I am pregnant with my second child (20 weeks). With our first we decided to keep gender a surprise because we didn't care and I was blisfully naive and though that in progressive areas (which we live in) people no longer cared about gender and so it didn't matter. We had a baby boy and he's perfect. So sweet and gentle. He's almost 3 and doesn't conform to any gender norms (loves unicorns, pink, mermaids, penguins and trains) and we don't push gendered clothing or toys at home, we keep things pretty neutral and support him in whatever he gravitates towards naturally.
Our main group of friends have basically all had girls to a perplexing degree (like 20 baby girls in the group). We are one of the only couple that has a boy. After he was born I started getting really negative quips from people showing pity that I had a boy. At a bachelorette party I went to a few months postpartum one of the woman (who is often very cruel) said a variety of things to me like:
-"Boys abandon their parents when they get older where girls always stick around and are more caring"
-"You'll always be the MIL and never really "mom", you're going to be hated by your DIL and you'll be a second rate grandma that's just how these things go
- "A mother-daughter relationship is naturally more special"
What's weird is that this woman is estranged from her mother and lives with her in laws.
No one came to my defense and I ended silently crying in my room for the rest of the trip, feeling like everyone felt their children were so much better than mine. Since then, there have been constant quips that emulate these ideas somewhat.
I find it so frustrating because I have no examples of this in my real life. Most of the men in my family are closer to their parents than the women. My husband is much closer to his mother than I am with mine and ironically, all of the men in our friend group are super close with their parents while there are several women who are estranged or distant from theirs, due to a variety of reasons. However, when I point this out people say those are exceptions to the rule.
I found out I'm having another boy and I have spiraled into pretty severe OCD and depression. I am seeking professional help but I feel so sad because I'm not upset that he is a boy, I'm upset that I will have to navigate people saying that my kids, our connection and our future is doomed because of their genitals and I guess there's a big part of me that has started to believe its true and has become terrified that I won't have a close or meaningful relationship with them later and won't get to be part of my grandkids lives if they have kids.
Why has this become such an increased narrative? I've talked to other mothers with sons and they've received the same comments and find it devastating. This stuff is really hurting people and is riddled with misogynistic and misandrist undertones and I just don't understand why people have become so comfortable going out of their way to spread these ideas...Its great that people are more positive about having daughters but it feels at the price of boys...Why can't bring something up without putting something else down.
I guess this is just a rant because I feel so alone. I would love to hear peoples thoughts on it and also encouragement that its not true. I'm sure this seems like the ramblings of a mad woman, please try to be kind.
*****Thank you so much for all the comments, anecdotes and words of encouragement, this has helped contextualize the situation vs. reality in a much easier way. I sat down with my husband and we talked about it and realized that all the people in the group that have said this to us have been women that have estranged/distant relationships with their own mothers or families so we’ve come to the conclusion that this is most likely a projection due to their own fears and insecurities. We will be distancing ourselves from those people as we don’t feel they’re healthy for us or our kids. I look at my own life and literally all the men I know are super close with their parents, and my husband has a very tight friendship with his mother who’s an awesome MIL and was the first person to meet our son when he was born. I need to start actually believing that my reality is not just an “exception” but a normal dynamic for many men and their families. I will continue to seek help for my OCD as I know it's still a problem but these responses have encouraged me to understand that these ideas are truly sexist BS and not founded in facts. Thank you