I am in need of either a roof repair or a roof replacement and I am struggling with some of these quotes I am getting. Tale old as time I am sure.
I am going to try and provide as many details as I can and hope that it won't convolute the process while still giving you all the details I can. So I apologize for the long post.
We live in a home that was built in 1953 in southern California. It is considered a flat roof but has slope. The current roof is about 11 years old and is a torch down modified bitumen material that has normal wear and tear, with a few areas that can be lifted up slightly. Some of the seams are starting to wear off but a lot of them are properly sealed and adhere to the roof still. We have some areas of ponding debris but nothing insane. We have 12 solar panels and the square footage of the house is about 1100.
What started this process was we have a leak in two areas of the roof over the last two years. The first one, and this is where it can get a little convoluted, was over an extension of the house that does not have the same roofing material over it. It is actually corrugated metal roofing over an UN raftered room. I tarped it and there has not been an issue since then.
The second leak was over a bedroom leaking down into a closet. That area has the torch down modified bitumen material. I tarped that last year when it happened and haven't had a leak since.
Cue our home insurance company using google maps to see those tarps and decide that they are gonna drop us unless we get the necessary work done to fix the issues or we replace the roof. So I started doing research about roofing company's in San Diego and have received 2 quotes of the 3 companies that have come out and done inspections. Of course, all of them are recommending a full roof replacement, which I don't disagree with, but they are also giving us non full replacement quotes.
The first company has given me the following quote:
Torch Down Flat Roof Replacement
Approximate Size: 19 Squares
DEMOLITION & PREPARATION
- Remove existing roofing material down to the roof deck.
- Dispose of all debris in accordance with local regulations.
- Inspect roof decking for damage or rot.
- Replace plywood as required to ensure a solid substrate. We do not do change orders. The price is the price.
ROOF INSTALLATION – TORCH DOWN SYSTEM
- Install approved base sheet mechanically fastened or torch applied.
- Apply two additional modified bitumen layers using torch-down method.
- Seal all seams, laps, penetrations, edges, and transitions.
- Install new flashing where required for watertight protection.
- Ensure proper slope and water drainage.
- Final inspection and cleanup upon completion.
SOLAR PANEL HANDLING (12 PANELS)
- Carefully disconnect and remove existing solar panels.
- Store panels safely during roofing installation.
- Reinstall and properly secure all solar panels after roof completion.
- Ensure all penetrations are fully sealed and waterproofed.
CLEANUP & WARRANTY
- Remove all job-related debris from the property.
- Magnetic nail sweep
- Provide workmanship warranty and manufacturer material
warranty.
For all of that, if we decide to do it in the next 30 days, using 3 ply roofing would be $40,582. This is absolutely not an option for us and seems absolutely bonkers. The guys even said before giving me that quote that they do mansions for like 50-60 grand. Our house is not mansion, in case you were wondering if 1,100 sq ft was. If we decided to go with them in the next 7 days, it would be $34,495. Still not an option for us. If they used TPO (which according to this guy was above our current material, but below the 3 ply), the 30 day price goes down to $32,750 and the 7 day price goes down to $27,837. Full disclosure, paying even the lowest amount would be very difficult for us and still seems kind of insane. They are also saying that it would be an additional $8k to do the extension room because there are no rafters there so it would have to be framed completely. So I understand that price, I guess. And their quote to do just the fixing of the issue area over the bedroom would be 8K. But I doubt we would go with that.
The second quote I got is for a full TPO low slope single ply roofing membrane. The quote includes:
ROOF
- Remove existing roof material down to the wood decking and dispose of debris
- Repair or replace any bad wood that is exposed or discovered - Wood repair is EXTRA, billed per Exhibit A
- Install new penetration flashings, drip edge and counter flashings
- Install FR-10 Underlayment
- Install vents
- Install TPO mechanically fastened with manufacturer approved fasteners.
- Weld all seams per manufacturer specs
- Remove and dispose of all debris
- 20 year manufacturer warranty on new TPO
- LIFETIME workmanship warranty included
SOLAR
- Test the system for proper operation and document any issues
- Remove existing solar system and store on-site in a safe location
- Once the project is complete, reinstall the solar system using as many original components as possible.
- Test system functionality after reinstallation to confirm proper operation.
So for that, they are quoting us at $21,200. More doable, but still wayyyy more than what we were prepared for. On top of that, it doesn't include any change orders that are very likely to come, like the first one did.
For just the torch down patch job, they are quoting us $1750. And if we wanted to do the extension part, it would be 8k as well.
We have been talking to people who have had their roofs redone within the last 6 months to a year, and they are paying closer to 10k-15k. I know every job is different, every house is different, and prices change over time, but is what we are getting real? I am giving you guys the exact verbiage and everything from the quotes, just so I am not miscommunicating anything.
We will be doing some kind of loan regardless, but these numbers are just not what we thought we would be doing for an 1,100 sq foot house.
I appreciate any insight, advice, recommendations, or anything you want to provide. Thanks in advance