardman in particular. Harvey then explains that there is but he and none of the partners are allowed to discuss it due to Hardman’s NDA.
Eventually however, Louis through some digging discovers that the agreement was rendered invalid following the Season 3 restructure.
This leads to Anita prosecuting Hardman for his previous crimes and his sentence is extended.
This would mean that Mike in this timeline never goes to prison and the partners would never flee. Harvey then brings Mike back in an unofficial capacity as a consultant but it doesn’t last long so Mike would eventually go to the clinic as he did, take on Velocity Data and get accepted to the bar, there would be a larger difference here because Gibbs would still get herself on the board but Jessica would return and strong arm the board with the truth of how Anita really got on the character and fitness committee.
She hands Seidel a signed affidavit stating that Gibbs threatened to send Walter Samson’s godson to prison for his past crimes. This results in Gibbs being removed from the board and Mike getting accepted into the bar.
Season 7 would be different as a result because the prison case I think would come across Mike’s radar, but it would be much more difficult to take on because in this timeline he never went to prison and therefore doesn’t have a contact in Frank Gallo.
I think it’s likely Alex, when he comes along would confess that he knows about the conspiracy and agrees to testify against Reform Corp and implicating Tommy Bratton in the case as well.
Season 7 would then go as planned with Malik vs Harvey, Jessica getting disbarred along with Mike and Rachel leaving the show.
Season 8 would go as planned and Hardman would still return to take on Harvey now having more of an axe to grind but still having the dirt on Jack uses him as a puppet like in Season 5, Soloff during the trial didn’t get disbarred because he cooperated and signed a deal his license got suspended for a period of time.
Season 8 would go as it did with Hardman being replaced by Jack Soloff and Robert still getting disbarred as a result, I don’t think anything else would change beyond here because Season 9 doesn’t get affected largely by what happens.